Round 1: Collingwood vs Adelaide

[JK]

How many times have Adelaide beaten Collingwood in Melbourne, does anyone know ... Im guessing it's between 1-3?

[GWW]

How many times have Adelaide beaten Collingwood in Melbourne, does anyone know ... Im guessing it's between 1-3?

They beat them in a final at Telstra 2 years ago i reckon, i can also recall a night game in 05 when they beat them. I'm sure some Crows supporters on the site will have a more accurate list than that though.

[Pup]

How many times have Adelaide beaten Collingwood in Melbourne, does anyone know ... Im guessing it's between 1-3?

They beat them in a final at Telstra 2 years ago i reckon, i can also recall a night game in 05 when they beat them. I'm sure some Crows supporters on the site will have a more accurate list than that though.

4 Times

1998, 2005, 2006 and 2007.

No finals though i am pretty sure.

[GWW]

I may have been mixing up a night final with a season proper final if that's the case.

[JK]

I may have been mixing up a night final with a season proper final if that's the case.

NAB Cup Granny I reckon mate 5 or so years ago

[GWW]

Ah yeah i do recall that game being around then.

I'm actually not sure what i remember haha.

I do recall they beat Collingwood in 05, i think McLeod kicked that goal from the boundary.

[JK]

Ah yeah i do recall that game being around then.

I'm actually not sure what i remember haha.

I do recall they beat Collingwood in 05, i think McLeod kicked that goal from the boundary.

Fair call, I'd forgotten about that one .. What a beauty of a goal too

[GWW]

Actually i think i recall now why i thought it was a final in 07 when they won - i think it was the final minor round game, and they had to win it to consolidate their position in the finals, so it was similar to a final, in that they had to win to keep their season alive.

[Pup]

Actually i think i recall now why i thought it was a final in 07 when they won - i think it was the final minor round game, and they had to win it to consolidate their position in the finals, so it was similar to a final, in that they had to win to keep their season alive.

Yeah Rnd 22 on a Friday Night.

[JK]

Actually i think i recall now why i thought it was a final in 07 when they won - i think it was the final minor round game, and they had to win it to consolidate their position in the finals, so it was similar to a final, in that they had to win to keep their season alive.

Yeah Rnd 22 on a Friday Night.

Stinker of a game too

[Booney]

pies by 6 goals. i dont think the crows will trouble them greatly.

Anyone for that matter..

Hey Booney your getting very Mouthy Very Early in the season.
your gunna come done with a massive thud!!! when port lose a couple in a row (every one is overrating them)

You see it as me "getting mouthy" when it in fact is my view on where Adelaide is at this year. I dont think Adelaide will trouble any of the top 6 sides of which Collingwood are one.

Why will I also "come undone with a massive thud" ? IMO Adelaide are about 8-12th and if you dont agree,thats fine.

[the joker]

lets just see, reply to this about 5 on sunday after the crows upset the Collywobbles and Essendon beat the pansies

[hearts on fire]

lets just see, reply to this about 5 on sunday after the crows upset the Collywobbles and Essendon beat the pansies

Excellent post, that actually hurt the Power fans...... just a little bit......

[wycbloods]

lets just see, reply to this about 5 on sunday after the crows upset the Collywobbles and Essendon beat the pansies

I don't think you will get the pleasure of seeing that happen this weekend Joker.

[Booney]

lets just see, reply to this about 5 on sunday after the crows upset the Collywobbles and Essendon beat the pansies

Excellent post, that actually hurt the Power fans...... just a little bit......

So you agree that Collingwood are favourites then? So why rip into my post if you agree?

Excellent post?

I can see I wont be able to discuss anything with the joker rationally.

[the joker]

you can always talk to the joker rationally.

[FD88]

Official side for the game:

B: Doughty (11), Rutten (25), Otten (22)
HB: Reilly (3), Bock (44), McLeod (23)
C: Cook (8), Goodwin (36), Knights (21)
HF: Douglas (26), Hentschel (37), Mackay (14)
F: Walker (13), Tippett (4), Porplyzia (40)
R: Maric (20), Vince (17), Edwards (9)
I/c: van Berlo (7), Stevens (27), Dangerfield (32), Petrenko (33)
Emerg: Griffin (6), Jacky (10), Shirley (12)

Such an exciting team!! Pity about Thommo but still...all the flair, pace, talent!!! Gun team.

[NFC]

Wow! Insanely exciting team!

Cannot wait! Walker, Cook and Petrenko are perhaps my top 3 fav youngsters so this is going to be sweet! And then with Otto and Danger to top it all off!

Douglas doesn't deserve his place though but I guess the one thing we lack is small forwards so he can be gifted games.

[Thiele]

A Big Welcome back Trent Hentschel

[Hondo]

Wow! Insanely exciting team!

Cannot wait! Walker, Cook and Petrenko are perhaps my top 3 fav youngsters so this is going to be sweet! And then with Otto and Danger to top it all off!

Agreed! Great team ....

Slotted Dangerfield into my SC team at the last minute!