MRP at it again

[MatteeG]

IMHO the Chappy hit looked worse than the Buddy one...

cos Gray flopped as usual

Very silly for him to leave the ground, but the force wasnt that hard.

Yep leaving the ground is where he went wrong. Would have nailed him harder if he didnt jump IMO.

[Booney]

IMHO the Chappy hit looked worse than the Buddy one...

cos Gray flopped as usual

Very silly for him to leave the ground, but the force wasnt that hard.

Chapman left the ground and hit Gray in the head. ...Gray flopped again...

[Footy Smart]

IMHO the Chappy hit looked worse than the Buddy one...

cos Gray flopped as usual

Very silly for him to leave the ground, but the force wasnt that hard.

Chapman left the ground and hit Gray in the head. ...Gray flopped again...

Get those teal coloured glasses of booney, he definately flopped, stupid by chapman no doubt - force wise Buddies IMO had more in it.

[Frosty]

As much as it hurts me to say it the Chapman decision is probably correct when you look at other similar scenarios from this season. Doesn't make it right in the overall context of the game and the softness that has become the norm - let's face it, the bump is dead!!!
As for Robbie Gray flopping - I actually don't mind him as a player but if he starts going all Gavin Wanganeen then I'm off him. The Chapman love tap and the earlier alleged push in the back from Josh Hunt that wouldn't have knocked my 8 month old daughter over are both beneath you Robbie. Stand up and play like a man!!!

[valleys07]

earlier alleged push in the back from Josh Hunt that wouldn't have knocked my 8 month old daughter over are both beneath you Robbie. Stand up and play like a man!!!

Hunt actually did land on his back, but through no fault of Hunt- the poor bloke almost had his nose wiped across his face courtesy of Gray throwing his head back.

[Spargo]

Chapman got one...
Richards got a reprimand

Not the first time a swans big man gets lucky at this time of the year fronting the judiciary.

[The Sleeping Giant]

So you think he should have been suspended?

[Spargo]

So you think he should have been suspended?

All 3 players (Buddy, Chappy & Richards)lined up their target. All 3 made head high contact. Only 2 got suspended.
I wish none got rubbed out but going on the other 2 then yes, your bloke should've copped a week.

[helicopterking]

I blame Malceski for me not being able to see Franklin last game and now Chapman this weekend.
If he didn't collapse(dive) like he was dead, Franklin would have been cleared, Chapman would have been cleared.
And for this I hope Freo go to town on Sydney.

[The Sleeping Giant]

[daysofourlives]

I blame Malceski for me not being able to see Franklin last game and now Chapman this weekend.
If he didn't collapse(dive) like he was dead, Franklin would have been cleared, Chapman would have been cleared.
And for this I hope Freo go to town on Sydney.

Funny how a club can that you play the next week has so much influence over wether or not your player gets suspended, absolute F&^%# joke.
And that is why $ydney has no respect or admiration from me anymore just a dog of a club and lets hope Malceski gets his just desserts.
Is Malceski gay?

[Frosty]

“As long as it's not heinous, it isn’t malicious, it isn’t untoward ... this should be met with a down the field, a 50 metre (penalty), or even ... a fine of $900”

Dermott Brereton nailed it!!!! Most sensible thing I've seen written about this whole mess in a long time - sod off Mark Fraser, put Dermie in charge of the MRP.

[Jim05]

“As long as it's not heinous, it isn’t malicious, it isn’t untoward ... this should be met with a down the field, a 50 metre (penalty), or even ... a fine of $900”

Dermott Brereton nailed it!!!! Most sensible thing I've seen written about this whole mess in a long time - sod off Mark Fraser, put Dermie in charge of the MRP.

Spot on, if there is no injury just a free down the ground would suffice.
The whole system is a joke, how Chapman gets a week for that yet McKernan gets stuff all for elbowing a guy in the face

[Armytank]

Exactly, it is getting ridiculous.

But don't blame Malceski, if Franklin hit you, you would be a quivering mess crying for your mummy.

He may have flopped like a rag doll but is no orfan this year

[daysofourlives]

Exactly, it is getting ridiculous.

But don't blame Malceski, if Franklin hit you, you would be a quivering mess crying for your mummy.

He may have flopped like a rag doll but is no orfan this year

What happened to cracking down on staging?
Suspend someone for it and it will stop.
Why did they bring in the rule to enable them to suspend someone if they are not going to use it. Could have got Christensen for it last week or Selwood any week
I dont just blame Malceski i also blame that dog of a club he plays for

[woodublieve12]

Exactly, it is getting ridiculous.

But don't blame Malceski, if Franklin hit you, you would be a quivering mess crying for your mummy.

He may have flopped like a rag doll but is no orfan this year

What happened to cracking down on staging?
Suspend someone for it and it will stop.
Why did they bring in the rule to enable them to suspend someone if they are not going to use it. Could have got Christensen for it last week or Selwood any week
I dont just blame Malceski i also blame that dog of a club he plays for

[daysofourlives]

Exactly, it is getting ridiculous.

But don't blame Malceski, if Franklin hit you, you would be a quivering mess crying for your mummy.

He may have flopped like a rag doll but is no orfan this year

What happened to cracking down on staging?
Suspend someone for it and it will stop.
Why did they bring in the rule to enable them to suspend someone if they are not going to use it. Could have got Christensen for it last week or Selwood any week
I dont just blame Malceski i also blame that dog of a club he plays for

Faggot

[woodublieve12]

[helicopterking]

Exactly, it is getting ridiculous.

But don't blame Malceski, if Franklin hit you, you would be a quivering mess crying for your mummy.

He may have flopped like a rag doll but is no orfan this year

What happened to cracking down on staging?
Suspend someone for it and it will stop.
Why did they bring in the rule to enable them to suspend someone if they are not going to use it. Could have got Christensen for it last week or Selwood any week
I dont just blame Malceski i also blame that dog of a club he plays for

Staging for a free kick, it happens and they walk away embarrassed.
Staging for someone to get suspended, you walk away a disgrace.

[gossipgirl]

Exactly, it is getting ridiculous.

But don't blame Malceski, if Franklin hit you, you would be a quivering mess crying for your mummy.

He may have flopped like a rag doll but is no orfan this year

What happened to cracking down on staging?
Suspend someone for it and it will stop.
Why did they bring in the rule to enable them to suspend someone if they are not going to use it. Could have got Christensen for it last week or Selwood any week
I dont just blame Malceski i also blame that dog of a club he plays for

hopefully the karma bus comes along