SA Footy

The good thing is that people and players can put their hand up and say 'I have a problem' and know they won't be ridiculed unlike in the past.


All the best to all of them

Brodlach wrote:The good thing is that people and players can put their hand up and say 'I have a problem' and know they won't be ridiculed unlike in the past.


All the best to all of them

It shits me when people say, "oh well he's got everything what does he have to be depressed about". Or he's not getting a kick, who are we to pass judgement on someone we don't even know.

Hope Boyd gets all the help he needs

These young lads get plucked from their lounge rooms where they have dinner with mum and dad every night into full on regimes where footy is installed into them 24/7.

Most apprentices or kids joining the workforce do their 8 hour day and then have their time with friends and family, they can go down the local for a beer and no one cares.

All the preparation and education in the world can't cater for every player in the system, sure there's great financial gains and celebrity status that goes along with the job but they do sacrifice a lot for the privilege.

Oh please. Poor kids.
Mental illness is a completely different subject to kids that walk into 60k plus jobs doing something they love.

Wedgie wrote:Oh please. Poor kids.
Mental illness is a completely different subject to kids that walk into 60k plus jobs doing something they love.

Of course, they have money, they must be happy and free of worries in the world.

One night your sitting on your lounge in Adelaide, next day your billeted out to a family you don't know in Sydney for an unknown amount of time, pretty easy transition.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Wedgie wrote:Oh please. Poor kids.
Mental illness is a completely different subject to kids that walk into 60k plus jobs doing something they love.

Of course, they have money, they must be happy and free of worries in the world.

One night your sitting on your lounge in Adelaide, next day your billeted out to a family you don't know in Sydney for an unknown amount of time, pretty easy transition.

Who said they were happy and free in the world?
I just know they would be a lot happier than people at the same age who are incarcerated, homeless, dependent on drugs or fighting in wars in general.
Mental illness doesnt choose people because of their employment.
And ai loved being billeted out to other families interstate when I was a teenager. Mind you if i was the minimum age of an AFL footballer I wouldnt even consider that, I'd be too old to want/need it.
Once again, nothing to do with mental illness.

For **** sake Wedgie. Is there any opinion you have on any subject that isn't directly transplanted from the 80s and supported by your personal anecdotes?

"But I loved being billeted out to families!"

Poor mental health can often be exacerbated or induced by social or familial isolation and/or brought on by stress. One persons situation and how they react to being drafted might be completely different to another. It's not a ******* pissing contest.

Wedgie wrote:Who said they were happy and free in the world?
I just know they would be a lot happier than people at the same age who are incarcerated, homeless, dependent on drugs or fighting in wars in general.
Mental illness doesnt choose people because of their employment.
And ai loved being billeted out to other families interstate when I was a teenager. Mind you if i was the minimum age of an AFL footballer I wouldnt even consider that, I'd be too old to want/need it.
Once again, nothing to do with mental illness.

For a week?

What's up? Did Ellen play a re-run today or you're just getting your quota up for the day?

morell wrote:For **** sake Wedgie. Is there any opinion you have on any subject that isn't directly transplanted from the 80s and supported by your personal anecdotes?

"But I loved being billeted out to families!"

Poor mental health can often be exacerbated or induced by social or familial isolation and/or brought on by stress. One persons situation and how they react to being drafted might be completely different to another. It's not a ******* pissing contest.

I'm sure the families were thrilled too

morell wrote:For **** sake Wedgie. Is there any opinion you have on any subject that isn't directly transplanted from the 80s and supported by your personal anecdotes?

"But I loved being billeted out to families!"

Poor mental health can often be exacerbated or induced by social or familial isolation and/or brought on by stress. One persons situation and how they react to being drafted might be completely different to another. It's not a ******* pissing contest.

It can also be induced by a million other things not faced by AFL footballers. It can actually be induced by anything!
But hang on, arent Boyd and Cloke from Victoria?

You're the only one getting personal and talking about pissing contests. You should learn to let others share opinions on this forum (which is one of the reasons I created it) in a mature manner.

Why do people get personal on forums? Surely that could induce depression or anxiety in people, who they're supposed to be showing empathy for?
Hypocritical?

Wedgie wrote:

morell wrote:For **** sake Wedgie. Is there any opinion you have on any subject that isn't directly transplanted from the 80s and supported by your personal anecdotes?

"But I loved being billeted out to families!"

Poor mental health can often be exacerbated or induced by social or familial isolation and/or brought on by stress. One persons situation and how they react to being drafted might be completely different to another. It's not a ******* pissing contest.

It can also be induced by a million other things not faced by AFL footballers. It can actually be induced by anything!

Of course, you can be born with a chemical imbalance, you can have it induced by a traumatic event. The one thing I am sure of is discounting or dismissing any cause, whether you think its pertinent or not, is not helpful.

Remember, you said this:

Wedgie wrote:Oh please. Poor kids.
Mental illness is a completely different subject to kids that walk into 60k plus jobs doing something they love.

Which is completely dismissing what people might be suffering with because you personally enjoyed some of their circumstances.

Poor form and I called you out on it. No need to get all sniffly.

Wedgie wrote:You're the only one getting personal and talking about pissing contests. You should learn to let others share opinions on this forum (which is one of the reasons I created it) in a mature manner.

No, I am not. I am calling you out for your outdated and ill informed opinions.

morell wins.. Fatality.

Wedgie wrote:Why do people get personal on forums? Surely that could induce depression or anxiety in people, who they're supposed to be showing empathy for?
Hypocritical?

You say the sweetest things, you come in wielding an axe and then say "hey, what's all the fuss?"

More insults morrell? Wow, we better all pray that I don't have depression. I won't lower myself to the same in case I induce you into a mental illness as I'm empathatic to the cause.
Saying AFL footballers are more likely to have depression than the general community is as ignorant as someone saying AFL footballers would be more likely to be born with a genetic heart disease. Its this ignorance that actually does more harm than good for the education of the general community in mental illness.

Wedgie wrote:More insults morrell? Wow, we better all pray that I don't have depression. I won't lower myself to the same in case I induce you into a mental illness as I'm empathatic to the cause.

I haven't insulted you as a person, once. I don't know who you are. The only things I have been critical of are the opinions you have shared of your own volition on here.

You are *not* entitled to your opinion, you are only entitled to be informed. Which on this subject, based on the non-anecdotal evidence you have provided, you are not.

Wedgie wrote:Saying AFL footballers are more likely to have depression than the general community is as ignorant (and outdated) as someone saying AFL footballers would be more likely to be born with a genetic heart disease. Its this ignorance that actually does more harm than good for the education of the general community in mental illness.

No one said that. Now you're just making stuff up.


Look, before it all gets out of hand and because I think you're reasonable, this post is the only thing I have issues with, aside from that, happy to move on:

Wedgie wrote:Oh please. Poor kids.
Mental illness is a completely different subject to kids that walk into 60k plus jobs doing something they love.

Wedgie wrote:
You're the only one getting personal and talking about pissing contests. You should learn to let others share opinions on this forum (which is one of the reasons I created it) in a mature manner.

I can't remember the last time you responded in a mature way to anything on here

Post of the year morrell. You can't see your own insults and I'm not entitled to an opinion on my own forum?
Wow.
Good luck in life mate.

bennymacca wrote:

Wedgie wrote:
You're the only one getting personal and talking about pissing contests. You should learn to let others share opinions on this forum (which is one of the reasons I created it) in a mature manner.

I can't remember the last time you responded in a mature way to anything on here

Thanks mate, I always take insults from you as a compliment.

Wedgie wrote:Oh please. Poor kids.
Mental illness is a completely different subject to kids that walk into 60k plus jobs doing something they love.

Doing something you love does not make you immune from mental illness.
Making all the money in the world does not make you immune from mental illness.

Comments like this show that the community, as a whole, still need educating on the subject.