SA Footy

is barnaby french contemplating playing for sturt ? (would be good for sturt & the competition), i believe that IF his back holds up over the next few weeks he'll end up playing despite what we've been told, he would have committed earlier but is concerned about his back

if he does play, the ruck isn't the only option, chb,chf is as well which would mean where will perrie play ?

Sturtpeter will be dancing in the streets

dash61 wrote:Sturtpeter will be dancing in the streets

well ffs don't put it on youtube

we asked the question a while ago and the answer was strictly coaching only, id be VERY SURPRISED if he did come back. I highly, HIGHLY doubt it.

I the only place that he might comeback to is the magoos to help out if we were short. I think our senior coach did that when at the roosters a few years back

Good ruckman only I reckon. After a couple of years away and not having the excessive talent to play KP forward or back, I don't think opposition CHB or CHF's would be shaking in their boots. IMHO

!!!!

I'm excited too!!!!*




*Believe it when I see it.

Hmm...bet you Sturt-ites wish it was Frenchy having that kick for goal late in the Elimination Final vs. the Bays last season, and not Feasty...

westcoastpanther wrote:Good ruckman only I reckon. After a couple of years away and not having the excessive talent to play KP forward or back, I don't think opposition CHB or CHF's would be shaking in their boots. IMHO

I agree, wouldn't be a huge threat in the SANFL this year if he made a comeback.

GWW wrote:

westcoastpanther wrote:Good ruckman only I reckon. After a couple of years away and not having the excessive talent to play KP forward or back, I don't think opposition CHB or CHF's would be shaking in their boots. IMHO

I agree, wouldn't be a huge threat in the SANFL this year if he made a comeback.

I would strongly disagree gents.

I am not for one minute suggesting he will play but if he did he would be extremely handy both in the ruck and in a KP. He has had trouble with his back but we must all remember he was training full time in the AFL and that wouldn't have helped the cause. The guy is only 31 yo, is built like a brick outhouse and has a great footy brain. He has a rowing background and as such his natural fitness and ability is terrific.

He would need to be managed carefully and IF he did play it would take a little while to get back to near his best, but rest assured, he would make a very big impact on Sturt and the SANFL, particularly around September (not that followers of South or Port would need to be concerned there).

If I were an opposition supporter I would rather he just coached!

MST wrote:

GWW wrote:

westcoastpanther wrote:Good ruckman only I reckon. After a couple of years away and not having the excessive talent to play KP forward or back, I don't think opposition CHB or CHF's would be shaking in their boots. IMHO

I agree, wouldn't be a huge threat in the SANFL this year if he made a comeback.

I would strongly disagree gents.

I am not for one minute suggesting he will play but if he did he would be extremely handy both in the ruck and in a KP. He has had trouble with his back but we must all remember he was training full time in the AFL and that wouldn't have helped the cause. The guy is only 31 yo, is built like a brick outhouse and has a great footy brain. He has a rowing background and as such his natural fitness and ability is terrific.

He would need to be managed carefully and IF he did play it would take a little while to get back to near his best, but rest assured, he would make a very big impact on Sturt and the SANFL, particularly around September (not that followers of South or Port would need to be concerned there).

If I were an opposition supporter I would rather he just coached!

Still not concerned

Not concerned about 6 consecutive wooden spoons either

Im just hopin he does play !!!!

MST wrote:

GWW wrote:

westcoastpanther wrote:Good ruckman only I reckon. After a couple of years away and not having the excessive talent to play KP forward or back, I don't think opposition CHB or CHF's would be shaking in their boots. IMHO

I agree, wouldn't be a huge threat in the SANFL this year if he made a comeback.

I would strongly disagree gents.

I am not for one minute suggesting he will play but if he did he would be extremely handy both in the ruck and in a KP. He has had trouble with his back but we must all remember he was training full time in the AFL and that wouldn't have helped the cause. The guy is only 31 yo, is built like a brick outhouse and has a great footy brain. He has a rowing background and as such his natural fitness and ability is terrific.

He would need to be managed carefully and IF he did play it would take a little while to get back to near his best, but rest assured, he would make a very big impact on Sturt and the SANFL, particularly around September (not that followers of South or Port would need to be concerned there).

If I were an opposition supporter I would rather he just coached!

Was that neccessary......

Possibly a tad harsh I guess.

westcoastpanther wrote:

MST wrote:

GWW wrote:

westcoastpanther wrote:Good ruckman only I reckon. After a couple of years away and not having the excessive talent to play KP forward or back, I don't think opposition CHB or CHF's would be shaking in their boots. IMHO

I agree, wouldn't be a huge threat in the SANFL this year if he made a comeback.

I would strongly disagree gents.

I am not for one minute suggesting he will play but if he did he would be extremely handy both in the ruck and in a KP. He has had trouble with his back but we must all remember he was training full time in the AFL and that wouldn't have helped the cause. The guy is only 31 yo, is built like a brick outhouse and has a great footy brain. He has a rowing background and as such his natural fitness and ability is terrific.

He would need to be managed carefully and IF he did play it would take a little while to get back to near his best, but rest assured, he would make a very big impact on Sturt and the SANFL, particularly around September (not that followers of South or Port would need to be concerned there).

If I were an opposition supporter I would rather he just coached!

Was that neccessary......

There seems to be an assumption that Sturt will make the finals this year!

I didn't see a lot of French after he left SA, but I always saw him as a serviceable rather than a good ruckman. However, I haven't seen much of the SANFL standard since 1998, so I don't know where he will fit there.

Psyber wrote:I didn't see a lot of French after he left SA, but I always saw him as a serviceable rather than a good ruckman. However, I haven't seen much of the SANFL standard since 1998, so I don't know where he will fit there.

from memory, i think he played more in a kp than he did in ruck (i did say from memory )

bayman wrote:

Psyber wrote:I didn't see a lot of French after he left SA, but I always saw him as a serviceable rather than a good ruckman. However, I haven't seen much of the SANFL standard since 1998, so I don't know where he will fit there.

from memory, i think he played more in a kp than he did in ruck (i did say from memory )

Found him:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnaby_French

bayman wrote:

Psyber wrote:I didn't see a lot of French after he left SA, but I always saw him as a serviceable rather than a good ruckman. However, I haven't seen much of the SANFL standard since 1998, so I don't know where he will fit there.

from memory, i think he played more in a kp than he did in ruck (i did say from memory )

Probably played more as a ruckman in the AFL and more as a kpp in the SANFL.

Which Sturt youngster did his SHoulder int he trial on the weekend? not good for the kid and for a Sturt player hes a pretty good bloke!

faces a while on the sidelines...get better soon lad