2009 State Game - SANFL vs WAFL in Perth

[sjt]

so he is out of your thoughts cause he has missed one game?

I think it's pretty obvious what he said (Phil). If recovered you'd look at him. Not hard to understand.

[Big Phil]

so he is out of your thoughts cause he has missed one game?

I think it's pretty obvious what he said (Phil). If recovered you'd look at him. Not hard to understand.

Exactly

AGAIN, HE WOULD BE IN MY STARTING SIDE IF THE SHOULDER IS GOOD AND HE FINDS FORM BETWEEN NOW AND LATE MAY

What more do you need to know Dutch man ??!!!

[Dutchy]

SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Coach: Darel Hart

FF: Daniel Havelberg Brant Chambers Ian Callinan

HF: James Gowans Clint Alleway Eddie Sansbury

C: James Allan Jade Sheedy James Gallagher

HB: Paul Thomas (C) Damon White Ryan Williams

FB: Luke Panozzo Corey AhChee Brett Zorzi

RK: Trevor Cranston Jeremy Clayton (VC) Chad O'Sullivan

INT: Jason Mackenzie Chris Gowans Tristian Gum Mark Mackenzie


Players I reckon will be a chance for the squad from each club:

CENTRALS:
Ian Callinan
Chad O'Sullivan
Eddie Sansbury
Scott Dutschke
Paul Thomas
Jason Mackenzie
Chris Gowans
James Gowans
Ryan Williams
Daniel Havelberg
Brayden O'Hara

GLENELG:
Trevor Cranston
Danny Meyer *
Luke Panozzo
Adam Fisher
Ty Allen
Ben Kane

STURT:
Brant Chambers
Jade Sheedy
Tristian Gum
Brodie Martin *
Luke Crane
Michael Coad

NORWOOD:
Brett Zorzi
James Gallagher
Kris Massie
Nick Duigan

PORT:
Jeremy Clayton
Corey Ah Chee
James Mieklejohn

EAGLES:
Mark Mackenzie
Luke Jarrad
Luke Powell
Ken McGregor
Brad Dabrowski

NORTH:
James Allan
Rhys Archard
Damon White
Matthew Wright
Cain Ackland
Ben Schwarze

SOUTH:
Craig Parry
James Boyd
Jason Torney
Ben Warren

WEST:
Stephen Bailey
Damien Cupido
Chris Schmidt *
Ryan Ferguson

* Still eligable for selction as only AFL Rookie Listed players

49 players there and no Backwell......suggest you go back and edit if he is in your initial squad

[smac]

I guess I didn't consider guys like Brett Backwell, Luke Crane, Todd Grima, Bryce Campbell, Leigh Treeby, Heath Younie, Daniel Schell, David Trotter, Byron Murphy, Andrew Hayes etc etc because they have had interrupted starts to the season with various injury concerns.

You left that part of his post out Dutchy. Don't be selective with your quoting...

[Dutchy]

I guess I didn't consider guys like Brett Backwell, Luke Crane, Todd Grima, Bryce Campbell, Leigh Treeby, Heath Younie, Daniel Schell, David Trotter, Byron Murphy, Andrew Hayes etc etc because they have had interrupted starts to the season with various injury concerns.

You left that part of his post out Dutchy. Don't be selective with your quoting...

No its quite clear he didnt consider him as he admited above, but then later he says he would play him...either he is in the squad or not, surely?

[smac]

Squads can change and have done many times in the past. If he proves fitness he can be added. And remember, this is Phil's imaginary squad. Feel free to whip up your own with Backwell in it from the get-go.

[LBJ8]

Are we going on form for this year? because if we are i wouldn't have Mouse, Cranston or Ben Kane in personally not having a stab at you dutchy but i just don't think either of those players have been playing there best footy so far this year.

[Big Phil]

Squads can change and have done many times in the past. If he proves fitness he can be added. And remember, this is Phil's imaginary squad. Feel free to whip up your own with Backwell in it from the get-go.

Exactly...

Gees Dutchy, you are dragging me over the coals for a "made up squad"...

Yes, I said in one post that I haven't considered Mouse in the squad at this point in time due to a current injury...

BUT

In another post, I said IF he was fit and finds form, he would be a definate starter in my final side selected...

What more do you want from me, you are getting carried away about an imaginary squad mate !!??

[Big Phil]

I guess I didn't consider guys like Brett Backwell, Luke Crane, Todd Grima, Bryce Campbell, Leigh Treeby, Heath Younie, Daniel Schell, David Trotter, Byron Murphy, Andrew Hayes etc etc because they have had interrupted starts to the season with various injury concerns.

You left that part of his post out Dutchy. Don't be selective with your quoting...

No its quite clear he didnt consider him as he admited above, but then later he says he would play him...either he is in the squad or not, surely?

IT'S MAKE BELIEVE MATE...

I'm NOT DARYL HART !!!

[Dutchy]

A squad that is up for discussion, with a squad of of 49 players (which is 25% of SANFL players) I would have thought a player of Mouse's credentials would be in there....he has played 3 of the 4 games


you put a squad up for discussion and thats what we are doing arent we? Struth!

[Big Phil]

A squad that is up for discussion, with a squad of of 49 players (which is 25% of SANFL players) I would have thought a player of Mouse's credentials would be in there....he has played 3 of the 4 games


you put a squad up for discussion and thats what we are doing arent we? Struth!

Absouletly mate, no probalems with the discussion about the squad...

BUT you are making a mountain out of mole hill, storm in a tea cup etc etc...

I'll edit my squad for you to have BACKWELL in there Dutchy, so can we move onto to other discussions about the side...

[Big Phil]

BUMP...

SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Coach: Darel Hart

FF: Daniel Havelberg Brant Chambers Ian Callinan

HF: James Gowans Clint Alleway Eddie Sansbury

C: James Allan Jade Sheedy James Gallagher

HB: Paul Thomas (C) Damon White Ryan Williams

FB: Luke Panozzo Corey AhChee Brett Zorzi

RK: Trevor Cranston Jeremy Clayton (VC) Chad O'Sullivan

INT: Jason Mackenzie Chris Gowans Tristian Gum Mark Mackenzie


Players I reckon will be a chance for the squad from each club:

CENTRALS:
Ian Callinan
Chad O'Sullivan
Eddie Sansbury
Scott Dutschke
Paul Thomas
Jason Mackenzie
Chris Gowans
James Gowans
Ryan Williams
Daniel Havelberg
Brayden O'Hara

GLENELG:
Trevor Cranston
Danny Meyer *
Luke Panozzo
Adam Fisher
Ty Allen
Ben Kane
Brett Backwell **

STURT:
Brant Chambers
Jade Sheedy
Tristian Gum
Brodie Martin *
Luke Crane
Michael Coad

NORWOOD:
Brett Zorzi
James Gallagher
Kris Massie
Nick Duigan

PORT:
Jeremy Clayton
Corey Ah Chee
James Mieklejohn

EAGLES:
Mark Mackenzie
Luke Jarrad
Luke Powell
Ken McGregor
Brad Dabrowski

NORTH:
James Allan
Rhys Archard
Damon White
Matthew Wright
Cain Ackland
Ben Schwarze

SOUTH:
Craig Parry
James Boyd
Jason Torney
Ben Warren

WEST:
Stephen Bailey
Damien Cupido
Chris Schmidt *
Ryan Ferguson

* Still eligable for selction as only AFL Rookie Listed players

49 players there and no Backwell......suggest you go back and edit if he is in your initial squad

EDIT...

** For Dutchy's satisfaction

[Dutchy]

Hooray

[Big Phil]

Hooray

[Squawk]

Would Mouse now be in the running to be Captain?

*runs and hides*

[Dutchy]

Well well well guess who is back and named to play this weekend?

[Squawk]

Well well well guess who is back and named to play this weekend?

\
Shaun Burgoyne?

[redandblack]

I wouldn't think Chris Schmidt would make the side ATM, but Damien Cupido would have to be one of the form defenders in the league.

[Big Phil]

Well well well guess who is back and named to play this weekend?

Pending a fitness test tomorrow night Dutch man

[sjt]

Would Mouse now be in the running to be Captain?

*runs and hides*

Playing coach!

also *runs and hides*