Chris Judd says he wants to go to Carlton

[gadj1976]

What's to stop Richmond, fresh from dealing with Carlton, now armed with pick 2 & 3 undermining Carlton and getting Judd? I'm sure, in this situation, WCE would be better dealing with Richmond with picks 2 & 3, rather than Carlton with 1, 18 & 20 AND having no other option than to let him walk into the PSD.

I can see it backfiring big time - and in Richmonds' favour.

Also, there is talk about Carlton playing hard ball, it often comes back to haunt clubs at the negotiating table. If Carlton play hardball now, WCE may be in a position to play hard ball down the line, and with a player like Judd, it wont be forgotten about quickly nor easily.

Chris Judd has to agree with the trade aggreements aswell. was different a few years ago. the trade between Crows and Freo in 94 for chris groom to freo and Mcleod to the crows. Chris Groom was in englandwith his crows teammates got a phonecall saying your now a Docker. would have been weird talking to your (ex) team mates after that

Does a player have to agree to a situation where they finish up in the PSD though? Case in point, Nick Stevens. He specified Collingwood as his team of preference, the trade didn't happen and he finished up at Carlton.

So maybe they might not get him in the trade week, but pick him up in the PSD - which I don't think Judd has any say in - is that correct? What would happen if Sydney had pick 1 in the PSD? Could Judd go there?

[smac]

If he falls through to the PSD, any club can nab him as long as they are prepared to meet any contract terms he nominates prior to the draft.

[Hondo]

I doubt slipping through to the PSD is a scenario Judd wants to risk given all the work he has done trying to pick a club

What's to stop Richmond taking Carlton's players/draft picks and then selecting Judd anyway in the PSD Then both the blues and Eagles miss out!