SA Footy

was listening to coastfm this moring & brenton honor comes on with his preview etc & when asked about james allens magarey medal win he said 'a big upset with him winning it'

all betting agencies had him around the even money mark most other sanfl experts had him in the placings at worst & honor says a big upset

to coastfm, get a real expert like punk, mal, dutchy, wedgie & even myself to talk sanfl because he has no idea & whats worse is he coached my club

Seriously how much more can Brenton Honour possibly get wrong? The worst media expert by a long shot and there would be no "upset" with him winning that award in a landslide if there was one!

I think he's failed to select 1 winner in the finals series.

Fingers crossed he picks the dogs on Sunday

Would you say his coaching stint was pretty similar to his journalistic stint, and for the same reason?

Hallelujah!

Guys, agree wholeheartedly with all your posts.

And I should know, I used to play under him!

Poor guy, Rhino! Commiserations!

His coaching at the bays was enough to prove everyone he had no idea!

woodwt wrote:His coaching at the bays was enough to prove everyone he had no idea!

totally agree

I think Brenton Honor fits in quite well at Coast FM

A shonk at a shonky radio station.

Punk Rooster wrote:I think he's failed to select 1 winner in the finals series.

sorry punk he picked north

kookas wrote:

woodwt wrote:His coaching at the bays was enough to prove everyone he had no idea!

totally agree

the day at woodville he slapped marcus baldwin in the face, that then to my way of thinking proved he has no idea in man management let alone tactics in the coaches box, i was in the rooms before the a game at unley & while we were down somewhere near the bottom, so were sturt who had had 'crisis meetings' with carmen & the players during the week & the final speech was (paraphrasing) 'this mob has had meetings on whether to sacked their coach or not, so go out there & put them out of their misery & end their season, history shows sturt won comfortably. i saw no tactics on the board just this end their season

woodwt wrote:His coaching at the bays was enough to prove everyone he had no idea!

Hehe yeah, i was going to say, we could have told you that years ago!

Never had any time for him as a player or coach and cant really comment re his radio and paper comments cos I can honestly say Ive never listened or read anything with his name behind it. [Why would you bother]

in fairness its probably the king hit he got in a reserves game at alberton (i wont mention who hit him) years ago & that knocked him completely stupid

bayman wrote:in fairness its probably the king hit he got in a reserves game at alberton (i wont mention who hit him) years ago & that knocked him completely stupid

Amazing how karma works though... i.e. the hitter

He did bring the 14 man flood to the SANFL... About the only thing I've seen him predict correctly is the result of the 2003 1st Semi; everything else he has got wrong.

spell_check wrote:He did bring the 14 man flood to the SANFL... About the only thing I've seen him predict correctly is the result of the 2003 1st Semi; everything else he has got wrong.

its funny you say that spelly because a year or so ago when on the abc tv broadcast they were talking about how the afl with their flooding tactics were spoiling footy as a spectacle & in some way were ruining the game.....which i was amazed at seeing he brought it to the sanfl a couple of years or so earlier, which makes me wrong as he did have a tactic afterall

what was wrong with the HONOR years at glenelg besides not winning, no tactics, no players etc.....

bayman wrote:

Punk Rooster wrote:I think he's failed to select 1 winner in the finals series.

sorry punk he picked north

there you go punk, you had no hope since friday morning when he picked north