SA Footy

Deledio would have been a super pick up IMHO. Surely couldn't have been Geelong's decision to turn down a trade for Caddy.

Rik E Boy wrote:WTF are we doing? Caddy for **** all when we could have used him to land Deledio. This is the worst move we have made since getting Justin Murphy.

regards,

REB

I really don't understand whats going on with this either. I didn't really think swapping Lids for Caddy was a good deal for us but swapping him for f%$k all is just embarrassing

I'm still pissed off Cotton On are making our Guernsey's!

RustyCage wrote:Geelong have a new apparel sponsor in Cotton On, and have launched the sleeved rugby style top they'll be using in the NAB next year, and possibly for a home and away game.

The moment Caddy realised he didnt want to play for Geelong anymore.
Unfortunately i cant take credit for that, saw it somewhere else

Yeah, Richmond knew where his g spot was after that!

I reckon Aaron Black was a good get for the Cats, type of stay at home forward that will really help Hawkins

Caddy used 1st rounder to get Caddy also in 2013!

Dutchy wrote:Caddy used 1st rounder to get Caddy also in 2013!

More Caddys than the PGA!

Brodlach wrote:I reckon Aaron Black was a good get for the Cats, type of stay at home forward that will really help Hawkins

Yeah, he might help if he stays at home and doesn't come to the game

Mr Beefy wrote:

Brodlach wrote:I reckon Aaron Black was a good get for the Cats, type of stay at home forward that will really help Hawkins

Yeah, he might help if he stays at home and doesn't come to the game

Gee, he'll be a bit dark with that comment.

Losing Smedts will hurt (your VFL side).....

He reminds me of Andrew Eccles who went from Adelaide to Carlton.... real ordinary.

Am I missing something with this bloke - from what I've seen he's not that good??

gadj1976 wrote:Losing Smedts will hurt (your VFL side).....

He reminds me of Andrew Eccles who went from Adelaide to Carlton.... real ordinary.

Am I missing something with this bloke - from what I've seen he's not that good??

He's half the player Touhy is.

regards,

REB

Rik E Boy wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:Losing Smedts will hurt (your VFL side).....

He reminds me of Andrew Eccles who went from Adelaide to Carlton.... real ordinary.

Am I missing something with this bloke - from what I've seen he's not that good??

He's half the player Touhy is.

regards,

REB

He's only 93cm tall?

gadj1976 wrote:Losing Smedts will hurt (your VFL side).....

He reminds me of Andrew Eccles who went from Adelaide to Carlton.... real ordinary.

Am I missing something with this bloke - from what I've seen he's not that good??

Think he was just a throw-in, wanted the first rounder which ended up at GWS for Marchbank & Pickett

Rik E Boy wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:Losing Smedts will hurt (your VFL side).....

He reminds me of Andrew Eccles who went from Adelaide to Carlton.... real ordinary.

Am I missing something with this bloke - from what I've seen he's not that good??

He's half the player Touhy is.

regards,

REB

Ecch, that makes our trading 'half ar$ed'

beef wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:Losing Smedts will hurt (your VFL side).....

He reminds me of Andrew Eccles who went from Adelaide to Carlton.... real ordinary.

Am I missing something with this bloke - from what I've seen he's not that good??

Think he was just a throw-in, wanted the first rounder which ended up at GWS for Marchbank & Pickett

We've had a ton of these blokes over the last decade though. Time to move on.

Grab pick 186 and just pick up some horse manure rather than be the club that gives a last hope to some of these also rans.

The GWS blokes, fair enough, they were pick <10 two years ago, but Smedts, seriously?

We need to take this convo to the Carlton board, if we can afford one.

Mr Beefy wrote:

Brodlach wrote:I reckon Aaron Black was a good get for the Cats, type of stay at home forward that will really help Hawkins

Yeah, he might help if he stays at home and doesn't come to the game

That's a pis ser!!! Couldn't get a game at North so why would he get a game at the cattery?? Trade our talent out for spuds. Hmmmmm

Mitch Clark given the boot. Another failed experiment.

Good to see Motlop in great nick unlike this time last year.