Carlton Season 2012

[Squids]

Try 16 and don't give me that national comp crap

VFL Premierships are NOT AFL Premierships any more than SANFL ones are!
That is truth not "crap".

Wrong


Pretty sure Carlton won them against the Pies, Hawks, Bombers, Tigers etc


not against Sturt, Glenelg, Westies, South etc



Last time I checked the Pies, Hawks, Bombers, Tiges and other are in the AFL

[gossipgirl]

Try 16 and don't give me that national comp crap

VFL Premierships are NOT AFL Premierships any more than SANFL ones are!
That is truth not "crap".

Wrong


Pretty sure Carlton won them against the Pies, Hawks, Bombers, Tigers etc


not against Sturt, Glenelg, Westies, South etc

ahh arrogant victorians you got to love their logic !!!! problem is no one buys it

Last time I checked the Pies, Hawks, Bombers, Tiges and other are in the AFL

[Johno6]

i wouldnt be surprised if blues came out n won tonight

[OnSong]

i wouldnt be surprised if blues came out n won tonight

I would be.

[Johno6]

i wouldnt be surprised if blues came out n won tonight

I would be.

I wouldn't be.

[Media Park]

Carlton's premiership's were won in the recognized elite competition of the time.
In the same elite competition, Port Adelaide has 1.

[The Dark Knight]

Carlton's premiership's were won in the recognized elite competition of the time.
In the same elite competition, Port Adelaide has 1.

And your mob, West Coast and the Brisbane Lions have won the most at three apiece.

[Booney]

Carlton's premiership's were won in the recognized elite competition of the time.
In the same elite competition, Port Adelaide has 1.

In whose eyes?

[RustyCage]

The AFL is the old VFL so their flags definitely should be recognised. Do premierships SANFL teams won while the comp was the SAFA or SAFL not count just because the comp had a different name?

[Dirko]

And why the **** is this back on the merry go round. It's only the retards who can't understand the basic background of the AFL as to why the history was carried over....

[Turbo]

We could argue this till the end of time but the afl is a rebadged vfl so 16 is the flags our proud club has won.

[Jim05]

We could argue this till the end of time but the afl is a rebadged vfl so 16 is the flags our proud club has won.

Correct
The VFL was only re-badged, a new comp wasnt just made up.
Everyone knew the rules when they joined

[Turbo]

We could argue this till the end of time but the afl is a rebadged vfl so 16 is the flags our proud club has won.

Correct
The VFL was only re-badged, a new comp wasnt just made up.
Everyone knew the rules when they joined

Glad we're on the same page with your equal league record 16 flag club you support

[helicopterking]

How has Mclean not been playing. He provides a hard edge around the contest and ball ups. Actually means Carlton can get a clearance when Judd doesnt get it.

[gadj1976]

How has Mclean not been playing. He provides a hard edge around the contest and ball ups. Actually means Carlton can get a clearance when Judd doesnt get it.

Haven't been able to carry him with guys like Curnow, Carrots and Murphy in the midfield. I agree, he's been good, but he needs runners around him each and every time he gets the footy. That means guys like Gartlett, Simpson, Walker et al need to get by him cos he struggles to run out of sight in a fog. Don't get me wrong, he has a role to play and is good at it, providing he has support. He gets shown up when he doesn't have support, and that's not his fault.

On another note, how much better do we look with Duigan back there?

[JK]

On another note, how much better do we look with Duigan back there?

Been really good tonight

[helicopterking]

Haven't been able to carry him with guys like Curnow, Carrots and Murphy in the midfield. I agree, he's been good, but he needs runners around him each and every time he gets the footy. That means guys like Gartlett, Simpson, Walker etc

He offers more then Curnow, because he brings guys into the game. Basically offers what Robinson does when he is worked threw the Midfield. Perfect guy to throw in there when youve had 2 or 3 goals kicked against to force ball ups and break even

[Squids]

Too many fumbles

[JK]

Too many fumbles

Yep, still not natural at the "in close" game .. Even late in this last quarter they've been a chance but just a few too many fumbles

[JK]

This young Watspn lad looks a player