Good to see yet another South player captaining the Crows

[RustyCage]

To be fair to Goodwin,they are taking a punt,but I bet he will do a fine job.

He's good with the media too. If they were to attemp to take a photo that might be incriminating against him or the team, he is already skilled in the art of verbal threats of physical abuse.

you're still not over that GF hiding are you champ?

Whats that got to do with the Crows? Yes I am over it by the way. Thanks for your concern!

[RustyCage]

Locky may we me so bold to suggest the Port supporters might want to pause on the Goodwin pay-outs until their Captain signs his contract, if he does

It not like he's going to go anywhere else. Just a matter of time.

[Psyber]

Locky may we me so bold to suggest the Port supporters might want to pause on the Goodwin pay-outs until their Captain signs his contract, if he does

It not like he's going to go anywhere else. Just a matter of time.

And then he still won't go anywhere because his body is past it [unfortunately I agree]. Damon White for Captain and CHF ??

[Booney]

To be fair to Goodwin,they are taking a punt,but I bet he will do a fine job.

He's good with the media too. If they were to attemp to take a photo that might be incriminating against him or the team, he is already skilled in the art of verbal threats of physical abuse.

you're still not over that GF hiding are you champ?

The manner in which you attempt to link the comment of PAFC to mine,then to our Grand Final loss has more flaws,faults and lack of common sense I thought not even achievable by a West Adelaide fan.

[NFC]

And another "South" player will captain after Goodwin...

[Hondo]

I reckon Rutten has the edge at this stage NFC

[NFC]

I reckon Rutten has the edge at this stage NFC

Hmm tough one, it's out of those two. Playing at FB might juts hold Rutten back.

[the wonder elephant]

I reckon Rutten has the edge at this stage NFC

Hmm tough one, it's out of those two. Playing at FB might juts hold Rutten back.

didnt stop tom harley from leading the cats to this years flag from the last line in defence !

[NFC]

I reckon Rutten has the edge at this stage NFC

Hmm tough one, it's out of those two. Playing at FB might juts hold Rutten back.

didnt stop tom harley from leading the cats to this years flag from the last line in defence !

True, but a slightly differing situation. Was/is there another standout leader in the Cats team? Ablett Jr maybe, but he wasn't ready this season.

VB is an outstanding leader which will make it harder for Rutten.

[Wedgie]

Harley doesn't usually play FB, that's Matthew Scarlett!
Harley's usually a CHB or when Egans playing there a mobile backman who can take a grab.

[fester69]

I reckon Cam Mooney is a natural born leader, but the "title" captain might weigh on him a bit. Barring Moons I reckon Chappie would be a great skipper, but how can you go past Harls, a Norwood man to boot?

[MW]

To be fair to Goodwin,they are taking a punt,but I bet he will do a fine job.

He's good with the media too. If they were to attemp to take a photo that might be incriminating against him or the team, he is already skilled in the art of verbal threats of physical abuse.

you're still not over that GF hiding are you champ?

The manner in which you attempt to link the comment of PAFC to mine,then to our Grand Final loss has more flaws,faults and lack of common sense I thought not even achievable by a West Adelaide fan.

You would have the arrogance to make it all about you Booney...I quoted PAFC1870 but your tripe of a comment came along for the ride, there was no intention to link the two. LMAO you're touchy aren't you?

Try to move on, It will get better with time....

[Andy #24]

Shouldn't Norwood supporters be shouting from the roof tops about a Norwood lad being a premiership captain of the greatest team of all rather than someone who's coaching an ordinary side?
Or are they a little less excitable than South fans?

Harley fell into that job. Just proves that a great captain isn't a necessity to do well.

[Wedgie]

Shouldn't Norwood supporters be shouting from the roof tops about a Norwood lad being a premiership captain of the greatest team of all rather than someone who's coaching an ordinary side?
Or are they a little less excitable than South fans?

Harley fell into that job. Just proves that a great captain isn't a necessity to do well.

Port had already shown that 3 years earlier.

[redden whites]

not to mention 97-98

[Hondo]

Come on RW, Bicks may not have been Nathan Buckley but he was a great player in his own right and a great leader

One blemish that ugly incident with Wakelin

[redden whites]

he was a great player in his own right

mate... please

[Hondo]

Matter of opinion I suppose but he played 276 more AFL games than I did

[JK]

Im with you Hondo ... Wasn't the most brilliant player at the club at any stage, but was everything you look for in a captain, a great leader.

[Andy #24]

I liked Bicks and even Tredders as captains. Both led by example. Notice the past tense. Tredders can't even lead himself out the goalsquare now.