SA Footy

johntheclaret wrote:Take you 3 hours to come up with that little hive of activity did it

I've been busy, just droning away.

I LOVE the state game, and apart from the GF and finals, is probably my favourite game of the year. It sucks there is no SOO in AFL so this is the next best thing, even if half the players aren't from SA etc. Always nice to beat the old enemy. Disappointing that so many hate this game. Back in the day it was just about the biggest game of the year. Still is in the NRL, they do it properly...

Staggered that Jansen from the doggies hasn't been included. Best player in the comp just about. Hopefully gets added soon.

Thunderstruck wrote:I LOVE the state game

That makes two of us. Can't wait to see us kick a Vic.

Not a real Victorian team,just a C grade competition,does anyone really care.
If 950 turn up great for those involved.
We have to give up a serious game of SANFL suburban footy why?
Yet another boring bye in SA again.
That makes it 5 over the footy season,
unbelievable.
Wake up SANFL.
Such a waste of a Saturdays in footy season.
Why?

VALE PARK wrote:Not a real Victorian team,just a C grade competition,does anyone really care.
If 950 turn up great for those involved.
We have to give up a serious game of SANFL suburban footy why?
Yet another boring bye in SA again.
That makes it 5 over the footy season,
unbelievable.
Wake up SANFL.
Such a waste of a Saturdays in footy season.
Why?

Agreed,it's crap.

Riley, O'Brien and Hoskin added to the squad. Happy with those additions but still like to see Jansen selected.

Fairly inexperienced VFL side:

VFL SQUAD OF 30

BOX HILL HAWKS
MIRRA David
ILES Sam
WARREN Max

COBURG
UYSAL Ozgur

ESSENDON
COGHLAN Daniel
FERRY James

FOOTSCRAY
RUSSELL Jordan
HAYES Will
DALGLEISH Lauchlan

FRANKSTON
CAVARRA Ben

NORTH BALLARAT
KIEL Luke
RIPPON Nick

PORT MELBOURNE
HARETUKU Khan
SANDILANDS Hugh
MIHOCEK Brody

RICHMOND
DARLEY Sam

SANDRINGHAM
SIMPKIN Tom

WERRIBEE
SHERLOCK Scott
HANSON Matt
WILSON Jake
SODOMACO Michael

WILLIAMSTOWN
DUNELL Sam
GIBBONS Michael
FAULKS Peter
MASTERS Leigh
DORGAN Jack
SIPOSS Arryn
ANASTASIO Anthony
WHEELER Willie
MEESE Nick

Let's face it, the Game is NOT a 'State Game', really.
Its a Representative Game - League vs League.

The State of Origin Games of the 80's were some of the BEST Games of Footy, I have witnessed.
Seeing Kernahan, Bradley, Jarman, Platten, Naley, Lindner, Leslie, Aish, McDermott, Roberts, Motley, Fielke, Anderson, Craig, Rendell, Mickan, Parker, as well as non-selected Vics like Bolton, Schimmelbusch & Big Grenville - was wonderful.

But that all changed with the advent of the AFC.

If they are determined to play a 'State Game' every year, then surely they need to make it 'State of Origin' based?
Having 1/2 the SA side from elsewhere, doesn't really promote 'pride in the jumper' does it?
How about reference to 'those that have gone before'?
All seems a little hollow to a bloke who grew up (& probably played U/16s &/or U/18s for Vic Country or Metro) in Victoria, doesn't it?

Perhaps making it State of Origin, might increase the interest level too?

I wonder what Lindner,Euctice,Carey,Pope,Window,Simunsen,Wedding,Motley,Bagshaw,Head,Marker,Darley would be thinking?

LPH wrote:Let's face it, the Game is NOT a 'State Game', really.
Its a Representative Game - League vs League.

No its not. If the best players were selected from each league the VFL would win by 15 goals.
Its not even a representative game, its a meaningless handicapped event designed as a junket for a small group of people.

VALE PARK wrote:I wonder what Lindner,Euctice,Carey,Pope,Window,Simunsen,Wedding,Motley,Bagshaw,Head,Marker,Darley would be thinking?

That they could get a game.

Just noticed Glenelg and Eagles both have 2 byes in a row.
That is about 20 days break between games,in the middle of the footy season!
Something wrong here!

VALE PARK wrote:Just noticed Glenelg and Eagles both have 2 byes in a row.
That is about 20 days break between games,in the middle of the footy season!
Something wrong here!

Bloody hell.

VALE PARK wrote:Just noticed Glenelg and Eagles both have 2 byes in a row.
That is about 20 days break between games,in the middle of the footy season!
Something wrong here!

It's all okay though. Earlier in the season we played 3 games in 12 days.

VALE PARK wrote:Just noticed Glenelg and Eagles both have 2 byes in a row.
That is about 20 days break between games,in the middle of the footy season!
Something wrong here!

There is something wrong with the whole bloody SANFL setup, to put it mildly

VALE PARK wrote:Just noticed Glenelg and Eagles both have 2 byes in a row.
That is about 20 days break between games,in the middle of the footy season!
Something wrong here!

14 May the last game for the Eagles until Sunday 4th June. 22 days. Disgraceful. We come back play 2 more games then another bye.

The SANFL are telling the clubs to increase their income streams.
How do they achieve that with so many games '5 byes' not being played during the season.
Sponsors with signage etc and members want action on home grounds in the footy season,
not people walking their dogs with empty grandstands.

Wedgie wrote:

LPH wrote:Let's face it, the Game is NOT a 'State Game', really.
Its a Representative Game - League vs League.

No its not. If the best players were selected from each league the VFL would win by 15 goals.
Its not even a representative game, its a meaningless handicapped event designed as a junket for a small group of people.

Spot on.
Would think the VFL is made up of mainly of AFL listed players who are ineligible for the game.
The VFL reps are basically the dregs of the comp

LPH wrote:Let's face it, the Game is NOT a 'State Game', really.

Well, it never truly was until about 1980.

Wedgie wrote:

LPH wrote:Let's face it, the Game is NOT a 'State Game', really.
Its a Representative Game - League vs League.

No its not. If the best players were selected from each league the VFL would win by 15 goals.
Its not even a representative game, its a meaningless handicapped event designed as a junket for a small group of people.

Correct weight, it's a farce.