SA Footy

Just for fun, us mods have voted under the 5-4-3-2-1 format to find out the SAFooty player of the year. In years past on FootySA, this has been a good guide to the Magarey Medal winner, because in 2004, 2005 and 2006, the winner of this has won the Magarey. This is up to last round:

James Allan North 26
Adam Fisher Glenelg 25
Chad O'Sullivan Central 25
Luke Crane Sturt 23
Ty Allen Glenelg 23
Jeremy Clayton Port 21
Paul Thomas Central 21
Jade Sheedy Sturt 19
Ian Perrie Sturt 16
Andrew Whiteman Sturt 15
Ian Callinan Central 15
Brett Backwell Glenelg 14
Byron Murphy Glenelg 14
Steven Summerton Port 14
Adam Thomson Sturt 13
Clint Alleway North 13
Corey AhChee Port 13
Josh Donohue Norwood 13
Mark Passador Eagles 13
Adam Cockshell Norwood 12
Ben Warren South 12
Jason Torney South 12
Luke Jarrad Eagles 12
Nathan Brown West 12
Trevor Cranston Glenelg 12
Andy Otten South 11
Daniel Hargraves Port 11
Leigh Treeby Eagles 11
Matthew Slade Central 11
Ryan Ferguson West 11
Brant Chambers Sturt 10
Luke Panozzo Glenelg 10
Rhys Archard North 10
Scott McGlone Sturt 10
Tom Holmes Glenelg 10
James McLeay Sturt 9
Luke Powell Eagles 9
Nick Duigan Norwood 9
Nick Lower Norwood 9
Tim Weatherald Norwood 9
Chris Ladhams North 8
Craig Parry South 8
Peter Fiacchi Eagles 8
Todd Grima Glenelg 8
Ben Schwarze Eagles 7
Daniel Havelberg Central 7
Daniel Ward North 7
David Trotter Norwood 7
James Gowans Central 7
James Turner South 7
John Hinge Glenelg 7
Luke McCabe Central 7
Nicholas Wark Sturt 7
Simon Feast Sturt 7
Damian Cupido West 6
Damon White North 6
Daniel Schell Central 6
Greg Bentley Sturt 6
Heath Younie North 6
James Gallagher Norwood 6
James Boyd South 6
Kristian DePasquale Port 6
Nick Gill North 6
Paul Puopolo Norwood 6
Peter Rolfe South 6
Sam Rudolph Glenelg 6
Andrew McIntyre North 5
Bryce Campbell Norwood 5
Daniel Elstone Port 5
Fabian deLuca Sturt 5
Jamie Vlatko Norwood 5
Justin McConnell Glenelg 5
Kris Massie Norwood 5
Mark McKenzie Eagles 5
Michael Wilson Port 5
Paul Stewart Eagles 5
Ryan Herring Sturt 5
Shane Neaves West 5
Stuart Bown Norwood 5
Taylor Walker Norwood 5
Ben Nelson Sturt 4
Brett Zorzi Norwood 4
Charlie Sharples Sturt 4
Ian Prendergast South 4
Jesse Aish Norwood 4
Joel Perry Port 4
Kenrick Tyrell Norwood 4
Luke Nitschke Norwood 4
Matthew Duldig Glenelg 4
Matthew Bode Glenelg 4
Matthew Wright North 4
Nick Salter Eagles 4
Paul Sherwood Glenelg 4
Richard Cochrane Central 4
Trent Sporn North 4
Andrew Hayes Central 3
Ben Kane Glenelg 3
Brett O'Hara North 3
Jacob Surjan Port 3
Jared Petrenko Eagles 3
Jason Mackenzie Central 3
Luke Ivens North 3
Nathan Krakouer Port 3
Rory O'Brien North 3
Sam Elliott South 3
Stephen Bailey West 3
Tristan Gum Sturt 3
Adam Grocke Eagles 2
Brad Moran West 2
Brayden O'Hara Central 2
Dane Avery Sturt 2
Greg Rowe West 2
Heath Lawry Central 2
Ivan Maric Port 2
Josh Thurgood Port 2
Mark Dolling Port 2
Matthew Broadbent Eagles 2
Michael Handby South 2
Michael Coad Sturt 2
Ruory Kirkby Glenelg 2
Ryan Willits West 2
Simon McCormick West 2
Tom Logan Glenelg 2
Tom Hateley South 2
Adam Klun Eagles 1
Ben Mules Glenelg 1
Craig Fitzgerald Eagles 1
Elijah Ware Central 1
James Meikeljohn Port 1
Louis Hadden Central 1
Marcus Burdett South 1
Matthew Westhoff Central 1
Matthew Thomas Norwood 1
Matthew Lokan Port 1
Scott Dutschke Central 1
Tim Delvins North 1
Yves Sibenaler Central 1

Round by Round Voting:

ROUND 1
Norwood v Sturt
5: Ian Perrie (Sturt)
4: Luke Crane (Sturt)
3: Nicholas Wark (Sturt)
2: Simon Feast (Sturt)
1: Jade Sheedy (Sturt)

North v Eagles
5: Chris Ladhams (North)
4: Rhys Archard (North)
3: Ben Schwarze (Eagles)
2: Rory O'Brien (North)
1: Tim Delvins (North)

Central v Port
5: Ian Callinan (Central)
4: Corey AhChee (Port)
3: Andrew Hayes (Central)
2: Steven Summerton (Port)
1: Scott Dutschke (Central)

South v Glenelg
5: Jason Torney (South)
4: Ian Prendergast (South)
3: Sam Elliott (South)
2: Tom Logan (Glenelg)
1: Ben Warren (South)

ROUND 2
Glenelg v Eagles
5: Adam Fisher (Glenelg)
4: Matthew Duldig (Glenelg)
3: Byron Murphy (Glenelg)
2: Ty Allen (Glenelg)
1: Luke Jarrad (Eagles)

Port v South
5: Ben Warren (South)
4: Jason Torney (South)
3: Corey AhChee (Port)
2: James Turner (South)
1: Nathan Krakouer (Port)

Sturt v Central
5: Adam Thomson (Sturt)
4: Jade Sheedy (Sturt)
3: Greg Bentley (Sturt)
2: Daniel Havelberg (Central)
1: Nicholas Wark (Sturt)

West v Norwood
5: Bryce Campbell (Norwood)
4: Jesse Aish (Norwood)
3: Josh Donohue (Norwood)
2: Nick Lower (Norwood)
1: Kenrick Tyrrell (Norwood)

ROUND 3
Eagles v Port
5: Daniel Hargraves (Port)
4: Jeremy Clayton (Port)
3: Corey AhChee (Port)
2: Ivan Maric (Port)
1: Leigh Treeby (Eagles)

North v Sturt
5: Luke Crane (Sturt)
4: Ian Perrie (Sturt)
3: Adam Thomson (Sturt)
2: Fabian deLuca (Sturt)
1: Brant Chambers (Sturt)

South v West
5: Damian Cupido (West)
4: James Turner (South)
3: Ryan Ferguson (West)
2: Shane Neaves (West)
1: Marcus Burdett (South)

Central v Norwood
5: Ian Callinan (Central)
4: Paul Thomas (Central)
3: Matthew Slade (Central)
2: Nick Lower (Norwood)
1: Matthew Westhoff (Central)

ROUND 4
Norwood v Eagles
5: Luke Powell (Eagles)
4: Nick Salter (Eagles)
3: David Trotter (Norwood)
2: Mark Passador (Eagles)
1: Jamie Vlatko (Norwood)

South v Sturt
5: Jade Sheedy (Sturt)
4: Andrew Whiteman (Sturt)
3: Nicholas Wark (Sturt)
2: Luke Crane (Sturt)
1: James McLeay (Sturt)

Glenelg v West
5: Tom Holmes (Glenelg)
4: Ty Allen (Glenelg)
3: Trevor Cranston (Glenelg)
2: Byron Murphy (Glenelg)
1: Brett Backwell (Glenelg)

Port v North
5: Steven Summerton (Port)
4: James Allan (North)
3: Chris Ladhams (North)
2: Clint Alleway (North)
1: Andrew McIntyre (North)

ROUND 5
Central v North
5: James Gowans (Central)
4: Paul Thomas (Central)
3: Trent Sporn (North)
2: Chad O'Sullivan (Central)
1: Rory O'Brien (North)

Norwood v South
5: Andy Otten (South)
4: James Boyd (South)
3: Josh Donohue (Norwood)
2: Brett Zorzi (Norwood)
1: James Turner (South)

Sturt v Glenelg
5: Ty Allen (Glenelg)
4: Trevor Cranston (Glenelg)
3: Luke Crane (Sturt)
2: Luke Panozzo (Glenelg)
1: Charlie Sharples (Sturt)

West v Eagles
5: Paul Stewart (Eagles)
4: Mark Passador (Eagles)
3: Leigh Treeby (Eagles)
2: Brad Moran (West)
1: Luke Jarrad (Eagles)

ROUND 6
Eagles v Sturt
5: Mark McKenzie (Eagles)
4: Luke Powell (Eagles)
3: Mark Passador (Eagles)
2: Adam Grocke (Eagles)
1: Leigh Treeby (Eagles)

North v South
5: Damon White (North)
4: Andrew McIntyre (North)
3: Luke Ivens (North)
2: Heath Younie (North)
1: Rhys Archard (North)

Port v West
5: Daniel Hargraves (Port)
4: Nathan Brown (West)
3: Jeremy Clayton (Port)
2: Ryan Willits (West)
1: Nathan Krakouer (Port)

Glenelg v Central
5: Brett Backwell (Glenelg)
4: Adam Fisher (Glenelg)
3: Trevor Cranston (Glenelg)
2: Luke McCabe (Central)
1: Justin McConnell (Glenelg)

ROUND 7
Norwood v Port
5: Josh Donohue (Norwood)
4: Paul Puopolo (Norwood)
3: Kenrick Tyrrell (Norwood)
2: Corey AhChee (Port)
1: Daniel Hargraves (Port)

Sturt v West
5: James McLeay (Sturt)
4: Jade Sheedy (Sturt)
3: Greg Bentley (Sturt)
2: Luke Crane (Sturt)
1: Ian Perrie (Sturt)

Glenelg v North
5: Brett Backwell (Glenelg)
4: James Allan (North)
3: Adam Fisher (Glenelg)
2: Heath Younie (North)
1: Sam Rudolph (Glenelg)

Central v Eagles
5: Chad O'Sullivan (Central)
4: Leigh Treeby (Eagles)
3: Matthew Slade (Central)
2: Heath Lawry (Central)
1: Mark Passador (Eagles)

ROUND 8
North v Norwood
5: Stuart Bown (Norwood)
4: Luke Nitschke (Norwood)
3: James Allan (North)
2: Nick Lower (Norwood)
1: Trent Sporn (North)

South v Glenelg
5: Ty Allen (Glenelg)
4: Justin McConnell (Glenelg)
3: Ben Kane (Glenelg)
2: Tom Holmes (Glenelg)
1: Ben Warren (South)

Sturt v Port
5: Ian Perrie (Sturt)
4: Steven Summerton (Port)
3: Charlie Sharples (Sturt)
2: Mark Dolling (Port)
1: Andrew Whiteman (Sturt)

West v Central
5: Luke McCabe (Central)
4: Richard Cochrane (Central)
3: Stephen Bailey (West)
2: Daniel Schell (Central)
1: Yves Sibenaler (Central)

ROUND 9
Norwood v Glenelg
5: Adam Fisher (Glenelg)
4: Byron Murphy (Glenelg)
3: Tom Holmes (Glenelg)
2: Ty Allen (Glenelg)
1: Luke Panozzo (Glenelg)

Eagles v North
5: Rhys Archard (North)
4: James Allan (North)
3: Mark Passador (Eagles)
2: Heath Younie (North)
1: Craig Fitzgerald (Eagles)

West v South
5: Nathan Brown (West)
4: Ben Warren (South)
3: Shane Neaves (West)
2: Simon McCormick (West)
1: James Boyd (South)

Port v Central
5: Daniel Havelberg (Central)
4: Chad O'Sullivan (Central)
3: Paul Thomas (Central)
2: Brayden O'Hara (Central)
1: Nathan Krakouer (Port)

ROUND 10
Central v South
5: Paul Thomas (Central)
4: Chad O'Sullivan (Central)
3: Peter Rolfe (South)
2: James Gowans (Central)
1: Elijah Ware (Central)

Eagles v Norwood
5: Taylor Walker (Norwood)
4: Adam Cockshell (Norwood)
3: Nick Lower (Norwood)
2: James Gallagher (Norwood)
1: Peter Fiacchi (Eagles)

Glenelg v Port
5: Byron Murphy (Glenelg)
4: Jeremy Clayton (Port)
3: Brett Backwell (Glenelg)
2: Ruory Kirkby (Glenelg)
1: James Meikeljohn (Port)

Sturt v North
5: Simon Feast (Sturt)
4: Andrew Whiteman (Sturt)
3: Tristan Gum (Sturt)
2: James McLeay (Sturt)
1: James Allan (North)

ROUND 11
North v West
5: James Allan (North)
4: Matthew Wright (North)
3: Daniel Ward (North)
2: Nick Gill (North)
1: Damon White (North)

South v Eagles
5: Luke Jarrad (Eagles)
4: Peter Fiacchi (Eagles)
3: Craig Parry (South)
2: Jason Torney (South)
1: Ben Warren (South)

Sturt v Norwood
5: Adam Thomson (Sturt)
4: Ben Nelson (Sturt)
3: Luke Crane (Sturt)
2: Paul Puopolo (Norwood)
1: Matthew Thomas (Norwood)

ROUND 12
Central v Glenelg
5: Ty Allen (Glenelg)
4: Luke Panozzo (Glenelg)
3: Adam Fisher (Glenelg)
2: Chad O'Sullivan (Central)
1: John Hinge (Glenelg)

Eagles v Sturt
5: Ryan Herring (Sturt)
4: Luke Crane (Sturt)
3: Fabian deLuca (Sturt)
2: Brant Chambers (Sturt)
1: Ian Perrie (Sturt)

North v South
5: Clint Alleway (North)
4: Daniel Ward (North)
3: Brett O'Hara (North)
2: Andy Otten (South)
1: Jason Torney (South)

West v Port
5: Daniel Elstone (Port)
4: Ryan Ferguson (West)
3: Steven Summerton (Port)
2: Kristian DePasquale (Port)
1: Damian Cupido (West)

ROUND 13
Eagles v Central
5: Luke Jarrad (Eagles)
4: Ben Schwarze (Eagles)
3: Jared Petrenko (Eagles)
2: Matthew Broadbent (Eagles)
1: Peter Fiacchi (Eagles)

Norwood v West
5: Kris Massie (Norwood)
4: Jamie Vlatko (Norwood)
3: Adam Cockshell (Norwood)
2: Ryan Ferguson (West)
1: Tim Weatherald (Norwood)

Port v North
5: Michael Wilson (Port)
4: Kristian DePasquale (Port)
3: Clint Alleway (North)
2: Josh Thurgood (Port)
1: Jeremy Clayton (Port)

Glenelg v Sturt
5: Ty Allen (Glenelg)
4: Paul Sherwood (Glenelg)
3: Scott McGlone (Sturt)
2: Dane Avery (Sturt)
1: Trevor Cranston (Glenelg)

ROUND 14
Central v West
5: Matthew Slade (Central)
4: Daniel Schell (Central)
3: Chad O'Sullivan (Central)
2: Ryan Ferguson (West)
1: Louis Hadden (Central)

North v Glenelg
5: Todd Grima (Glenelg)
4: Matthew Bode (Glenelg)
3: Luke Panozzo (Glenelg)
2: John Hinge (Glenelg)
1: Trevor Cranston (Glenelg)

Port v Eagles
5: Jeremy Clayton (Port)
4: Joel Perry (Port)
3: Jacob Surjan (Port)
2: Peter Fiacchi (Eagles)
1: Matthew Lokan (Port)

South v Norwood
5: Adam Cockshell (Norwood)
4: Nick Duigan (Norwood)
3: Tim Weatherald (Norwood)
2: Tom Hateley (South)
1: James Boyd (South)

ROUND 15
Central v Port
5: Chad O'Sullivan (Central)
4: Jeremy Clayton (Port)
3: Jason Mackenzie (Central)
2: Paul Thomas (Central)
1: Corey AhChee (Port)

West v Glenelg
5: Adam Fisher (Glenelg)
4: John Hinge (Glenelg)
3: Todd Grima (Glenelg)
2: Greg Rowe (West)
1: Nathan Brown (West)

Norwood v North
5: Tim Weatherald (Norwood)
4: James Gallagher (Norwood)
3: David Trotter (Norwood)
2: Josh Donohue (Norwood)
1: Nick Duigan (Norwood)

Sturt v South
5: Andrew Whiteman (Sturt)
4: Scott McGlone (Sturt)
3: Brant Chambers (Sturt)
2: Michael Coad (Sturt)
1: James McLeay (Sturt)

ROUND 16
Glenelg v South
5: Craig Parry (South)
4: Andy Otten (South)
3: Peter Rolfe (South)
2: Michael Handby (South)
1: Ben Mules (Glenelg)

North v Eagles
5: James Allan (North)
4: Nick Gill (North)
3: Clint Alleway (North)
2: Leigh Treeby (Eagles)
1: Adam Klun (Eagles)

Norwood v Central
5: Ian Callinan (Central)
4: Nick Duigan (Norwood)
3: Paul Thomas (Central)
2: Brett Zorzi (Norwood)
1: David Trotter (Norwood)

West v Sturt
5: Jade Sheedy (Sturt)
4: Brant Chambers (Sturt)
3: Scott McGlone (Sturt)
2: Nathan Brown (West)
1: Andrew Whiteman (Sturt)

spell_check wrote:Just for fun, us mods have voted under the 5-4-3-2-1 format to find out the SAFooty player of the year. In years past on FootySA, this has been a good guide to the Magarey Medal winner, because in 2004, 2005 and 2006, the winner of this has won the Magarey. This is up to last round:

James Allan North 26
Adam Fisher Glenelg 25
Chad O'Sullivan Central 25
Luke Crane Sturt 23
Ty Allen Glenelg 23
Jeremy Clayton Port 21
Paul Thomas Central 21
Jade Sheedy Sturt 19
Ian Perrie Sturt 16
Ian Callinan Central 15
Brett Backwell Glenelg 14
Byron Murphy Glenelg 14

While many haven't made mention of him when it comes to a Centrals players Magarey Medal chances, Chad O'Sullivan, might just slip under the radar of a few people and although he might not have 3 or 4 "3 VOTES" to this stage of the year, you might find he will have a few 2's and 1 votes. I wouldn't be surprised if he ends up being right up and there come the end of the night and IMO will be the highest polling Dogs player. I think that The Bays and Double Blues might just have too many consistant players share the votes amongst themselves

Paul Thomas is obviously up there despite missing 3 games through suspension and surprisingly, despite missing about 9 consecutive games this year, Ian Callinan is only about 1/2 a dozen best on ground "5 Votes" shy of the leader in the SAFooty player of the year. One would assume the winner of this prestigious award from this great footy web site will probably come from the top 1/2 dozen players. So based on Spelly's fact about this being a good guide for the eventual Magarey winner, I'm going to say that if Sully doesn't win it to become Centrals 6th medalist, I reckon that either James Allan or maybe Adam Fisher might take the bikkies in the night...

GO SULLY, KEEP UP THE CAREER BEST FORM...

Here's the top 25 in a clearer format:

Code: Select all

James Allan        North        26
Adam Fisher        Glenelg      25
Chad O'Sullivan    Central      25
Luke Crane         Sturt        23
Ty Allen           Glenelg      23
Jeremy Clayton     Port         21
Paul Thomas        Central      21
Jade Sheedy        Sturt        19
Ian Perrie         Sturt        16
Andrew Whiteman    Sturt        15
Ian Callinan       Central      15
Brett Backwell     Glenelg      14
Byron Murphy       Glenelg      14
Steven Summerton   Port         14
Adam Thomson       Sturt        13
Clint Alleway      North        13
Corey  AhChee      Port         13
Josh Donohue       Norwood      13
Mark Passador      Eagles       13
Adam Cockshell     Norwood      12
Ben Warren         South        12
Jason Torney       South        12
Luke Jarrad        Eagles       12
Nathan Brown       West         12
Trevor Cranston    Glenelg      12

Also Fisher is currently 8/1 and Ty Allen is 20/1 for the Magarey, Ive jumped on those two as they seem a bit of value if Glenelg keep winning looking at the votes they've got so far in the SAFooty player of the year.

Fisher doesnt get votes and at 8/1 is under the odds imo

Yep, agreed.

Fisher will not win the MM...I think Glenelg's best chance is Allen, though Ben Kane, Backwell and Fish will obviously pinch some votes. Cranston may surprise but the umpires generally don't appreciate the good ruckmen...

From Sturt I think Sheedy and Chambers are a good show, and Centrals have Paul Thomas (though ineligible) that normally is a big poller of votes...

Jimmy Allan is an absolute gun, but I reakon his ability to rack up the stats would not always be noticed by the umpires...he seems to get such high numbers, but does not always have a resounding effect on the team's performances. North's up and down season may cost him a few votes.

Still too hard to tip at this stage.

Hope you're right about Ty Allen TB, go you good thing! $21 was great value I thought!

Wedgie wrote:Hope you're right about Ty Allen TB, go you good thing! $21 was great value I thought!

How many players have you backed for the medal Wedgie?

All games voting are up.

Adelaide Hawk wrote:

Wedgie wrote:Hope you're right about Ty Allen TB, go you good thing! $21 was great value I thought!

How many players have you backed for the medal Wedgie?

2

If O'sullivan wins Big Phil will cary on like a pork chop. And abuse me with smilies .

LBT wrote:If O'sullivan wins Big Phil will carry on like a pork chop. And abuse me with smilies

Just the 4 though.

spell_check wrote:

LBT wrote:If O'sullivan wins Big Phil will carry on like a pork chop. And abuse me with smilies

Just the 4 though.

Says who ?

SJABC wrote:

spell_check wrote:

LBT wrote:If O'sullivan wins Big Phil will carry on like a pork chop. And abuse me with smilies

Just the 4 though.

Says who ?

Cheater...

SJABC wrote:

spell_check wrote:

LBT wrote:If O'sullivan wins Big Phil will carry on like a pork chop. And abuse me with smilies

Just the 4 though.

Says who ?

Cheat!!!!! Adam Fisher is a big chance to take out this award however, why the crows didnt pick him up i will never know.

ssssssssshhhhhhhhhhhh don't tell Philby

Don't worry, SJABC, one huge smiley is just as effective:

When we round up the season, and look back on the year that was, is the biggest issue in footy going to be the use of the smiley?