Page 1 of 2
RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 5:28 pm
by magpie in the 80's
Panthers 11.9.75
Bays 14.17.101
Goals Panthers: Warren 2, Veide 2, Lyons 2, Minns 1, Cockshell 1, Williams 1, Rolfe 1, McKernan 1
Goals Glenelg: Panozzo 3, T.Grima 3, Duldig 2, Fisher 2, Holmes, Meyer, Hall, C.Kane.
Best Panthers: Redigolo, Lyons, Sandery, Splitt, McKenna, Rolfe
Best Glenelg: Fischer, Carr, Cranston, Holmes, Sellar, Backwell
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 5:36 pm
by The Apostle
LBT wrote:I know you'd love to beat port in a grand final, but i cant see that happening this year

I know you'd love to beat Centrals in a grand final, but i cant see that happening this year

...
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 5:38 pm
by FlyingHigh
The Apostle AK wrote:LBT wrote:I know you'd love to beat port in a grand final, but i cant see that happening this year

I know you'd love to beat Centrals in a grand final, but i cant see that happening this year

...
Have to lose four GF's to have any respect these days, not these one-year-wonder types

Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 5:58 pm
by LBT
magpie in the 80's wrote:Panthers 11.9.75
Bays 14.17.101
Goals Glenelg: Hall.
An appropriate win.
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 6:00 pm
by stampy
dont know if the margin flattered them or us, we were crap when it came to handling errors, our third qtr was atrocious, the umpires for most of the match were deplorable - dont know whats happened there, too much afl mimicking maybe, however a win is a win, to be 4-2 and playing shitehouse is ok from a tigers point of view, if we can rid ourselves of the costly turnovers in the backline we might be a threat. thought jimmy sellar did pretty good today, and grima later in the match, match fitness will help him, poor josh carr didnt know what to do with the ball when he got it, however thats to be expected not knowing the players or the gameplan, all in all it was disappointing but looking from where we have come from in the last few years we should be reasonably satisfied, a mountain of work still to be done
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 7:17 pm
by Dutchy
Fair summary Stampy
I only got there for the 2nd half, thought we did enough and while they hit the front it was thru no system, just opportunistic goals therefore wasnt really worried at all.
Our commitment and small teams stuff was so much better this week, we just need to sharpen our skills and game plan.
Good to be winning with so much improvement in us.
Interesting that Sampson and his coaches were still up in their box 20 minutes after the game when I left
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 7:22 pm
by am Bays
FlyingHigh wrote:Have to lose four GF's to have any respect these days, not these one-year-wonder types

Bookmark this one SAFootyers, Glenelg being criticised for NOT losing enough Grand Finals!!!!
Who'd a thunk it??
Need to show improvement on today to win our next two games against likely finals contenders. There's a lot to be said for winning ugly but gee all our wins have been this year so I for one are getting sick of it. Mind you unlike last year when we won 13 in a row we haven't had the same line up all year so it will be good to finally get a settled line up so blokes can gets some consistancy in our system. Far too much 2nd guessing and wrong options being taken.
The best thing today was our ressies had an 15 goal win, time to put some pressure on spots.
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 7:24 pm
by spell_check
am Bays wrote:FlyingHigh wrote:Have to lose four GF's to have any respect these days, not these one-year-wonder types

Bookmark this one SAFootyers, Glenelg being criticised for NOT losing enough Grand Finals!!!!
Who'd a thunk it??
Full points for originality, but we both know what it's like to be 2nd a lot so I reckon there's some sympathy there.

Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 7:49 pm
by whufc
Much like the dogs yesterday, a win is a win and it's all 2 points. Rack them up early so you can address player management alot easier and not rush players back from injury and so forth.
Nothing to worry about for the bays at this stage sitting 4-2.
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 7:51 pm
by gerling182
135 more disposals and a heap more inside 50 entries, it's fair to say the Bays were easily the best side out there, but far too inclined to handball under pressure, if you turn it over you might as well stick it on the boot and turn it over 50 metres further away from your goals. Carr and Fisher were ball magnets, Backwell worked into the game as it wore on and put his stamp on the game and Grima was fantastic crashing the packs (taking out Torney on one occasion!) and kicking 3 goals, 2 coming in the last quarter when the game was on the line.
For South fans at least you hung in there despire being outplayed, Boyd was good but when Sandery is your second biggest possesion winner deep in defence you've got some problems. At least you only play Port next week!
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 8:20 pm
by FlyingHigh
am Bays wrote:FlyingHigh wrote:Have to lose four GF's to have any respect these days, not these one-year-wonder types

Bookmark this one SAFootyers, Glenelg being criticised for NOT losing enough Grand Finals!!!!
Who'd a thunk it??
Probably didn't quite think about that enough before I wrote it

Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 9:20 pm
by stampy
gerling182 wrote:135 more disposals and a heap more inside 50 entries, it's fair to say the Bays were easily the best side out there, but far too inclined to handball under pressure, if you turn it over you might as well stick it on the boot and turn it over 50 metres further away from your goals. Carr and Fisher were ball magnets, Backwell worked into the game as it wore on and put his stamp on the game and Grima was fantastic crashing the packs (taking out Torney on one occasion!) and kicking 3 goals, 2 coming in the last quarter when the game was on the line.
For South fans at least you hung in there despire being outplayed, Boyd was good but when Sandery is your second biggest possesion winner deep in defence you've got some problems. At least you only play Port next week!
carr ball magnet? i didnt think so, when he did get it he dint know what to bloodydo with it

Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 9:38 pm
by saintal
South had a crack but as is usually the case just weren't good enough when it mattered. 15 minutes in the second Q were costly as the bays killed us out of the middle to find a multitude of forwards lining up to take an easy grab.
To the boys credit the third Q was a huge improvement, as a couple of tackles finally stuck (been terrible to that point) and the bays didn't handle the pressure well. We managed to capitalise, not through slick forward entries, more just getting numbers to the contests and kicking it long inside 50 instead of mucking around with it.
3 points up at 3/4 time, but the bays wrapped it up in the opening 10 minutes of the last term.
Some of the new guys showed a bit for South, Lyons in particular, while Cockshell did some good things after half time and will be better for the run (kicking is a worry though). Boyd, Parry, McKernan, Sandery were also ok. Torney injured again a concern (showed courage as is the norm), while Boyd's groin looked proppy in the final Q.
Bays were decent but are capable of far better footy than that you would hope if you were a supporter. On the plus side a few of us gave Chri$ Hall a nice welcoming home.
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 9:40 pm
by prowling panther
gerling182 wrote:135 more disposals and a heap more inside 50 entries, it's fair to say the Bays were easily
I would say that the Bays wasted to much of the footy by careless footy, to have 35 touches a quarter more than your opponent has to say something when the best they could do was to shake of South only in the last quarter.
South harrased pretty well all day, made plenty of mistakes as well, kicked to no one in particular, I can tell you one thing, when a lot of these young kids get about 20-30 games under their belts there will be a lot of opposites going home with the cockiness knocked out of them.
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 9:44 pm
by Dirko
saintal wrote:On the plus side a few of us gave Chri$ Hall a nice welcoming home.
You did ? Struth didn't hear anything, however when he kicked that lovely goal the roar was bloody loud

Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 9:51 pm
by prowling panther
SJABC wrote:saintal wrote:On the plus side a few of us gave Chri$ Hall a nice welcoming home.
You did ? Struth didn't hear anything, however when he kicked that lovely goal the roar was bloody loud

Probably 'cos you had tiger poo in your ears.

Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 9:57 pm
by Dirko
Have you been to the Dave Flanagan school of comedy by chance ?
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 10:03 pm
by bay_girl23
stampy wrote: the umpires for most of the match were deplorable - dont know whats happened there
biased opinion maybe, but would have to agree...
free kicks - south 27, bays 14
still room for improvement on what we saw from the boys today, though happy to have the win
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 10:05 pm
by prowling panther
SJABC wrote:Have you been to the Dave Flanagan school of comedy by chance ?
Someone has to write his stuff, do you go and watch him in your spare time?
Re: RD 6 Panthers v Glenelg Review

Posted:
Sun May 03, 2009 10:19 pm
by Dirko
subpol wrote:Someone has to write his stuff, do you go and watch him in your spare time?
Nah, I'd rather stick splinters under my fingernails......