SA Footy

i think so

yes it is

I think the top 5 at the moment will all play finals, but the top 5 is far from "set". The teams that are in there will jockey for top 3 spots, and if one of them has a run of injuries or losses, they could lose their spot altogether if someone like Norwood or West string sime wins together.

Adelaide Hawk wrote:I think the top 5 at the moment will all play finals, but the top 5 is far from "set". The teams that are in there will jockey for top 3 spots, and if one of them has a run of injuries or losses, they could lose their spot altogether if someone like Norwood or West string sime wins together.

that wasn't the question & you know it but it is meant to mean that for those 5 teams 'currently' in the top 5 to stay there or not, c'mon ah it is sunday no need to be that pedantic

bayman wrote:

Adelaide Hawk wrote:I think the top 5 at the moment will all play finals, but the top 5 is far from "set". The teams that are in there will jockey for top 3 spots, and if one of them has a run of injuries or losses, they could lose their spot altogether if someone like Norwood or West string sime wins together.

that wasn't the question & you know it but it is meant to mean that for those 5 teams 'currently' in the top 5 to stay there or not, c'mon ah it is sunday no need to be that pedantic

I'm not sure what to say, I answered the question. I said if a team in the top 5 has injuries and either Norwood or West string some wins together, the top 5 could alter. So my answer was (and is) "no", it's not set.

I also said I would think the teams who already comprise the top 5 will eventually make the final 5. I don't own a crystal ball, anything could happen over the second half of the season.

Adelaide Hawk wrote:

bayman wrote:

Adelaide Hawk wrote:I think the top 5 at the moment will all play finals, but the top 5 is far from "set". The teams that are in there will jockey for top 3 spots, and if one of them has a run of injuries or losses, they could lose their spot altogether if someone like Norwood or West string sime wins together.

that wasn't the question & you know it but it is meant to mean that for those 5 teams 'currently' in the top 5 to stay there or not, c'mon ah it is sunday no need to be that pedantic

I'm not sure what to say, I answered the question. I said if a team in the top 5 has injuries and either Norwood or West string some wins together, the top 5 could alter. So my answer was (and is) "no", it's not set.

I also said I would think the teams who already comprise the top 5 will eventually make the final 5. I don't own a crystal ball, anything could happen over the second half of the season.

we know all that my friend it is a simple yes or no on what we've all seen so far this year....to me i think the 5 is set & obviously the order is not

bayman wrote:

Adelaide Hawk wrote:

bayman wrote:

Adelaide Hawk wrote:I think the top 5 at the moment will all play finals, but the top 5 is far from "set". The teams that are in there will jockey for top 3 spots, and if one of them has a run of injuries or losses, they could lose their spot altogether if someone like Norwood or West string sime wins together.

that wasn't the question & you know it but it is meant to mean that for those 5 teams 'currently' in the top 5 to stay there or not, c'mon ah it is sunday no need to be that pedantic

I'm not sure what to say, I answered the question. I said if a team in the top 5 has injuries and either Norwood or West string some wins together, the top 5 could alter. So my answer was (and is) "no", it's not set.

I also said I would think the teams who already comprise the top 5 will eventually make the final 5. I don't own a crystal ball, anything could happen over the second half of the season.

we know all that my friend it is a simple yes or no on what we've all seen so far this year....to me i think the 5 is set & obviously the order is not

Then why ask the question?

Grumpy Adelaide Hawk!

LBT wrote::? Grumpy Adelaide Hawk!

Well I wasn't but I am now. What is the f***ing point of asking a question if you don't want any discussion, just a yes or no answer? This is a forum, not a census.

the last spot in the 5 will be contested between Eagles and Norwood.

I sympathise with you on this one, AH.

Adelaide Hawk wrote:

LBT wrote::? Grumpy Adelaide Hawk!

Well I wasn't but I am now. What is the f***ing point of asking a question if you don't want any discussion, just a yes or no answer? This is a forum, not a census.

that is why it is a poll & not a question

I still think if the legs get there act together they will be able to take the eagles spot in the 5 by the time the year ends.

Wasn't it only a couple of weeks ago everyone was saying Centrals would go through undefeated and stroll to another flag? Now that's changed and the top three now right open.

Who's to say Norwood and West win a few more games and keep the fight for 4th and 5th right open?

On that basis, I say no, the top 5 isn't set.

No, the top five is definitely not set. It could have been over the last two weeks with another win to the Eagles and two losses to Norwood. This, plus other results, has meant it is now a battle mainly between Eagles and Norwood, before Saturday week ago it was between North and West.

Adelaide Hawk wrote:I think the top 5 at the moment will all play finals, but the top 5 is far from "set".

agree

it is set now one would think, now for the order of it