2010 Brownlow Medal Count - Live scores *SPOILER ALERT*

[Voice]

A Footballing mercenary that was lured to salary cap cheats by a corporate criminal. Eye gouged a player in last year's finals and elbowed Pavlich this season (luckily that isn't suspendable for some reason). There were no winners tonight.

1. He wanted to go home.
2. Carlton's backers and administrators weren't his fault.
3. He served his suspension for the gouging incident.
4. Probably lucky with the Pavlich hit.
5. A humble and well spoken winner.

Bitter much?

Just stating facts. Besides wasn't he going home to Melbourne the team he followed as a kid?

No, he was going home to Melbourne, the place where he grew up. Speaking of growing up........

[hotpies]

The look on Eddie's face was priceless.

Hopefully we see more of that on Saturday.

Swan looked like a spoilt brat that had his toy taken away. Then straight on to his phone and looked to be txt’n. What a sore loser.

Well done Judd a humble winner.

I think- Swan was nervous as all ****, as the Media made him a red hot favourite, & he didn't look comfortable dealing with the pressure.

Swan looked very nervous, but he was still robbed!

[Media Park]

Thank you KB...

[Johno6]

Priceless

[Johno6]

p.s that crap at the start where they walked ablett n swan out makes them look more like knobs now neither of them won...

it was so frickin cheesey

[Booney]

to the people who took the $1.70 on offer for Swan to win.

Were they all unaware of a bloke called Pendelbury?

[JK]

Other than adding a fair stack to the wallet, obviously only special players in history get remembered as triple medallists and IMHO Juddy fits that bill.

... even though he's only won 2.

He won't make 3 because the umpires made fools of themselves last night and will mark him far harder in future.

Yep oops, my bad .. Hope he does make it 3 though, has been a brilliant footballer, perhaps those bitching and moaning about the result forget that sometimes.

[Leaping Lindner]

A Footballing mercenary that was lured to salary cap cheats by a corporate criminal. Eye gouged a player in last year's finals and elbowed Pavlich this season (luckily that isn't suspendable for some reason). There were no winners tonight.

1. He wanted to go home.
2. Carlton's backers and administrators weren't his fault.
3. He served his suspension for the gouging incident.
4. Probably lucky with the Pavlich hit.
5. A humble and well spoken winner.
Bitter much?

Just stating facts. Besides wasn't he going home to Melbourne the team he followed as a kid?

No, he was going home to Melbourne, the place where he grew up. Speaking of growing up........

Um no. I saw an interview with him and footage of him strolling around Melbourne's training ground when he first came back.
"Very excited to be back here in Victoria and with a chance to play for the club I followed as a kid etc....." And then the meeting with Richard Pratt was arranged and......
Again just stating facts.
Being told to grow up by someone from the Sturt Cheer Squad....the irony is killing me

[Hondo]

I like Dane Swan as a footballer and these are some points that may give his fans some comfort re the Brownlow:

- he polled better than ever before
- the sharing of votes with Pendlebury vindicates the "champion team, not a team of champions" tag

When people talk about Swan the first thing they say is his fitness ("gut running"). He runs and runs and runs and gets lots of possessions as a result. No one else can keep up with him. I have heard him described as untaggable. These are all positive compliements. He'd be a huge asset to any side. However, to be brutally honest the Brownlow isn't about the best, fairest and fittest.

So, given he has Pendles to compete with and given he arguably doesn't have the same natural talent as an Ablett or a Judd then his 24 votes could be seen as terrific achievement and make him not too far away from winning one.

[Leaping Lindner]

For my mind, a very deserving winner.

Good post CK.

Leaping Lindner....

You sound like a senile old jealous fool. Glad you post on here as your sour grape ramblings made me have a good laugh.

Thanks !

It's a football FORUM not a football circle jerk. People are allowed to have opposing views SJABC.
Glad you got a laugh out of it though , I suppose you need one after last weekend

[Media Park]

I'm not entirely sure which poster is having a bigger bleed here, but it's making my day...

Congrats again Juddy, bad luck Gaz, and the Collywobble who finished third...

[JK]

If Gaz had won the medal would he have had to present it to himself?

[Gingernuts]

History is littered with blokes who were 'robbed' of the Brownlow. In the end I'm sure all Swan cares about is getting the premiership medal on Saturday.

[Rik E Boy]

Chris Judd BWAHAHAHA. Just goes to show what can happen when you are a one man team.

regards,

REB

[Gingernuts]

Chris Judd BWAHAHAHA. Just goes to show what can happen when you are a one man team.

regards,

REB

Only a few more days with that avatar REB??

[Dirko]

It's a football FORUM not a football circle jerk. People are allowed to have opposing views SJABC.
Glad you got a laugh out of it though , I suppose you need one after last weekend

jerk ! LOL. More ramblings from the senile.....

Keep it up "circle man". At least we had a game last weekend...

Chris Judd BWAHAHAHA. Just goes to show what can happen when you are a one man team.

Quite right REB. Gazza was thinking the same thing for next season when he's at the Gold Coast.

[Leaping Lindner]

It's a football FORUM not a football circle jerk. People are allowed to have opposing views SJABC.
Glad you got a laugh out of it though , I suppose you need one after last weekend

jerk ! LOL. More ramblings from the senile.....

Keep it up "circle man". At least we had a game last weekend...

Chris Judd BWAHAHAHA. Just goes to show what can happen when you are a one man team.

Quite right REB. Gazza was thinking the same thing for next season when he's at the Gold Coast.

Pity you didn't turn up.

[overloaded]

[quot

Judd 30, Hodge 16 ... umpires are wanting us to believe Judd had twice the season Hodge did? I don't think so. Even Judd himself said his season wasn't good enough to win ... he's right.

Umpires are a mob of white maggots.

Judd should do the right thing and hand back the medal to the AFL and pass it on to someone who actually had some competition in their side

[Wedgie]

The MVP is like the Cox Plate and the Brownlow is like the Melbourne Cup.
The best horse in the nation wins the Cox where quite often a scrubber gets up in the Melbourne Cup despite it being worth more money and prestige.

[Rik E Boy]

Chris Judd BWAHAHAHA. Just goes to show what can happen when you are a one man team.

Quite right REB. Gazza was thinking the same thing for next season when he's at the Gold Coast.

LMAO landed one there.

regards,

REB