SA Footy

Armchair expert wrote:West Coast with a match winning lead already

arent they behind

locky801 wrote:

Armchair expert wrote:West Coast with a match winning lead already

arent they behind

Lead in the Harley Reid Cup

Knew the Eagles were ordinary but gee whiz!


Pies looking all over Carlton early

RB wrote:

whufc wrote:How did Dusty’s point stand at the end of the quarter.

He kicked it before the siren but then the siren went through well before the Essendon defender punched it through.

Why would it not stand?

The siren went before the Essendon player punched it. Surely once the Essendon player touches it the ball is dead.

I would get it if the punch was before the siren and then the ball went through for a point.

RB wrote:

whufc wrote:How did Dusty’s point stand at the end of the quarter.

He kicked it before the siren but then the siren went through well before the Essendon defender punched it through.

Why would it not stand?

The siren went before the Essendon player punched it. Surely once the Essendon player touches it the ball is dead.

I would get it if the punch was before the siren and then the ball went through for a point.

whufc wrote:

RB wrote:

whufc wrote:How did Dusty’s point stand at the end of the quarter.

He kicked it before the siren but then the siren went through well before the Essendon defender punched it through.

Why would it not stand?

The siren went before the Essendon player punched it. Surely once the Essendon player touches it the ball is dead.

I would get it if the punch was before the siren and then the ball went through for a point.

Scores always count after play has ended even it is touched by another player unless the behind was not assisted by a player from the same team.

Brodlach wrote:Knew the Eagles were ordinary but gee whiz!

woeful dont even look interested

Carlton being rag dolled by Collingwood.

Mitch McGovern has come off the line of the ball twice already…. Money well spent.

locky801 wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Knew the Eagles were ordinary but gee whiz!

woeful dont even look interested

The Eagles took just one mark inside 50.
I listened to most of the game on the radio and it was an absolute drubbing! West Coast continue to go backwards.

mots02 wrote:Carlton being rag dolled by Collingwood.

Mitch McGovern has come off the line of the ball twice already…. Money well spent.

They are clearly juicing, look at Pendleburys arms, twice the size of last season reminds me of Bartel back in 2007

The injury excuse is an absolute cop out too for West Coast.
The Essendon top up sides of 2016 never got beaten by this much against the best sides let alone a bog average Hawks side that will finish bottom 4 this year. The West Coast players have simply given up

whufc wrote:

RB wrote:

whufc wrote:How did Dusty’s point stand at the end of the quarter.

He kicked it before the siren but then the siren went through well before the Essendon defender punched it through.

Why would it not stand?

The siren went before the Essendon player punched it. Surely once the Essendon player touches it the ball is dead.

The rule being as it is means that a touched behind after the siren functions just as a touched behind during the quarter.

Jim05 wrote:The injury excuse is an absolute cop out too for West Coast.
The Essendon top up sides of 2016 never got beaten by this much against the best sides let alone a bog average Hawks side that will finish bottom 4 this year. The West Coast players have simply given up

Yep, nobody gave a **** today.

Massive changes needed. Just burn the place down and start again.

I really enjoyed that, I loved the way that the boys kept on fighting out until the end even though things didn't go there way.

And for the record I am talking about my sons under 8s soccer side....

might be 100 point drubbing here as well

Free kick Curnow.

Brutal knee to the side of the head in the Saints Giants game

close game in western sydney

The softest free in the history of game paid against Greene there.

Armchair expert wrote:The softest free in the history of game paid against Greene there.

because it was Toby