SA Footy

Hopefully it'll be Norwood's Josh Donohue. He's kicked nearly thirty goals and has had as big an impact for a young player as I've seen in a long time. He's got great hands, super awareness and his tackling for someone his size is extraordinary.

Who does anyone think will finish second?

topsywaldron wrote:Hopefully it'll be Norwood's Josh Donohue. He's kicked nearly thirty goals and has had as big an impact for a young player as I've seen in a long time. He's got great hands, super awareness and his tackling for someone his size is extraordinary.

Who does anyone think will finish second?

Paul Puopollo

Maybe Broadbent from the Eagles could win, he is a real talent but did miss a few games with State Under 18's duties...

Tommy Holmes from the Bays for me, should win it just over James Boyd from South...

Big Phil wrote:Tommy Holmes from the Bays for me, should win it just over James Boyd from South...

Not seen any Norwood games this year then?

I have and int eh two games I saw Holmes was ahead of Donohue - have you forgotten May 23rd already Topsy?

Holmes for me aswell!!

topsywaldron wrote:

Big Phil wrote:Tommy Holmes from the Bays for me, should win it just over James Boyd from South...

Not seen any Norwood games this year then?

Actually I have Topsy and a couple of non Centrals games for that matter. I just think Holmes and Boyd have been more consistant than Josh and because the Glenelg and South boys play on the ball, I think they will get a little more notice than Donohue. I think Josh is a talented player and think he'll be right up there so if it makes you happy...

1st - Tom Holmes (Glenelg)
2nd - James Boyd (South)
3rd - Josh Donohue (Norwood)

Weren't you at the game Saturday? JD spent a lot of time playing on-ball.

To nearly be in the top ten goal kickers playing off a flank and on ball is almost Callinan-esque IMHO. A shame for him he's not on Ian's $80K!

I think Jared Petrenko will be high up the pecking order. I also would rate Donohue ahead of Holmes and Boyd. Boyd runs around getting cheap kicks all day and doesn't hurt you. Holmes, well he is very good, but i just think Donohue has had more of an impact on a more consistent basis from what i have seen of them both this year.

wycbloods wrote:I think Jared Petrenko will be high up the pecking order. I also would rate Donohue ahead of Holmes and Boyd. Boyd runs around getting cheap kicks all day and doesn't hurt you. Holmes, well he is very good, but i just think Donohue has had more of an impact on a more consistent basis from what i have seen of them both this year.

don't think he can win it now as he is a full time crow????????

heater31 wrote:

wycbloods wrote:I think Jared Petrenko will be high up the pecking order. I also would rate Donohue ahead of Holmes and Boyd. Boyd runs around getting cheap kicks all day and doesn't hurt you. Holmes, well he is very good, but i just think Donohue has had more of an impact on a more consistent basis from what i have seen of them both this year.

don't think he can win it now as he is a full time crow????????

Ok i was unsure of his eligibility due to his promotion to the senior list. Although he still isn't a full time crow, he goes back to the rookie list after the season has finished doesn't he?

I'd love to say Tommy Holmes, but I reakon Boyd just shades him with a slightly better level of consistency over the season...

No doubt someone will have some stats somewhere that indicate Holmes has better consistency than Boyd, but I think Boyd has been slightly better over the year.

TigerBoss wrote:No doubt someone will have some stats somewhere that indicate Holmes has better consistency than Boyd, but I think Boyd has been slightly better over the year.

Boyd's a deserving runner up.

topsywaldron wrote:

TigerBoss wrote:No doubt someone will have some stats somewhere that indicate Holmes has better consistency than Boyd, but I think Boyd has been slightly better over the year.

Boyd's a deserving runner up.

To Tommy Holmes, followed by Josh Donohue in 3rd spot

I'd really like Martin or Thring to win it as they are both quality people.

But.. Broadbent's an exceptionally talented player.

Good luck to everyone concerned.

Boyd
Holmes
Broadbent


Note ; Hartlett better than the lot of them but in my opinion he hasn't played enough games to win it

Ill be a sheep and say Holmes or Boyd as well.

Matthew Broadbent, with Hamish Hartlett not far behind. While Hartlett had an interrupted season, that shouldn't affect his chances hopefully. A very open field though.

One of the Eagles players.

Boyd will go very very close to winning the B+F down at South. I know I'm biased, but surely this award is his?

He has also polled quite a number of votes in the advertiser's comp, up in the top 1/2 dozen players i think.