robert shirley

[Thiele]

I hope that the two week ban stands

[the joker]

I hope that the two week ban stands

i hope not, Chris Judd is Roberts Shirleys Bitch, you would be conflicted wouldnt you Thiele being a westies and a crow supporter

[Thiele]

I hope that the two week ban stands

i hope not, Chris Judd is Roberts Shirleys Bitch, you would be conflicted wouldnt you Thiele being a westies and a crow supporter

Iam conflicted. But he got what he desreves

[NFC]

I hope he gets 4 now.

[SnappyTom]

I hope he gets 4 now.

I'm with you.

[whufc]

show some balls SANFL and make the suspension stand.

It was obvious the moment that the Eagles appealed it was coming from the crows.

I asked earlier whether the crows could just play him or not i wouldn't be surprised if they do, even if the suspension isn't over-turned. The AFL clubs are a rule to themselves when it comes to the SANFL competition.

If the roles were reversed and Fisher dumped any Eagles player would have Neil Craig's footage become available i think not.

Just because your season is gone crows don't ruin all the SANFL supporters season.

[whufc]

I hope he gets 4 now.

I'm with you.

I kind of hope he gets off, plays for the crows and does his hammy in the first minute and the crows have to play a player short all game

[bayman]

Geez a lot of you blokes are going to upset "bayman" who insists that its the worst incident in the last 18 seasons

I dont think Shirley should get off but Im happy with the penalty handed down thus far.

WRONG YOU GOOSE I SAID IT IS THE WORST INCIDENT ''I HAVE SEEN'' SINCE THE 1991 GRAND FINAL.....


c'mon you name something worse that has happened on the sanfl playing arena since that day in 1991 ?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Geez a lot of you blokes are going to upset "bayman" who insists that its the worst incident in the last 18 seasons

I dont think Shirley should get off but Im happy with the penalty handed down thus far.

WRONG YOU GOOSE I SAID IT IS THE WORST INCIDENT ''I HAVE SEEN'' SINCE THE 1991 GRAND FINAL.....


c'mon you name something worse that has happened on the sanfl playing arena since that day in 1991 ?

Totally agree with you bayman. Westies were pathetic that day.

[eddie eagle]

Geez a lot of you blokes are going to upset "bayman" who insists that its the worst incident in the last 18 seasons

I dont think Shirley should get off but Im happy with the penalty handed down thus far.

WRONG YOU GOOSE I SAID IT IS THE WORST INCIDENT ''I HAVE SEEN'' SINCE THE 1991 GRAND FINAL.....


c'mon you name something worse that has happened on the sanfl playing arena since that day in 1991 ?

King hit in 2007 SANFL grand final was worse IMO

[Thiele]

Any news

[centrecirclelegend]

Geez a lot of you blokes are going to upset "bayman" who insists that its the worst incident in the last 18 seasons

I dont think Shirley should get off but Im happy with the penalty handed down thus far.

WRONG YOU GOOSE I SAID IT IS THE WORST INCIDENT ''I HAVE SEEN'' SINCE THE 1991 GRAND FINAL.....


c'mon you name something worse that has happened on the sanfl playing arena since that day in 1991 ?

richard champions face getting smashed in by that bay player who is now a builder.......

[spell_check]

Geez a lot of you blokes are going to upset "bayman" who insists that its the worst incident in the last 18 seasons

I dont think Shirley should get off but Im happy with the penalty handed down thus far.

WRONG YOU GOOSE I SAID IT IS THE WORST INCIDENT ''I HAVE SEEN'' SINCE THE 1991 GRAND FINAL.....


c'mon you name something worse that has happened on the sanfl playing arena since that day in 1991 ?

richard champions face getting smashed in by that bay player who is now a builder.......

That was in 1990.

[southee]

SANFL needs to keep their stance on this....otherwise Weak as P**s

[Thiele]

So if Shirley gets off does it mean its ok to do spear tackles. He has done a crime so he should the time. I don't care if he belongs to the Power or the Crows. He could of cost some-one a carreer

[Wedgie]

The appeal was unsuccessful, Shirely's ban of 2 weeks will remain.

Probably a fair result in the end.

[Blacky]

should have got 5

[Thiele]

The appeal was unsuccessful, Shirely's ban of 2 weeks will remain.

Probably a fair result in the end.

Thanks

[am Bays]

Geez a lot of you blokes are going to upset "bayman" who insists that its the worst incident in the last 18 seasons

I dont think Shirley should get off but Im happy with the penalty handed down thus far.

WRONG YOU GOOSE I SAID IT IS THE WORST INCIDENT ''I HAVE SEEN'' SINCE THE 1991 GRAND FINAL.....


c'mon you name something worse that has happened on the sanfl playing arena since that day in 1991 ?

King hit in 2007 SANFL grand final was worse IMO

I was going to say that too, McIntosh on Dew in teh 1997 prelim and the GFC circa 2000-2002

[eddie eagle]

I just wonder, if being named in the crows side, prior to knowing the result of the appeal, is significant?

I expect it now means that his "first match" will be the AFL match against carlton on saturday.

He may only miss the centrals or hawthorn match as his second match.

Could be a nice move by the Crows, assisting their player, within the rules!!.