Brodlach wrote:Plenty of Superstars have never won a premiership, some never even play finals.
Aaron Keating won a premiership medal, would never rate him above Boak.
Truly a champion clubman
This is correct. Also not the entire basis of my argument.
Great clubman? Couldn't agree more. Outstanding, in fact.
Great player? Good to very good, for mine.
Rozee on track for 3 AA's inside the first 6 seasons of his career, Butters not far off. Both have won a B&F already and I expect will add to that. Zak already an AFLCA winner, both could very well win an AFL MVP award by careers end.
These sorts of recognitions, for the most part, go from defining an individual career from good-very good to great-legendary and rank your individual legacy to the game, depending how many times you are awarded them. The premierships are more your legacy within your club.
Aside from that, from where Trav's career looked headed at the end of 2014, to where it has ended up - I expected (and hoped for) more, but that is just my opinion.