SA Footy

Any ideas for the 22 to be picked for all australian this year, who will b unlucky to miss out?

how does the Geelong side sound?

All the Geelong team should fill the All Australian Team

Dwayne Russels team was pretty funny in the mail. HB line is Ling C.Brown and S Burgoyne. Wonder whos taking the CHF?

Stumps wrote:Dwayne Russels team was pretty funny in the mail. HB line is Ling C.Brown and S Burgoyne. Wonder whos taking the CHF?

You seen Campbell Brown play this year?

rod_rooster wrote:

Stumps wrote:Dwayne Russels team was pretty funny in the mail. HB line is Ling C.Brown and S Burgoyne. Wonder whos taking the CHF?

You seen Campbell Brown play this year?

Correct RR, plays a good foot above himself sometimes...had a great year.

I'll give it a crack*...

F: M.Pavlich L.Franklin B.Ebert
HF: C.Cornes J.Brown B.Harvey
C: S.Mitchell L.Hodge K.Cornes
HB: T.Lockyer B.Rutten A.McLeod
B: N.Malceski D.Glass C.Brown
R: D.Cox J.Bartel G.Ablett
I: B.Lade D.Kerr B.Kirk R.O'Keefe

I think Matthew Scarlett will make the team ahead of Glass and Rutten. Also i would have Hamish Macintosh as the bench ruckman instead of Brendon Lade. Other than that i think that team is just about right

Stumps wrote:Dwayne Russels team was pretty funny in the mail. HB line is Ling C.Brown and S Burgoyne. Wonder whos taking the CHF?

Did he really name Shaun Burgoyne across half-back?

Because Peter has been outstanding there this year.

Be surprised if Brett Ebert gets a guernsey.

Not Kane Cornes though - he's more than just an accumulator of cheap possies these days...

Ebert is the premier small forward in the comp IMO,he should get in.

Has Cox had that good of a year,or is it his reputation putting him forward?

Booney wrote:Ebert is the premier small forward in the comp IMO,he should get in.

Has Cox had that good of a year,or is it his reputation putting him forward?

I think hes had an average year, hasn't been the best ruckman in the comp.

Booney wrote:.

Has Cox had that good of a year,or is it his reputation putting him forward?

Reputation only Boonster

The sarge wrote:I think Matthew Scarlett will make the team ahead of Glass and Rutten.

Rutten held the league's best goal kicker in 07, J Brown to 1.1 and 2.2 i believe.
Glass has been far superior to Scarlett IMO, his job on F Gehrig last week was superb.
Scarlett good, and similar player, but i don't think he's better than Rutten and Glass.

Does Sandilands still lead the AFL for taps?

Aerie wrote:I'll give it a crack*...

F: M.Pavlich L.Franklin B.Ebert
HF: C.Cornes J.Brown B.Harvey
C: S.Mitchell L.Hodge K.Cornes
HB: T.Lockyer B.Rutten A.McLeod
B: N.Malceski D.Glass C.Brown
R: D.Cox J.Bartel G.Ablett
I: B.Lade D.Kerr B.Kirk R.O'Keefe

Good team there Aerie, I reckon you'll have it just about spot on. Maybe Carrazzo will make it on the bench in place of Kirk. Also, I would have Lade as the ruckman, with Hamish McIntosh on the bench. Don't think Cox has done enough this year and agree with Booney regarding his place may be held only by reputation.

Don think Rutten would be CHB... he gets exposed for pace when on a quicker player... even Richo gave him the round around...

C Jones? H McIntosh?

silicone skyline wrote:

The sarge wrote:I think Matthew Scarlett will make the team ahead of Glass and Rutten.

Rutten held the league's best goal kicker in 07, J Brown to 1.1 and 2.2 i believe.
Glass has been far superior to Scarlett IMO, his job on F Gehrig last week was superb.
Scarlett good, and similar player, but i don't think he's better than Rutten and Glass.

Does Sandilands still lead the AFL for taps?

Surely cambell brown should be in a key defensive posistion ahead of all of them, he plays a foot above his size....

I reckon any position in the defensive half of an all australian team is a "key position"

Riewoldt's 2nd half of the year has been pretty good and the selectors love him so I reckon he'll at least make it to the bench ... Dal Santo could be another from the Saints to give it a shake.

Also, H McIntosh as starting ruckman for mine.

silicone skyline wrote:I reckon any position in the defensive half of an all australian team is a "key position"

ummmmm yeah

Campbell Brown was named in the back pocket in the team being discussed, thus my point that he is already in a key position, regardless of being named CHF or FB