Retirements and Delistings

[Footy Smart]

Sorry I forgot I wasn't allowed to provide an alternative and possibly negative opinion on a crows player.... rattle rattle rattle

You most certainly are allowed to, but negative crows based posts are all you do provide on this site. This would be fine if your comments were provided with some context and some evidence to substantiate your opinion.

Mate... firstly I have provided plenty of negative Power post on this site (refer to countless Trengrove/pfieffer baggings)... maybe you only see the crows ones...
And do I need to provide evidence that Goodes killed Van Berlo in the first half of that final coming of VB's wing?

geez, pfieffer is stiff at least he has a crack

And yes, I agree he towled us up in that first half, however in the context conversation it was an invalid and negative point.... and one game doesn’t make a season

Im more than happy to discuss AFC in a negative context if the conversation isn’t based on blatant bias and un supported.

I mean when we lose on the weekend which is highly likely, some say certain. There will be threads created blatantly abusing AFC for really no reason other than some on hear hate AFC for whatever reason and don’t like conversing sensibly.

[Brodlach]

Who do you support scoob?

Port Adelaide Brod

Thanks, explains a bit

[scoob]

Sorry I forgot I wasn't allowed to provide an alternative and possibly negative opinion on a crows player.... rattle rattle rattle

You most certainly are allowed to, but negative crows based posts are all you do provide on this site. This would be fine if your comments were provided with some context and some evidence to substantiate your opinion.

Mate... firstly I have provided plenty of negative Power post on this site (refer to countless Trengrove/pfieffer baggings)... maybe you only see the crows ones...
And do I need to provide evidence that Goodes killed Van Berlo in the first half of that final coming of VB's wing?

geez, pfieffer is stiff at least he has a crack

And yes, I agree he towled us up in that first half, however in the context conversation it was an invalid and negative point.... and one game doesn’t make a season

Im more than happy to discuss AFC in a negative context if the conversation isn’t based on blatant bias and un supported.

I mean when we lose on the weekend which is highly likely, some say certain. There will be threads created blatantly abusing AFC for really no reason other than some on hear hate AFC for whatever reason and don’t like conversing sensibly.

He can crack all he likes but if you turn the ball over every second possession you are open to criticism.

Fair enough with the rest of the post - but there is a massive bias towards adelaide in the press and a large bias to adelaide on here... and IMHO Van Berlo is very average AFL player and if his role is a run with role then I don't think he is particularly good at it - as highlighted by Adam Goodes in the first final

[scoob]

Who do you support scoob?

Port Adelaide Brod

Thanks, explains a bit

Like what?

[Squids]

Van Berlo is very average but there is no shame in getting toweled up by Goodes.

[Brodlach]

IMO your argument about Van Berlo has no basis to it.

He would be a walkup start at Port.

I am not saying that as a Crows supporter but a footy fan. It is easy to say "wasn't allowed to provide an alternative and possibly negative opinion on a crows player" but you can when your comment has actual merit or fact.

[Squids]

IMO your argument about Van Berlo has no basis to it.

He would be a walkup start at Port.

I am not saying that as a Crows supporter but a footy fan. It is easy to say "wasn't allowed to provide an alternative and possibly negative opinion on a crows player" but you can when your comment has actual merit or fact.

Terrible argument.

[scoob]

IMO your argument about Van Berlo has no basis to it.

He would be a walkup start at Port.

I am not saying that as a Crows supporter but a footy fan. It is easy to say "wasn't allowed to provide an alternative and possibly negative opinion on a crows player" but you can when your comment has actual merit or fact.

Of course he would be a walk up at Port, I think you and I would be walk up's at Port. That doesn't make him a good AFL player - westhoff is a walk up at port, Trengrove is supposedly a leader!?!?!

Ok so I can only offer my opinion when you think it has merit or fact. Fact Goodes killed VB. Fact VB can shirk the issue at times. Fact he is not a game breaker. If being a good runner and being good on the track is the criteria that you want in a captain then he is ideal.

[UK Fan]

Sounds like someone rubbished a crows player.

The gollums are out in full force protecting their "precious" today.

[gossipgirl]

Van Berlo is very average but there is no shame in getting toweled up by Goodes.

Walkup start at Carlton as well

[Brodlach]

Sounds like someone rubbished a crows player.

The gollums are out in full force protecting their "precious" today.

Not at all.

Scoob, Dane Swan or Gary Ablett ever get beaten by their opposition player on the day? Never seen Van Berlo ever shirk an issue.

Cassissi or VB captain of my team, I know who I would pick everday of the week.

[Squids]

Van Berlo is very average but there is no shame in getting toweled up by Goodes.

Walkup start at Carlton as well

Mclean Judd Simpson Murphy Robinson Walker Carrazzoo

guess again champ.

[Mr Beefy]

Sounds like someone rubbished a crows player.

The gollums are out in full force protecting their "precious" today.

Not at all.

Scoob, Dane Swan or Gary Ablett ever get beaten by their opposition player on the day? Never seen Van Berlo ever shirk an issue.

Cassissi or VB captain of my team, I know who I would pick everday of the week.

Given that Cassisi plays for another team, I guess you dont have a choice.

[scoob]

Sounds like someone rubbished a crows player.

The gollums are out in full force protecting their "precious" today.

Not at all.

Scoob, Dane Swan or Gary Ablett ever get beaten by their opposition player on the day? Never seen Van Berlo ever shirk an issue.

Cassissi or VB captain of my team, I know who I would pick everday of the week.

Swan / Ablett beaten - very very rarely!

If you haven't seen him shirk the issue you obviously don't watch him enough.

and Cassisi or VB poor arguement again... Scott Thompson >>>>>>>>> VB in captains stakes

[Brodlach]

Van Berlo is very average but there is no shame in getting toweled up by Goodes.

Walkup start at Carlton as well

Mclean Judd Simpson Murphy Robinson Walker Carrazzoo

guess again champ.

Gun midfielders theses, hows their finals appearances going this year?

[Brodlach]

Sounds like someone rubbished a crows player.

The gollums are out in full force protecting their "precious" today.

Not at all.

Scoob, Dane Swan or Gary Ablett ever get beaten by their opposition player on the day? Never seen Van Berlo ever shirk an issue.

Cassissi or VB captain of my team, I know who I would pick everday of the week.

Swan / Ablett beaten - very very rarely!

If you haven't seen him shirk the issue you obviously don't watch him enough.

and Cassisi or VB poor arguement again... Scott Thompson >>>>>>>>> VB in captains stakes

Talking captains, Thompson is not the captain

[Squids]

Van Berlo is very average but there is no shame in getting toweled up by Goodes.

Walkup start at Carlton as well

Mclean Judd Simpson Murphy Robinson Walker Carrazzoo

guess again champ.

Gun midfielders theses, hows their finals appearances going this year?

How were Van Berlo's finals appearances the last couple of years?

[scoob]

Sounds like someone rubbished a crows player.

The gollums are out in full force protecting their "precious" today.

Not at all.

Scoob, Dane Swan or Gary Ablett ever get beaten by their opposition player on the day? Never seen Van Berlo ever shirk an issue.

Cassissi or VB captain of my team, I know who I would pick everday of the week.

Swan / Ablett beaten - very very rarely!

If you haven't seen him shirk the issue you obviously don't watch him enough.

and Cassisi or VB poor arguement again... Scott Thompson >>>>>>>>> VB in captains stakes

Talking captains, Thompson is not the captain

Neither is Swan

[Brodlach]

Van Berlo is very average but there is no shame in getting toweled up by Goodes.

Mclean Judd Simpson Murphy Robinson Walker Carrazzoo

guess again champ.

Gun midfielders theses, hows their finals appearances going this year?

How were Van Berlo's finals appearances the last couple of years?

He was pretty good last week

[Brodlach]

Sounds like someone rubbished a crows player.

The gollums are out in full force protecting their "precious" today.

Not at all.

Scoob, Dane Swan or Gary Ablett ever get beaten by their opposition player on the day? Never seen Van Berlo ever shirk an issue.

Cassissi or VB captain of my team, I know who I would pick everday of the week.

Swan / Ablett beaten - very very rarely!

If you haven't seen him shirk the issue you obviously don't watch him enough.

and Cassisi or VB poor arguement again... Scott Thompson >>>>>>>>> VB in captains stakes

Talking captains, Thompson is not the captain

Perhaps I should have highlighted these quotes