Page 1 of 3
worst umpiring in SANFL for a long long time

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 7:12 pm
by rubbers0ul
was an absolute disgrace, the ump in the eagles 50 was a cheat.
cooper pull sibnealer on him and gets a free; was a f****n disgrace. - possibly the worst decision ive seen ever.
and the player currie tackled placed the ball on the ground in the motion of the tackle and got a free.
an eagles player playing on after coping one around the face and getting caught a good 10metres from where he started to play on.
the eagles player that went down with an oscar due to contact about 50metres out 3rd quarter, on the reply currie didnt touch him
slade getting tackled around the face on the boundary line members side, no free.
these are just off the top of my head. the guy next to me was listening to a walkmen and he said the commentators even started laughing at some of the frees they were kicking goals from.
for me, this umpiring was worse then the deal the crows copped vs west coast.
richard williams destroyed us in the grand final last year two, when the eagles player kept faking hed been hit in the face by gowans, the reply showed that the contact was soooooooooooooooo small and the eagles player just threw his head back.

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 7:17 pm
by Rik E Boy

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 7:19 pm
by SOUTHWARK
Gee you got home quick.Didn't wait around till the end?

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 7:26 pm
by RoosterMarty
I didnt read all of that.
Re: worst umpiring in SANFL for a long long time

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 7:36 pm
by PortAdelaideProud
rubbers0ul wrote:was an absolute disgrace, the ump in the eagles 50 was a cheat.
cooper pull sibnealer on him and gets a free; was a f****n disgrace. - possibly the worst decision ive seen ever.
and the player currie tackled placed the ball on the ground in the motion of the tackle and got a free.
an eagles player playing on after coping one around the face and getting caught a good 10metres from where he started to play on.
the eagles player that went down with an oscar due to contact about 50metres out 3rd quarter, on the reply currie didnt touch him
slade getting tackled around the face on the boundary line members side, no free.
these are just off the top of my head. the guy next to me was listening to a walkmen and he said the commentators even started laughing at some of the frees they were kicking goals from.
for me, this umpiring was worse then the deal the crows copped vs west coast.
richard williams destroyed us in the grand final last year two, when the eagles player kept faking hed been hit in the face by gowans, the reply showed that the contact was soooooooooooooooo small and the eagles player just threw his head back.

Here's 50 cents, ring someone who cares. Centrals were crap, Eagles were great. You got beaten by a better team.
Re: worst umpiring in SANFL for a long long time

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:08 pm
by bulldog pommy
rubbers0ul wrote:was an absolute disgrace, the ump in the eagles 50 was a cheat.
cooper pull sibnealer on him and gets a free; was a f****n disgrace. - possibly the worst decision ive seen ever.
and the player currie tackled placed the ball on the ground in the motion of the tackle and got a free.
an eagles player playing on after coping one around the face and getting caught a good 10metres from where he started to play on.
the eagles player that went down with an oscar due to contact about 50metres out 3rd quarter, on the reply currie didnt touch him
slade getting tackled around the face on the boundary line members side, no free.
these are just off the top of my head. the guy next to me was listening to a walkmen and he said the commentators even started laughing at some of the frees they were kicking goals from.
for me, this umpiring was worse then the deal the crows copped vs west coast.
richard williams destroyed us in the grand final last year two, when the eagles player kept faking hed been hit in the face by gowans, the reply showed that the contact was soooooooooooooooo small and the eagles player just threw his head back.
On behalf of all Central fans: you are a w@nker

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:10 pm
by Booney
Rik E Boy wrote::-({|=
If you gentlemen dont mind,I would like to add this,


Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:16 pm
by NFC
Re: worst umpiring in SANFL for a long long time

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:26 pm
by bayman
rubbers0ul wrote:was an absolute disgrace, the ump in the eagles 50 was a cheat.
cooper pull sibnealer on him and gets a free; was a f****n disgrace. - possibly the worst decision ive seen ever.
and the player currie tackled placed the ball on the ground in the motion of the tackle and got a free.
an eagles player playing on after coping one around the face and getting caught a good 10metres from where he started to play on.
the eagles player that went down with an oscar due to contact about 50metres out 3rd quarter, on the reply currie didnt touch him
slade getting tackled around the face on the boundary line members side, no free.
these are just off the top of my head. the guy next to me was listening to a walkmen and he said the commentators even started laughing at some of the frees they were kicking goals from.
for me, this umpiring was worse then the deal the crows copped vs west coast.
richard williams destroyed us in the grand final last year two, when the eagles player kept faking hed been hit in the face by gowans, the reply showed that the contact was soooooooooooooooo small and the eagles player just threw his head back.
you got comprehensively beaten & were outclassed by a committed team, your team at times were undisciplined you have pulled out a few decisions so whether your right or not with those decisions i can not phathom how they would make up 13 goals & furthermore you were never ever going to win after 1/4 time & the umps had nothing to do with it

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:33 pm
by Rushby Hinds

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:34 pm
by am Bays
Yep 5 "free" in the against you and I bet just as many would have gone against the Eagles......
So that is why you lost by 12 goals........
Can I say we offcially have a winner for the worst post of the year title sown up......
Tip mate when you lose this is the best policy

Re: worst umpiring in SANFL for a long long time

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:36 pm
by Dutchy
bulldog pommy wrote:rubbers0ul wrote:was an absolute disgrace, the ump in the eagles 50 was a cheat.
cooper pull sibnealer on him and gets a free; was a f****n disgrace. - possibly the worst decision ive seen ever.
and the player currie tackled placed the ball on the ground in the motion of the tackle and got a free.
an eagles player playing on after coping one around the face and getting caught a good 10metres from where he started to play on.
the eagles player that went down with an oscar due to contact about 50metres out 3rd quarter, on the reply currie didnt touch him
slade getting tackled around the face on the boundary line members side, no free.
these are just off the top of my head. the guy next to me was listening to a walkmen and he said the commentators even started laughing at some of the frees they were kicking goals from.
for me, this umpiring was worse then the deal the crows copped vs west coast.
richard williams destroyed us in the grand final last year two, when the eagles player kept faking hed been hit in the face by gowans, the reply showed that the contact was soooooooooooooooo small and the eagles player just threw his head back.
On behalf of all Central fans: you are a w@nker
GOLD!
I was also wondering how he got home so quick!!!!
One thing I did notice however was when Cicca went for the hanger in the last 1/4 inside 50 Richard Williams went over to him to explain the free kick he gave away and at the end of the chat shaked hands with him and patted him on the back!!! still 10 minutes to go...
Re: worst umpiring in SANFL for a long long time

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:37 pm
by Rushby Hinds
rubbers0ul wrote:was an absolute disgrace, the ump in the eagles 50 was a cheat.
cooper pull sibnealer on him and gets a free; was a f****n disgrace. - possibly the worst decision ive seen ever.
and the player currie tackled placed the ball on the ground in the motion of the tackle and got a free.
an eagles player playing on after coping one around the face and getting caught a good 10metres from where he started to play on.
the eagles player that went down with an oscar due to contact about 50metres out 3rd quarter, on the reply currie didnt touch him
slade getting tackled around the face on the boundary line members side, no free.
these are just off the top of my head. the guy next to me was listening to a walkmen and he said the commentators even started laughing at some of the frees they were kicking goals from.
for me, this umpiring was worse then the deal the crows copped vs west coast.
richard williams destroyed us in the grand final last year two, when the eagles player kept faking hed been hit in the face by gowans, the reply showed that the contact was soooooooooooooooo small and the eagles player just threw his head back.
PS it wasn't even Richard Williams that made (most) of these decisions!
LOL!!!!!!!!!!
umpires

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:40 pm
by redden whites
Maybe being a watcher with no real care in the result makes a difference but i though the men in white were exeptional today......Have not thought this all year but today first rate

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:48 pm
by stampy
some people are never satisfied 5 flags in 7 years, what i woulnt give for just one of the bastards


Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:51 pm
by dinglinga
everytime they had the camera on the gowans they were always winging to the umpires....
should be a quiet line up in centrelink tomorrow in elizabeth

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:52 pm
by sydney-dog
the umpiring was a little inconsistent at times BUT it did not effect the result and the better team won on the day
we got smashed by 10 goals, our players made more mistakes then the umpires

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:55 pm
by am Bays
Rubbers0ul proving that you don't have to have a long neck to be a goose....

Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:56 pm
by magpie in the 80's
dinglinga wrote:everytime they had the camera on the gowans they were always winging to the umpires....
should be a quiet line up in centrelink tomorrow in elizabeth
thought it would be the other way round. they would have bet all their money on a centrals win


Posted:
Sun Oct 08, 2006 8:57 pm
by SCD
If in doubt blame the umpires.. it wasn't blokes dropping there heads when they heard footsteps or the fact that at 3 quarter time the eagles had 29 shots to 5 on goal.. all we can say is cry all you like cause it won't effect the fact that the Eagles have won this year!