Page 2 of 2

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2023 9:23 am
by Brodlach
am Bays wrote:More evidence for the current Westies to say the green shoots are maturing and we’re on the right track


Yep agree, only won 4 games but was only beaten 4 times by more than 5 goals and was competitive in all games except 1 which I couldn’t have said in previous seasons.

Not once did we play with our best 5 players on the ground all year, captain Brand didn’t play at all.

Adam Hartlett continues to improve this group and deserves a lot of credit. A couple of goal scoring talls would be exactly what we need

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2023 12:44 pm
by northerner
Brodlach wrote:
am Bays wrote:More evidence for the current Westies to say the green shoots are maturing and we’re on the right track


Yep agree, only won 4 games but was only beaten 4 times by more than 5 goals and was competitive in all games except 1 which I couldn’t have said in previous seasons.

Not once did we play with our best 5 players on the ground all year, captain Brand didn’t play at all.

Adam Hartlett continues to improve this group and deserves a lot of credit. A couple of goal scoring talls would be exactly what we need

And an SANFL star who will be joining for mums cooking will help.

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2023 1:03 pm
by another grub
no Maxie Marslen hurt

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2023 5:48 pm
by Brodlach
northerner wrote:
Brodlach wrote:
am Bays wrote:More evidence for the current Westies to say the green shoots are maturing and we’re on the right track


Yep agree, only won 4 games but was only beaten 4 times by more than 5 goals and was competitive in all games except 1 which I couldn’t have said in previous seasons.

Not once did we play with our best 5 players on the ground all year, captain Brand didn’t play at all.

Adam Hartlett continues to improve this group and deserves a lot of credit. A couple of goal scoring talls would be exactly what we need

And an SANFL star who will be joining for mums cooking will help.


What does that mean?

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2023 7:40 pm
by Thiele
Brodlach wrote:
northerner wrote:
Brodlach wrote:
am Bays wrote:More evidence for the current Westies to say the green shoots are maturing and we’re on the right track


Yep agree, only won 4 games but was only beaten 4 times by more than 5 goals and was competitive in all games except 1 which I couldn’t have said in previous seasons.

Not once did we play with our best 5 players on the ground all year, captain Brand didn’t play at all.

Adam Hartlett continues to improve this group and deserves a lot of credit. A couple of goal scoring talls would be exactly what we need

And an SANFL star who will be joining for mums cooking will help.


What does that mean?[/quote ]Think of the CEO of West Adelaide, her son plays for Sturt

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2023 7:47 pm
by Thiele
I must it was nice to see Adam give the young kids ago like, Bock ,Thackery, and in the last round like White and Obst and they didn't look out of place

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2023 7:58 pm
by Brodlach
Ah, gotcha!

I wish but just a dream

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Mon Aug 28, 2023 10:24 pm
by wedgetail
Didn't see the game but disappointing the Eags couldn't send off Sheeds with a win. West are no longer easy beats and have shown a lot more resilience this year. Lonergan's retirement predictable. A valuable component of our back to back premierships and often under estimated in his impact on games.

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Tue Aug 29, 2023 4:38 pm
by northerner
Troy Menzel copped a two-game ban for a bump, that certainly could be argued the opposition was as much at fault for causing the collision.

However, I am not sure the Club will challenge on Troys behalf, especially as it seems he is unlikely to be there next season.

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Tue Aug 29, 2023 4:50 pm
by Big Phil
northerner wrote:Troy Menzel copped a two-game ban for a bump, that certainly could be argued the opposition was as much at fault for causing the collision.

However, I am not sure the Club will challenge on Troys behalf, especially as it seems he is unlikely to be there next season.


Could be a home coming of sorts, perhaps? TTG maybe?

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Tue Aug 29, 2023 5:10 pm
by Sticks28
Big Phil wrote:
northerner wrote:Troy Menzel copped a two-game ban for a bump, that certainly could be argued the opposition was as much at fault for causing the collision.

However, I am not sure the Club will challenge on Troys behalf, especially as it seems he is unlikely to be there next season.


Could be a home coming of sorts, perhaps? TTG maybe?


I could potentially see him ending up at Golden grove with his brother. Unless they both go out to the country for monster amounts of cash

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Tue Aug 29, 2023 5:56 pm
by MW
wedgetail wrote:Didn't see the game but disappointing the Eags couldn't send off Sheeds with a win. West are no longer easy beats and have shown a lot more resilience this year. Lonergan's retirement predictable. A valuable component of our back to back premierships and often under estimated in his impact on games.


I hear this at the end of every season...

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Tue Aug 29, 2023 6:05 pm
by gazzamagoo
MW wrote:
wedgetail wrote:Didn't see the game but disappointing the Eags couldn't send off Sheeds with a win. West are no longer easy beats and have shown a lot more resilience this year. Lonergan's retirement predictable. A valuable component of our back to back premierships and often under estimated in his impact on games.


I hear this at the end of every season...


Yep, the bigger concern is the poor performance across the grades.

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Tue Aug 29, 2023 6:32 pm
by MW
gazzamagoo wrote:
MW wrote:
wedgetail wrote:Didn't see the game but disappointing the Eags couldn't send off Sheeds with a win. West are no longer easy beats and have shown a lot more resilience this year. Lonergan's retirement predictable. A valuable component of our back to back premierships and often under estimated in his impact on games.


I hear this at the end of every season...


Yep, the bigger concern is the poor performance across the grades.


Yeah normally strong in the lower grades, not this year. Maybe due to the senior team pinching them throughout the year? who knows...

Re: Round 18 Eagles v West

PostPosted: Tue Aug 29, 2023 7:30 pm
by Brodlach
Had to do something different this year and they played the kids. Hopefully they stick together and success comes.

Certainly effected the lower grades