who the crows delist and trade this year

[Westsider]

Heard rumour that Scott Welsh may be seeking a trade to the Kangaroos next year.

Why bother lol

[sydney-dog]

Welsh to Kanga's

I doubt it, not the type of player the Kanga's need

[NFC]

Alan Obst was REALLY impressive today. Genuinely quick, aggressive and a great mark. Obviously his main flaw and his undoing was his kicking, but we drafted Gill for crying out loud and Obst is no worse.

To me Obst has massive upside. Blokes who are 192cm and that quick don't come around too often. I wouldn't mind having him back on the list because with a bit of work on the kicking he could be a decent AFL player.

[Killa]

Best thing for the crows is look around first.
One of the Johnson brothers at Essendon wants out with a fresh start
Carlton delisted Teague
Didak
And that is just off top my head

Players need to be traded
McGregor
Doughty
Meesen
Hudson

Players are Gone
Roo
Perie
Jerihco

Players must keep
Campbell
Welsh
Mattner

Players must get out of SANFL
Greenwood- Plays for Port Adelaide, tough quick and reminds me of a davey and wells type of player.
J Wunke- Plays for North is only 17, has a great set of hands and reminds me on a Westoff type of player.
Blackwell- Take a wildcard on a player, he mature and maybe a way to go to toughn up midfield
Hurley- Played at Sturt done a knee, SA's captain last year, worth a punt. Appraintly should have been taken.

[Dirko]

Carlton delisted Teague
Blackwell- Take a wildcard on a player, he mature and maybe a way to go to toughn up midfield

Killa,

Teague was a good player but too slow for the game. Tough as nail though...
Backwell, was delisted by Carlton also. Good player, won BOTH the Liston
& Magarey but IMO too small for AFL football. He's now 27 and would be a big gamble.

[NFC]

Players must get out of SANFL
Greenwood- Plays for Port Adelaide, tough quick and reminds me of a davey and wells type of player.
J Wunke- Plays for North is only 17, has a great set of hands and reminds me on a Westoff type of player.
Blackwell- Take a wildcard on a player, he mature and maybe a way to go to toughn up midfield
Hurley- Played at Sturt done a knee, SA's captain last year, worth a punt. Appraintly should have been taken.

Have no interest in any of those players.

Hurley's disposal is what cost him a place on an AFL list, and a year out with a knee reconstruction wouldn’t have done him any favours considering he was slow as it was.

[sydney-dog]

this time of year, everyone mentions Hurley, get over it, he will not get drafted

[stan]

Best thing for the crows is look around first.
One of the Johnson brothers at Essendon wants out with a fresh start
Carlton delisted Teague
Didak
And that is just off top my head

Players need to be traded
McGregor
Doughty
Meesen
Hudson

Players are Gone
Roo
Perie
Jerihco

Players must keep
Campbell
Welsh
Mattner

Players must get out of SANFL
Greenwood- Plays for Port Adelaide, tough quick and reminds me of a davey and wells type of player.
J Wunke- Plays for North is only 17, has a great set of hands and reminds me on a Westoff type of player.
Blackwell- Take a wildcard on a player, he mature and maybe a way to go to toughn up midfield
Hurley- Played at Sturt done a knee, SA's captain last year, worth a punt. Appraintly should have been taken.

I cant see you getting much for him. Maybe a 3rd round pick, but thats pushing it.

As for the others, well there pretty much gone anyway. Will be interesting to see what the crows can get from trade week.

[Aerie]

Alan Obst was REALLY impressive today. Genuinely quick, aggressive and a great mark. Obviously his main flaw and his undoing was his kicking, but we drafted Gill for crying out loud and Obst is no worse.

To me Obst has massive upside. Blokes who are 192cm and that quick don't come around too often. I wouldn't mind having him back on the list because with a bit of work on the kicking he could be a decent AFL player.

I'd rather Havelberg and Salter than Obst. Though, that was the best game I've seen Obst play yesterday.

[smac]

Alan Obst was REALLY impressive today. Genuinely quick, aggressive and a great mark. Obviously his main flaw and his undoing was his kicking, but we drafted Gill for crying out loud and Obst is no worse.

To me Obst has massive upside. Blokes who are 192cm and that quick don't come around too often. I wouldn't mind having him back on the list because with a bit of work on the kicking he could be a decent AFL player.

I'd rather Havelberg and Salter than Obst. Though, that was the best game I've seen Obst play yesterday.

Best game I've seen him play too. And Havelberg is running on the credits earnt by kicking 14 in one game. He works hard but doesn't seem to quite have "it" (whatever that is...).

[Killa]

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2007 2:54 pm

Re: who the crows delist and trade this year
Killa wrote:
Players must get out of SANFL
Greenwood- Plays for Port Adelaide, tough quick and reminds me of a davey and wells type of player.
J Wunke- Plays for North is only 17, has a great set of hands and reminds me on a Westoff type of player.
Blackwell- Take a wildcard on a player, he mature and maybe a way to go to toughn up midfield
Hurley- Played at Sturt done a knee, SA's captain last year, worth a punt. Appraintly should have been taken.

Have no interest in any of those players.

Hurley's disposal is what cost him a place on an AFL list, and a year out with a knee reconstruction wouldn’t have done him any favours considering he was slow as it was.

Haven't you seen greenwood play. averages nearly 20 touches a game been in Port best for most of the year. He was SA's best player in the U/18's Chapionships and miss out in All-Australian side, but I don't know how. Basically have you seen this kid play because he is hard as nails. Greenwood is a top 10 draft pick.
With Wunke all I would do is put him on the Rookie list while he is only 17 with a big future.

However SA teams have the best chance by picking a 22 to 25 year olds who is matured and ready for AFL.

[Blue Boy]

this time of year, everyone mentions Hurley, get over it, he will not get drafted

Syd a bit harsh - has your source told you this !!!

[MW]

Welsh to Kanga's

I doubt it, not the type of player the Kanga's need

Wasnt Welsh a premiership player with the Kangas in 99?

[Felch]

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2007 2:54 pm

Re: who the crows delist and trade this year
Killa wrote:
Players must get out of SANFL
Greenwood- Plays for Port Adelaide, tough quick and reminds me of a davey and wells type of player.
J Wunke- Plays for North is only 17, has a great set of hands and reminds me on a Westoff type of player.
Blackwell- Take a wildcard on a player, he mature and maybe a way to go to toughn up midfield
Hurley- Played at Sturt done a knee, SA's captain last year, worth a punt. Appraintly should have been taken.

Have no interest in any of those players.

Hurley's disposal is what cost him a place on an AFL list, and a year out with a knee reconstruction wouldn’t have done him any favours considering he was slow as it was.

Haven't you seen greenwood play. averages nearly 20 touches a game been in Port best for most of the year. He was SA's best player in the U/18's Chapionships and miss out in All-Australian side, but I don't know how. Basically have you seen this kid play because he is hard as nails. Greenwood is a top 10 draft pick.
With Wunke all I would do is put him on the Rookie list while he is only 17 with a big future.

However SA teams have the best chance by picking a 22 to 25 year olds who is matured and ready for AFL.

Greenwood can play and is worth looking at IMO, but i reckon he might be gone by Adelaide's first pick.

[the joker]

Welsh to Kanga's

I doubt it, not the type of player the Kanga's need

Wasnt Welsh a premiership player with the Kangas in 99?

there is no welsh will want to leave crows. he has ben offered another contract. just started a family, has some business here and he left North in the first place because he hates the Melbourne lifestyle

[the joker]

Adelaide would lose Hudson and McGregor to the Bulldogs - and its No. 10 draft pick to Brisbane.

In return, the Crows get, with these advantages:

ROOKIE ruckman Cameron Wood, 20, who would return home to be part of an inexperienced Adelaide ruck unit working to the lead of Rhett Biglands in his comeback season from a serious knee injury.

DEFENDER Jordan McMahon, 24, who allows Craig to finally release Graham Johncock from Adelaide's back six to play in the midfield rotations.

PACY key position player Stephen Tiller, 20, who offers speed to a team needing it.

DRAFT pick No. 5 from the Bulldogs that advances the Crows five spots from the No. 10 it currently holds and sends to Brisbane in return for Wood. This enhances Adelaide's hopes of claiming Port Adelaide Magpies midfielder-forward and SA under-18 captain Brad Ebert in November's national draft.

[silicone skyline]

Adelaide would lose Hudson and McGregor to the Bulldogs - and its No. 10 draft pick to Brisbane.

In return, the Crows get, with these advantages:

ROOKIE ruckman Cameron Wood, 20, who would return home to be part of an inexperienced Adelaide ruck unit working to the lead of Rhett Biglands in his comeback season from a serious knee injury.

DEFENDER Jordan McMahon, 24, who allows Craig to finally release Graham Johncock from Adelaide's back six to play in the midfield rotations.

PACY key position player Stephen Tiller, 20, who offers speed to a team needing it.

DRAFT pick No. 5 from the Bulldogs that advances the Crows five spots from the No. 10 it currently holds and sends to Brisbane in return for Wood. This enhances Adelaide's hopes of claiming Port Adelaide Magpies midfielder-forward and SA under-18 captain Brad Ebert in November's national draft.

Agreed, that's both a realistic and positive outcome.

[the joker]

on the crows shopping list are Didak, Aaron Davey,Brad Ottens and justin Westhoff... cant see Ottens or Westhoff being released by there clubs though

Rumours about Didak are rubbish. He will not be moving from Collingwood, especially to a club with a losing culture like Adelaide.

losing culture???? how many times have the fagpies finished in the bottom 4 in the last ten years compared to the crows.

[NFC]

Alan Obst was REALLY impressive today. Genuinely quick, aggressive and a great mark. Obviously his main flaw and his undoing was his kicking, but we drafted Gill for crying out loud and Obst is no worse.

To me Obst has massive upside. Blokes who are 192cm and that quick don't come around too often. I wouldn't mind having him back on the list because with a bit of work on the kicking he could be a decent AFL player.

I'd rather Havelberg and Salter than Obst. Though, that was the best game I've seen Obst play yesterday.

Pass on Havelberg. Too slow, lumbering to play a KPP at AFL level.

[NFC]

Greenwood can play and is worth looking at IMO, but i reckon he might be gone by Adelaide's first pick.

There is NO way Greenwood will be gone by pick 10. NO WAY.