Page 11 of 15
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:20 amby marbles
Eddie McGuire was outstanding yesterday, that game was easily the most exciting vision all year and his commentary and adrenaline made it that way
Last nights port game in comparison was dead shit dull & boring, it sounded like a morgue, or a bunch of nuns commentating a mouse race in a library
10 out of 10 for eddie
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:21 amby kickinit
bennymacca wrote:Rik E Boy wrote:bennymacca wrote:eddie is ridiculously bad as a commentator.
I couldn't disagree more. I think Eddie is an excellent commentator, just don't let him near a Pies game. You can hear his passion for the game when he calls. However if I was a Blackbirds fan I'd probably agree because he was barracking for Carlton. A quick look at the ladder might explain that.
regards,
REB
Usually I don't mind him that much, but he was openly barracking for carlton, and I suspect you are right about the reason.
He probably did it because roo does it every time he's doing a crows game, or he barracks for who ever is playing port.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:28 amby cracka
Jase wrote:Rik E Boy wrote:bennymacca wrote:eddie is ridiculously bad as a commentator.
I couldn't disagree more. I think Eddie is an excellent commentator, just don't let him near a Pies game. You can hear his passion for the game when he calls. However if I was a Blackbirds fan I'd probably agree because he was barracking for Carlton. A quick look at the ladder might explain that.
regards,
REB
even as a Carlton fan I love Eddie... what he has done for the Pies is amazing. Love hearing him commentate and yesterday was more about the underdog (bottom team in the comp) having a red hot crack against a top 4ish team.... could have been anyone down the bottom and he would have been carrying on...
Good commentary, probably not... entertaining, heck yeah.
Sure beats Riccutio mumbling through a call... now thats crap....
I thought he was great. I agree, I think his barracking was more for a club on its knees standing up & fighting. He comes from the old MMM commentary guys who I love listening too. Pity they can't time their commentary to the broadcast as then I'd turn the TV volume down & listen to the radio.
The crows a top 4ish side, you're kidding right, that talk is for bias crows supporters.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:47 amby carey
Hope Sam Lane wears a bikini down the slide tomorrow!
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:49 amby Jim05
carey wrote:Hope Sam Lane wears a bikini down the slide tomorrow!
Thats just sick, she is terrible
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:50 amby carey
Jim05 wrote:carey wrote:Hope Sam Lane wears a bikini down the slide tomorrow!
Thats just sick, she is terrible
Don't know about that Jimbo, Fair rack.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:51 amby Brodlach
Jim would rather see Hirdy in a bikini
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 12:08 pmby Jase
cracka wrote:Jase wrote:Rik E Boy wrote:bennymacca wrote:eddie is ridiculously bad as a commentator.
I couldn't disagree more. I think Eddie is an excellent commentator, just don't let him near a Pies game. You can hear his passion for the game when he calls. However if I was a Blackbirds fan I'd probably agree because he was barracking for Carlton. A quick look at the ladder might explain that.
regards,
REB
even as a Carlton fan I love Eddie... what he has done for the Pies is amazing. Love hearing him commentate and yesterday was more about the underdog (bottom team in the comp) having a red hot crack against a top 4ish team.... could have been anyone down the bottom and he would have been carrying on...
Good commentary, probably not... entertaining, heck yeah.
Sure beats Riccutio mumbling through a call... now thats crap....
I thought he was great. I agree, I think his barracking was more for a club on its knees standing up & fighting. He comes from the old MMM commentary guys who I love listening too. Pity they can't time their commentary to the broadcast as then I'd turn the TV volume down & listen to the radio.
The crows a top 4ish side, you're kidding right, that talk is for bias crows supporters.
My top 4ish comment was for the Crows fans ... though they are pretty close to top 4 on the ladder now...
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 12:22 pmby Jim05
Brodlach wrote:Jim would rather see Hirdy in a bikini
Well I did go to a ladyboy show in Chiang Mai last night lol.
Just dont rate Sam Lane, pretty average IMO
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 12:42 pmby carey
So from Essendons point of view it's the investigation from ASADA and WADA's fault they miss goals from 20m out directly in front, Oh yeah seems fair
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 1:27 pmby MW
marbles wrote:Eddie McGuire was outstanding yesterday, that game was easily the most exciting vision all year and his commentary and adrenaline made it that way
Last nights port game in comparison was dead shit dull & boring, it sounded like a morgue, or a bunch of nuns commentating a mouse race in a library
10 out of 10 for eddie
You are fking kidding right? The single most biased call in the history of the game. It was a disgrace.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 1:29 pmby PatowalongaPirate
MW wrote:marbles wrote:Eddie McGuire was outstanding yesterday, that game was easily the most exciting vision all year and his commentary and adrenaline made it that way
Last nights port game in comparison was dead shit dull & boring, it sounded like a morgue, or a bunch of nuns commentating a mouse race in a library
10 out of 10 for eddie
You are fking kidding right? The single most biased call in the history of the game. It was a disgrace.
Incorrect. The most biased call in the history of the game happens every week on FiveAA.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 1:34 pmby carey
PatowalongaPirate wrote:MW wrote:marbles wrote:Eddie McGuire was outstanding yesterday, that game was easily the most exciting vision all year and his commentary and adrenaline made it that way
Last nights port game in comparison was dead shit dull & boring, it sounded like a morgue, or a bunch of nuns commentating a mouse race in a library
10 out of 10 for eddie
You are fking kidding right? The single most biased call in the history of the game. It was a disgrace.
Incorrect. The most biased call in the history of the game happens every week on FiveAA.
Correct.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 1:34 pmby Lightning McQueen
MW wrote:marbles wrote:Eddie McGuire was outstanding yesterday, that game was easily the most exciting vision all year and his commentary and adrenaline made it that way
Last nights port game in comparison was dead shit dull & boring, it sounded like a morgue, or a bunch of nuns commentating a mouse race in a library
10 out of 10 for eddie
You are fking kidding right? The single most biased call in the history of the game. It was a disgrace.
I can't believe you fell for that!
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 1:42 pmby MW
PatowalongaPirate wrote:MW wrote:marbles wrote:Eddie McGuire was outstanding yesterday, that game was easily the most exciting vision all year and his commentary and adrenaline made it that way
Last nights port game in comparison was dead shit dull & boring, it sounded like a morgue, or a bunch of nuns commentating a mouse race in a library
10 out of 10 for eddie
You are fking kidding right? The single most biased call in the history of the game. It was a disgrace.
Incorrect. The most biased call in the history of the game happens every week on FiveAA.
Yes for both Crows and Port games as they are only broadcasting to their fans/state. Channel 7/Fox are a national coverage so should be catering for both teams that were playing, not just the Victorian underdog.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 1:54 pmby carey
I've never seen a worse 10mins of footy than the start of the GWS v Brisbane game. Div 7 at absolute best.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 2:08 pmby carey
Worst 1/4 of footy in the history of the game.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 2:37 pmby marbles
Lightning McQueen wrote:MW wrote:marbles wrote:Eddie McGuire was outstanding yesterday, that game was easily the most exciting vision all year and his commentary and adrenaline made it that way
Last nights port game in comparison was dead shit dull & boring, it sounded like a morgue, or a bunch of nuns commentating a mouse race in a library
10 out of 10 for eddie
You are fking kidding right? The single most biased call in the history of the game. It was a disgrace.
I can't believe you fell for that!
well as a carlton supporter, round of applause for eddie
its games like that as to why (when carlton play well) that we see carlton on tv more than anyone.
pure 100% entertainment afl football at its best
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 3:46 pmby Yangebup
Speaking of biased calls, what about Ling & Co on friday night who wouldve thought Richmond even played?
Ling needs to get over his man love crush on Nat Fyfe its embarrassing.
I cannot understand why Leigh Matthews was taken off friday nights & Ling replacing him.
FFS someone give him an assistant coaching job please so we dont have to listen to his CRAP anymore.
Re: Round 10 stuff
Posted:
Sun Jun 07, 2015 4:08 pmby helicopterking
The wind is crazy in the WC/ Nth game.