InoUno wrote:Instead of bagging scotty pascoe for coming of the fence, which made no difference to the finish result you should be congratulating for Elsi Who being the only local to keep some of the stakemoney in SA in either of the group races on Sat night!! Was also a great run in vic oaks week earlier coming from last on the home turn.
You also seem to talk about someone you know nothing about, how retarded you sound by wanting to add a driver of some 500 winners and one of the best mares to have raced in SA in the last decade in Carvils Choice to a list of "incompetents". Get a Life!
That's right.. Elsie Who - ran 3rd in a field of 7 - in which 4 horses galloped, including one that beat her home..
I believe that coming off the fence did make a difference to the race - If Pascoe stays to the fence and gets cover off the winner (and the only horse travelling well around him at the time) then he runs 2nd.. because the 2nd horse wouldn't have been able to duck inside him to beat him home... It was a poor tactical decision and it's not the first one in the past month, given he's driving $10 - $20k horses from NZ and is struggling to get a winner considering the horses he has...
Elsie Who went super at Moonee Valley a week before - when held up until turning from home, so why come off the fence and overdrive it this week - when it went the way it did last week?? Poor decision making that's why.. Itchy Fingers.... The sprint lane was there or pull out turning for home - but to come off 600m from home when the leader (winner) was travelling so good and everything else was struggling was a poor drive - bordering on incompetent....
As for Carvils Choice - 9 years is a long time ago... Pascoe may have been an ok driver then - but this is a long time down the track and with the horses he is driving, he should be getting more winners then he is!
If you want to go back - i'll take B Clarke on Gammalite in the mid 80's as my example - he drove lots and lots of winners of the horse.. does it make him a good driver now?? Not to me..
You can't bag a bloke for 1 bad drive, I agree with that - but when he constantly overdrives them and gets them beat - then he's doing a Scaffidi......
Again, you can't say a bloke is a champion on the back of 1 good driver - but if you want me to wrap him up - well I did see a good drive this week - look at La Bella Mafia.. doesn't overdrive this week and it wins.. nice horse needs to be driven cold (not 3 wide at the bell with no cover) - but this horse should be winning races like that because it's a nice horse!!
Centreman - completely agree with your post on the winner of the oaks (local bred & owned - that's something we should be congratulating the local industry on, great effort by all involved with the young horse
) drivers and situations in races and especially the prizemoney...
Driving in races is one of the hardest things to do, I don't doubt that because one mistake can cost your horse the race - but it's the constant decision making that makes them either a good or incompetent driver...
I would rather have some of the blokes i'm going to name below (who don't get a real go) rather then some of the drivers that overdrive their horses all the time go around a bit more often...
Simon Jones (has been driving a few winners off no real opportunities)
Mark Norman (Does ok with the drives he has - generally looking for luck)
Terry Hayes (Can't remember the last horse he drove with ability, but positions them good)
Jeremy Seal (Drive on Zerrafoss yesterday was really good - horse didn't finish off 2nd up from a lenghty spell (should improve on yesterdays run I think) + drove that trotter Land Invasion really really good the other week)
Symon Kittel (Is good at the push and shove and moves horses out the way and holds his ground really well)
Just to name a few good drivers off limited oportunites - but then you get other blokes who have to overdrive every horse they have and give them limited oportunites to win races..
Probably was a bit harsh to lump Pascoe in with Biddell, Champion (snr + jrn), McBride, Crawford but you can't keep overdriving them and be called a good driver when you don't get results....
Port Power has 16 years history at Football Park...
The Port Magpies have 40 years history and the two shall never be confused or combined