Trade week 2007

[NFC]

Not necessarily the worst trade ever. They wont do too good at the Saints. Better than them going to a good team.

They get 2 first choice players for an average pick. They pick up Schneider who will do well at the feet or Riewoldt/Kosi and Dempster who's a good tall running defender.

Can't find much to disagree with in this one, seems a good deal for the Saints ... Would Cap space have been an issue at Sydney?

I think that's the case, but surely they could've done better than pick 26!

[woodwt]

Moran is not different than meeson!

[NFC]

Moran is not different than meeson!

Exactly what I've been saying.

[NFC]

Steven King and Charlie Gardiner to Saints for pick 90.

[Pidge]

Morton to Richmond for pick 35

[Hondo]

Moran is not different than meeson!

Exactly what I've been saying.

Except that Meesen wanted to go home so we get a replacement

[Rik E Boy]

Steven King and Charlie Gardiner to Saints for pick 90.

This is the cleanout I was expecting after 2006, not our premiership year. Let's have a look at who the Cats have let go so far

Callan
Gardiner
King
Playfair

Gardiner, Playfair and King will release some salary cap pressure and Callan wasn't getting a gig anyhow. Geelong have picked up some late draft picks that I believe the club will use to select father son pick Donahue, another forward I believe (ok you got me I don't know that much about him). Most of those guys would struggle to get into the best 22 but I thought King would stay at least.

At least the future has been secured. Prismal and Blake were retained and I hope Tenace is given another chance. Remember this time last year Geelong tried to shop Steve Johnson around unsuccesfully. I'm hoping that Tenace grabs his chance and runs with it.

Good luck with your careers boys....just don't do any damage against the Cats!

regards,

REB

[Pidge]

I hope that the saints win the premiership next year only because it will probably be Robert Harvey's last year.

[NFC]

Oh man, biggest shafting of all time.

Hudson and pick 43 for picks 30 and 38.

TERRIBLE DEAL AFC.

[smac]

Oh man, biggest shafting of all time.

Hudson and pick 43 for picks 30 and 38.

TERRIBLE DEAL AFC.

You won't get too many disagreements on that one Lemon, lime.

[NFC]

Oh man, biggest shafting of all time.

Hudson and pick 43 for picks 30 and 38.

TERRIBLE DEAL AFC.

You won't get too many disagreements on that one Lemon, lime.

Cheers Dr. Pepper.

[MW]

Crows really do suck at trade week don't they....

[Pup]

Not necessarily the worst trade ever. They wont do too good at the Saints. Better than them going to a good team.

I would say the opposite, they will do very well for the Saints IMO.

Pick 26 in a shallow draft for a crumbing forward and a running defender/midfielder both in the swans best 22.

Poor trade for Sydney IMO.

Schneider will do very well under Kosi, Riewoldt and Co

[Blue Boy]

Oh man, biggest shafting of all time.

Hudson and pick 43 for picks 30 and 38.

TERRIBLE DEAL AFC.

Obviously something had to be done - with 1 hour to go !!!

Not a good result but better than nothin cause it looks like the Bulldogs were happy to let it slip through to pre season !!!

[MW]

Dempster is shite.....he will not be in the saints 22 unless they have injuries
Schneider is a good pick up and pick 26 for him alone would of been good for both parties, so getting Dempster to add depth is a good move by the saints.

[blink]

Schneider will do very well under Kosi, Riewoldt and Co

Isn't that S. Milne's domain??

[MW]

Oh man, biggest shafting of all time.

Hudson and pick 43 for picks 30 and 38.

TERRIBLE DEAL AFC.

Obviously something had to be done - with 1 hour to go !!!

Not a good result but better than nothin cause it looks like the Bulldogs were happy to let it slip through to pre season !!!

Good point....

[NFC]

Oh man, biggest shafting of all time.

Hudson and pick 43 for picks 30 and 38.

TERRIBLE DEAL AFC.

Obviously something had to be done - with 1 hour to go !!!

Not a good result but better than nothin cause it looks like the Bulldogs were happy to let it slip through to pre season !!!

Good point....

Well considering we were promised a pick in the 20's all week, this trade is rubbish!

[MW]

Promise all you want, but in 1 hours time the crows would of got ZERO and Bulldogs would of got him anyway
better than nothing

[Pup]

Schneider will do very well under Kosi, Riewoldt and Co

Isn't that S. Milne's domain??

Milne wont be around much longer.

I honestly cant see him getting a game with Adam there?