Chris Judd - to Collingwood?

[Pup]

What a joke

Says he only wants to leave WCE to be closer to family then surely he should do the right thing by the club and give them a couple of clubs so they can get the best deal. But no, he will choose Collingwood because Eddie has been talking to him during the year and can give Twigley a leg up in the media. Makes me sick

I am sure the club would take players if they were young and good enough to make our 22 every week SD but if Collingwood offer crappy picks with a second rate player because they know he wont go anywhere else, i would be more than happy for the club to say try your luck in the PSD with the tigers and good luck for the next 3 years not playing finals footy.

I hope he makes a decision either way soon so we can all stop hearing about it because to be honest our club has got bigger issues at hand than Chris Judd.

[sydney-dog]

Pup

the mail from WA is that the Eagles believe the deal with the Pies was done some time ago, and the Eagles are prepared to lose Judd for nothing rather than deal with Collingwood, similar to the Power Stevens situation

Judd may nominate the Pies, however, getting thier is his and his managements biggest challenge

[Psyber]

Sounds like the AFL should disband and hand over Collingwood to the Tigers as a fitting reward for their poaching behaviour. That would solve a lot of problems!

[the joker]

its a two horse race now. he has also told essendon he wont go there either

[Dirko]

I can see this being ala Nick Stevens revisited..
He will nominate the Pies. They won't get a deal. Into PSD and then bingo Blues pick himup !!

[THE MOLE]

Judd to annonce that hes signed with the blues today or tomorrow!!!!
Finally, something to look forward tooooo!!!

[Dogwatcher]

I've hear he'll be happy to sit out a season if he doesn't get the deal he wants. From a fairly good source too.

[blink]

I heard that too dogwatcher!

Maybe taking a year off would do wonders for his career. Really give his groin time to heal, and also get rid of all those nagging injuries.

Look at what having a year off did for Warney's career...

[Dogwatcher]

Gave him more time to get on his phone....

[FlyingHigh]

If Judd did end up at Collingwood, it would be somewhat ironic that a team that has earnt the respect of the footy world this year through the fighting efforts of their kids, picks up one of the most respected (leaving talent aside for a minute) players in footy, and everyone would instantly hate them.

[Dogwatcher]

We're used to that sort of thing FH.

[SCD]

If Judd did end up at Collingwood, it would be somewhat ironic that a team that has earnt the respect of the footy world this year through the fighting efforts of their kids, picks up one of the most respected (leaving talent aside for a minute) players in footy, and everyone would instantly hate them.

People instantly hate Collingwood anyway..
doesn't matter if they have Judd or not, it's just no one wants them to get any advantage...
How could a Melbourne supporter as a kid honestly choose to go to Collingwood though it would surely be a turn up

[FlyingHigh]

More than usual then DW. Or perhaps I should have said lose that respect, as if it did hapeen, you'd think anything less than GF appearance is not good enough

[Punk Rooster]

pathetic & very immature attitude by some people here- Collingwood are entitled to persue Judd just as everyone else is.
If he ends up at Collingwood, get over it, because if he doesn't, I know I'll get over it very quickly...

[Dogwatcher]

I'm curious to know why WCE won't trade with Collingwood...

[GWW]

I'm curious to know why WCE won't trade with Collingwood...

I'm not sure, but wasnt there a minor verbal war after the final in Perth about a month ago, cant remember what it was all about.

[ORDoubleBlues]

I'm curious to know why WCE won't trade with Collingwood...

I'm not sure, but wasnt there a minor verbal war after the final in Perth about a month ago, cant remember what it was all about.

Someone mentioned further back that West Coast are of the belief that something was worked out between Judd and Collingwood months ago.

[Dogwatcher]

announcement coming now I reckon

[Punk Rooster]

What a joke

Says he only wants to leave WCE to be closer to family then surely he should do the right thing by the club and give them a couple of clubs so they can get the best deal. But no, he will choose Collingwood because Eddie has been talking to him during the year and can give Twigley a leg up in the media. Makes me sick

I am sure the club would take players if they were young and good enough to make our 22 every week SD but if Collingwood offer crappy picks with a second rate player because they know he wont go anywhere else, i would be more than happy for the club to say try your luck in the PSD with the tigers and good luck for the next 3 years not playing finals footy.

I hope he makes a decision either way soon so we can all stop hearing about it because to be honest our club has got bigger issues at hand than Chris Judd.

Are you still going to have a cry, now that he's nominated Carlton?

[Dirko]

Geez change the title of this thread...c'mon over Juddy !!