SA Footy

Can someone confirm if Biglands has in fact suffered another ligament tear and requires a full knee reconstruction?

The Crows were asked to speak on 5AA tonight re Rhett but declined due to waiting on test results

Hope all is OK

There never the same knees, if your a ruckman.
The crows know he's finished for 2008 before it started.

NO-MERCY wrote:There never the same knees, if your a ruckman.
The crows know he's finished for 2008 before it started.

my concern was always, his damaged knee was his left knee, this is his jumping leg, even when fit may of struggled to regain his leap

And given the severity of Henschell's injury he may never recover properly too, the same with Eichner at the PAMs....

The advancement in rehab over teh past 10 years has been significant but as when there is severe trauma to the surrounding connective tissue, menisci and in Henschell's case the medial ligament well you face a hard road back....

As if Biglands was any good to start with. Blackbirds screwed whether he's fit or not.

regards,

REB

Crows took the gamble by not signing Hudson....funny how Karma works....3 ACL's from their ruckmen in 3 years

Biglands injury only a 4-6 week one, according to 5AA. No reco required.

Dutchy wrote:Crows took the gamble by not signing Hudson....funny how Karma works....3 ACL's from their ruckmen in 3 years

Its 1995-96 all over again...remind me how '97 went....

1980 Tassie Medalist wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Crows took the gamble by not signing Hudson....funny how Karma works....3 ACL's from their ruckmen in 3 years

Its 1995-96 all over again...remind me how '97 went....

Forget '97, just remind me about '95....

Rik E Boy wrote:As if Biglands was any good to start with. Blackbirds screwed whether he's fit or not.

Dutchy wrote:Crows took the gamble by not signing Hudson....funny how Karma works....3 ACL's from their ruckmen in 3 years

IMO Karma would be Hudson doing his knee again !

Felch wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Crows took the gamble by not signing Hudson....funny how Karma works....3 ACL's from their ruckmen in 3 years

IMO Karma would be Hudson doing his knee again !

Why?

Rushby Hinds wrote:

Felch wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Crows took the gamble by not signing Hudson....funny how Karma works....3 ACL's from their ruckmen in 3 years

IMO Karma would be Hudson doing his knee again !

Why?

Sh!tting on his team-mates !!!

And before i get hounded down, i do know for a FACT that some of his team-mates feel this way.

Felch wrote:

Rushby Hinds wrote:

Felch wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Crows took the gamble by not signing Hudson....funny how Karma works....3 ACL's from their ruckmen in 3 years

IMO Karma would be Hudson doing his knee again !

Why?

Sh!tting on his team-mates !!!

And before i get hounded down, i do know for a FACT that some of his team-mates feel this way.

Well of course they are. You suppose Jimmy Allen's old VFL team mates were happy that he left for a better offer in the SANFL?

No big loss if Biglands goes down this year, we will struggle to make the eight so I would like to see Maric and Griffin given a good go as the ruck combo

Probably not Rushby.

Not sure how this relates to my karma comment though ??? I did say 'IMO'.

story from adelaidenow http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/stor ... 28,00.html

Felch wrote:Probably not Rushby.

Not sure how this relates to my karma comment though ??? I did say 'IMO'.

Ok, so you are saying that "IMO" means that probably everyone else will disagree with you?


In that case you are very correct.

IMO.

Rushby Hinds wrote:

Felch wrote:Probably not Rushby.

Not sure how this relates to my karma comment though ??? I did say 'IMO'.

Ok, so you are saying that "IMO" means that probably everyone else will disagree with you?


In that case you are very correct.

IMO.

No, i meant that i dont really care if anyone disagrees with me.

But nice guess anyway, IMO