Page 1 of 1
The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 6:54 pmby Benchwarmer
Pick 3, 20 and Josh Kennedy
Things change ... that was "insufficient" in the eyes of Trevor Nisbett two weeks ago
Welcome to the clan, Juddy!
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 6:58 pmby sydney-dog
lets hope so, it may open the door for more trades
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 7:00 pmby NFC
IMO, average trade for the Eagles but there's probably not a lot they can do.
Pick 3 is quality, Kennedy was a high pick but there are a lot of doubts surrounding him, and pick 20 is average.
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 7:05 pmby sydney-dog
maybe from next year clubs might be able to draft future picks, this would allow a club to draft a future first round pick and provide a fair system
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 7:25 pmby sydney-dog
other reports say Kennedy met with Wosha today and Josh is still undecided on a move to WA
If Josh says No, and the Blues miss out on Judd, would Josh want to stay at Carlton, the members and supporters would string him up
Unfair pressure on the Kid
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 7:27 pmby NFC
sydney-dog wrote:other reports say Kennedy met with Wosha today and Josh is still undecided on a move to WA
If Josh says No, and the Blues miss out on Judd, would Josh want to stay at Carlton, the members and supporters would string him up
Unfair pressure on the Kid
The whole thing is ridiculous. If Carlton can't do a deal, will he walk into the PSD to Richmond?
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 8:08 pmby gadj1976
NFC wrote:sydney-dog wrote:other reports say Kennedy met with Wosha today and Josh is still undecided on a move to WA
If Josh says No, and the Blues miss out on Judd, would Josh want to stay at Carlton, the members and supporters would string him up
Unfair pressure on the Kid
The whole thing is ridiculous. If Carlton can't do a deal, will he walk into the PSD to Richmond?
see the other threads on this too. yes, but Carlton have said they'd pay him $2mill for one year to gazump Richmond.
The Australian states "Carlton will hand over 20-year-old Kennedy and pick 3 and 20 in the pre-season draft for the Eagles captain who quit the club last month to return to Melbourne".
Pre season draft picks, ba bow! National Draft perhaps.
Edit : Carltonfc.com.au states "No change as Judd talks continue" as a headline, 5.34pm 10/10
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Wed Oct 10, 2007 10:06 pmby Pup
Not official yet but very likely to happen tomorrow.
Josh has been given the night to sleep on it and decide if he wants to move to WA and play for WCE. I feel for him.
Either way, if he comes to WCE he will be welcomed with open arms.
3 and 20 and JK doesnt make me happy but at least it is something. Probably get Cotchin or Masten.
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Thu Oct 11, 2007 1:17 amby brod
Josh has stated all along that he wishes to stay in victoria, dont know what another nights sleep will do to change his mind
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Thu Oct 11, 2007 8:51 amby Rik E Boy
brod wrote:Josh has stated all along that he wishes to stay in victoria, dont know what another nights sleep will do to change his mind
Because when he wakes up the 'Truth' fairy will have left a bag of non marked, non-sequential bills in a large sack with a dollar sign on it. It is Carlton we are talking about here....
regards,
REB
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Thu Oct 11, 2007 2:35 pmby Dirko
It's done and CONFIRMED.
Must say as a Blue Boy am very happy with the deal...
WEST COAST get...picks 3/20 and J Kennedy.
CARLTON get..C Judd & pick 46
.
Very surprised that the Eagles gave a pick as well....
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Thu Oct 11, 2007 2:44 pmby Benchwarmer
I agree. Hopefully, we don't listen to the recruiting ghosts of the past and go for a recycled dud again!
Re: The Australian on-line says Juddy's a Blue
Posted:
Thu Oct 11, 2007 2:50 pmby Punk Rooster
Rik E Boy wrote:Because when he wakes up the 'Truth' fairy will have left a bag of non marked, non-sequential bills in a large sack with a dollar sign on it. It is Carlton we are talking about here....
regards,
REB
Can the TRUTH fairy visit me please?
