Tredrea to retire - immediately

[Punk Rooster]

but from 2000-2004 he was the best CHF in the league.

Oh dear...where do I start

1. Wayne Carey
2. Johnathon Brown
3......

Tredrea- never liked the bloke (as a player), but was certainly a footballer who commanded respect on the field...

[Dirko]

* Moved from Power Board to allow comments from all footy fans *

Hooray !! Common sense prevails.

Well done on a good career Warren. A real force to reckon with. Always gave Carlton plenty of headaches....

[whufc]

w**ker on the field, extemely good player though and seemed like a genuinely nice, down to earth bloke from what i have heard from him on the radio.

[Hondo]

but from 2000-2004 he was the best CHF in the league.

Oh dear...where do I start

You want to start with Carey circa 200-2004?

Missed 2002 altogether and in Crows colours 2003-4

Think Tredders shaded Carey in that time (not overall)

Brown really hit his straps in 2004 but wasn't at an elite level 2001 (debut) - 2003

Who else? Tredrea was all-Australian each year from 2001-2004. I think the AA selectors agreed with Booney. AFL Coaches Association 'Champion Player of the Year' Award: 2004 and AFL Players Association 'Champion Player of the Year' Award: 2003 (3rd place), 2004 (3rd place).

I think it's easy to forget the high level he was at in those years, 6 years on.

[Dutchy]

Booney may wish to retract 2000 & 2001

[JK]

Has been a champion power player, and for a number of years there was one of the best power forwards in the competition .. Has forged an outstanding career and been a great club man for Port.

[dedja]

What he said ...

[Booney]

Booney may wish to retract 2000 & 2001

Or maybe not. He was AA CHF, he was CHF in a team playing in Prelim finals. Its a matter of persoanl opinion and I am sticking to mine.

[The Dark Knight]

Well done Tredders on a fantastic career. It's unfortunate that is has to end like it has. One a the great Port Adelaide players and a great CHF. Now comes the hard part Port has to find their next CHF......

[BUZZ]

Will remember his performance in the 96 sanfl gf vs centrals. Played 2nd fiddle to hodges for the day but as a 17yo in a league gf, kicking 2 and taking some great contested marks, was always going to be a great player

yes i remember that!

It looked as though Hodges was playing 2nd fiddle to Tredders

[NO-MERCY]

Will remember his performance in the 96 sanfl gf vs centrals. Played 2nd fiddle to hodges for the day but as a 17yo in a league gf, kicking 2 and taking some great contested marks, was always going to be a great player

yes i remember that!

It looked as though Hodges was playing 2nd fiddle to Tredders

He was.

[The Dark Knight]

Will remember his performance in the 96 sanfl gf vs centrals. Played 2nd fiddle to hodges for the day but as a 17yo in a league gf, kicking 2 and taking some great contested marks, was always going to be a great player

yes i remember that!

It looked as though Hodges was playing 2nd fiddle to Tredders

He was.

I don't think Hodges would of liked playing second fiddle to a 17 year old.

[Wedgie]

I'll always remember him for being Paul Chapman's step ladder.

[Booney]

Was wondering how long it would take you.

[Wedgie]

Was wondering how long it would take you.

If you wonder about that you really should look at getting a hobby or getting out more mate!
Tredrea was a better player than Chad Cornes, there ya go, a compliment!

[Booney]

Was wondering how long it would take you.

If you wonder about that you really should look at getting a hobby or getting out more mate!
Tredrea was a better player than Chad Cornes, there ya go, a compliment!

LOL - the first thing I thought of when I heard of Tredders impending retirement was "I bet Wedgie posts the pic of Chapman on his back".



* I get out lots and have several hobbies *

[Wedgie]

Was wondering how long it would take you.

If you wonder about that you really should look at getting a hobby or getting out more mate!
Tredrea was a better player than Chad Cornes, there ya go, a compliment!

LOL - the first thing I thought of when I heard of Tredders impending retirement was "I bet Wedgie posts the pic of Chapman on his back".



* I get out lots and have several hobbies *

So you would have lost your bet then, I like to surprise.

[Dutchy]

The bow was probably the most embaressing thing an AFL footballer has ever done on the footy field...

[Booney]

Almost on que, that was the next comment I was waiting on.

I'd say losing a GF by 20 goals is fairly embarassing myself.....or a Prelim by 87.

[Q.]

The bow was probably the most embaressing thing an AFL footballer has ever done on the footy field...

Kane Cornes taking a dive when BBBBH shaped up to him was equally