SA Footy

I hope hes improved on what he did at Port,

Mathew Knights has been appointed coach of Essendon for the next 3 Years.

Staggering move.

i'd doubt he'd last the 3 years they've employed him for, a staggering move imho

They obviously didn't take into account his time at Alberton and the reasons why he left! Surely blokes like Hardwick and Sumich would feel hard done by - not to mention Daniher!

BPBRB wrote:They obviously didn't take into account his time at Alberton and the reasons why he left!!

Do tell?

Plunge Penguin wrote:

BPBRB wrote:They obviously didn't take into account his time at Alberton and the reasons why he left!!

Do tell?

Best coming from a Port supporter who would know! Let's just say the Players, Management and Board all hated him by the time he left!

BPBRB wrote:

Plunge Penguin wrote:

BPBRB wrote:They obviously didn't take into account his time at Alberton and the reasons why he left!!

Do tell?

Best coming from a Port supporter who would know! Let's just say the Players, Management and Board all hated him by the time he left!

I quite enjoyed his coaching stint.

smithy wrote:

BPBRB wrote:

Plunge Penguin wrote:

BPBRB wrote:They obviously didn't take into account his time at Alberton and the reasons why he left!!

Do tell?

Best coming from a Port supporter who would know! Let's just say the Players, Management and Board all hated him by the time he left!

I quite enjoyed his coaching stint.

Good point - now if they can just continue to replicate his stint now, although I think Ginever is trying hard to do a "Knights"!

well he does have the advantage of already having knowledge of the playing group, that may have helped him get the job

the bOmbers for Spoon in 08

LMFAO!

Wasn't it after he coached PAM's they brought back Jack to rescue the club? So does that mean they will reappoint Sheeds in a couple of seasons after 2/3 years of wooden trophy's!! WTF are the Bomber's thinking!!

TroyGFC wrote:Wasn't it after he coached PAM's they brought back Jack to rescue the club? So does that mean they will reappoint Sheeds in a couple of seasons after 2/3 years of wooden trophy's!! WTF are the Bomber's thinking!!

totally agree

He didnt nothing but create drama when he was at alberton, nobody liked him

I applaud the Essendon football club in appointing such a well
proven coach...75 games for 27 wins and 48 loses including
the stint at Port Magpies...
Well done Essendon..watch the Bombers fly up,up....

SJABC wrote:=D>

I applaud the Essendon football club in appointing such a well
proven coach...75 games for 27 wins and 48 loses including
the stint at Port Magpies...
Well done Essendon..watch the Bombers fly up,up....

Who did Carlton appoint? What was his record?

Brett Ratten.
After finishing at the Blues, went to the Dees for a year as assistant, the coached Norwood in the EFL, where he took them to the GF.
During this time also coached the EFL rep side, then in 2006 back to Carlton as assistant.
Carlton B & F in 1995 (premiership year), 97 & 2000. Captain Carlton 2002-2003.

Unlike Essendon people I have spoken too who aren't too happy with the appointment of Knights, all I can say is that I am rapped that the Blues have Ratts, as I have met the man, and none more genuine nor Carlton orientated then he..

Just the numbers, thanks.

smac wrote:Just the numbers, thanks.

For Norwood 21 wins to 14 loses.
EPL 1 win 0 loses
CFC 0 win 6 loses.

Reasonably limited I guess, but better than I though. Thanks for the info.

Interesting that both clubs appointed from within, when they have been shithouse for more than a short period.

With what was on offer, those who applied, this would have to be one of the most controversial appointments of an AFL coach in years

locky801 wrote:With what was on offer, those who applied, this would have to be one of the most controversial appointments of an AFL coach in years

Agreed, there were a couple of comments re Ratts at Carlton & Bails at Melbourne, but nothing like Knights at Bomberland...

IMO...I believe that Essendon may have erred on this one. It'd be hard for a club to appoint a coach after having the same one close to 30 odd years. The main reason given was Knights presentation to the selection committee was the best. Wether they looked at his record with the PAM's who knows. The fact he was coaching the Bendigo Bombers without a lot of success hangs a question mark also.
Time will tell but IMO, I feel the appointments of Ratten & Bailey were the better choices for both the Carlton & Melbourne footy clubs, as for Knights the jury is out...well out...