Judd's gouge

[scoob]

Fair result for mine... dont think he deserved to get punished... has good record giv ehim the benefit of the doubt....

NFC... the umpires dont hence simon goodwin not winning last years medal...

Goodwin >> Cornes.

[Dutchy]

Fair result for mine... dont think he deserved to get punished... has good record giv ehim the benefit of the doubt....

NFC... the umpires dont hence simon goodwin not winning last years medal...

Goodwin >> Cornes.

In the Betting comp...Yes!!

[mypaddock]

Fair result for mine... dont think he deserved to get punished... has good record giv ehim the benefit of the doubt....

NFC... the umpires dont hence simon goodwin not winning last years medal...

was a clear eye gouge- every report should be judged on that individual incident, so wat if he had a good record- its still an eye gouge! farmer got six weeks, judd gets off, wat a farce the AFL tribunal is!

[JK]

Completely different incidents for mine MP ... Farmer went out of his way to deliberately gouge from a position where it was totally unnecessary, Judd on the bottom of a pack is more likely to be trying to shove someone off.

Plus Judd is a great ball player and Farmer is plain stupid!

Would have been happy for my Brownlow bets if Judd had been found guilty and reprimanded though

[scoob]

Fair result for mine... dont think he deserved to get punished... has good record giv ehim the benefit of the doubt....

NFC... the umpires dont hence simon goodwin not winning last years medal...

was a clear eye gouge- every report should be judged on that individual incident, so wat if he had a good record- its still an eye gouge! farmer got six weeks, judd gets off, wat a farce the AFL tribunal is!

every individual incident then you compare it too farmers?? im not sure if it was an eye guage and obviously the tribunal wasnt either and given his good record gave him the benefit of the doubt... good decision in my book.

[Gilly]

After seeing the incident a few times, Chris Judd is definitely in trouble. If he does get suspended, Chad Cornes should be the favorite for the Brownlow.

Chad Cornes?

I didn't know umpires noticed players who stood out the back of packs and collected uncontested possession after uncontested possession?

Gold NFC. If the All Australian selectors decide to name a position "loose man in defence", Cornes is a shoe in.