by BUZZ » Fri Mar 21, 2008 5:38 pm
by LaughingKookaburra » Fri Mar 21, 2008 5:42 pm
BUZZ wrote:I beleive an top A1 side would be able to match it with a lower SANFL side and will certainly clean up a SANFL reserves side. A mate of mine rekons im silly and there would be a 10 goal difference with the reserves and 20+ with a league side.
Your views..........
by bickle » Fri Mar 21, 2008 7:04 pm
by BUZZ » Fri Mar 21, 2008 7:14 pm
by Jayne » Fri Mar 21, 2008 9:39 pm
LaughingKookaburra wrote:BUZZ wrote:I beleive an top A1 side would be able to match it with a lower SANFL side and will certainly clean up a SANFL reserves side. A mate of mine rekons im silly and there would be a 10 goal difference with the reserves and 20+ with a league side.
Your views..........
That is very ambitious. Goody would not get close to West Adelaide of last year. I reckon 20 goals is being generous.
by silent hour » Sat Mar 22, 2008 11:42 am
by silent hour » Sat Mar 22, 2008 8:12 pm
by Redandblack00 » Sat Mar 22, 2008 9:03 pm
by silent hour » Sat Mar 22, 2008 9:57 pm
Redandblack00 wrote:silent hour wrote:After watching the West v South trial game today I might have to change my mind about the top 4 div 1 teams not being able to beat an SANFL league team. Both West and South skill levels were atrocious and I know it was only a trial but on todays effort I would expect a top 4 div 1 side would not only be able to match either West or South but maybe even beat them.
My opinion only
HAHA... Are you serious? You cant be? I spoke to Matty Illman about this months ago and he said even how bad Westies were the last few years, there was no way their premiership side would get near West. He said 15 goals minimum. Remember all these blokes were fringe players/reserves players at LEAGUE CLUBS!!! There are some players that may not be up to it at westies but you have to remember 3/4 of the side would laugh at an amatuer side. Can you imagine one of the Amatuer hacks on CUPIDO one out in the goalsquare.... ?? Lenny Clarke rucking against Illman? You need to show more respect!
Post this thread in the SANFL thread and you people who think a SAAFL side could beat an SANFL side would shot down quick smart!
You dont see too many amatuer players come out and dominate SANFL, actually you usually see them play 3-4 reserves games and go back to where they come from cause they cant get a kick in the reserves!!!!! FFS.... what a joke....
by Jayne » Sat Mar 22, 2008 10:04 pm
Redandblack00 wrote:silent hour wrote:After watching the West v South trial game today I might have to change my mind about the top 4 div 1 teams not being able to beat an SANFL league team. Both West and South skill levels were atrocious and I know it was only a trial but on todays effort I would expect a top 4 div 1 side would not only be able to match either West or South but maybe even beat them.
My opinion only
HAHA... Are you serious? You cant be? I spoke to Matty Illman about this months ago and he said even how bad Westies were the last few years, there was no way their premiership side would get near West. He said 15 goals minimum. Remember all these blokes were fringe players/reserves players at LEAGUE CLUBS!!! There are some players that may not be up to it at westies but you have to remember 3/4 of the side would laugh at an amatuer side. Can you imagine one of the Amatuer hacks on CUPIDO one out in the goalsquare.... ?? Lenny Clarke rucking against Illman? You need to show more respect!
Post this thread in the SANFL thread and you people who think a SAAFL side could beat an SANFL side would shot down quick smart!
You dont see too many amatuer players come out and dominate SANFL, actually you usually see them play 3-4 reserves games and go back to where they come from cause they cant get a kick in the reserves!!!!! FFS.... what a joke....
by brod » Sat Mar 22, 2008 11:24 pm
Jayne wrote:Redandblack00 wrote:silent hour wrote:After watching the West v South trial game today I might have to change my mind about the top 4 div 1 teams not being able to beat an SANFL league team. Both West and South skill levels were atrocious and I know it was only a trial but on todays effort I would expect a top 4 div 1 side would not only be able to match either West or South but maybe even beat them.
My opinion only
HAHA... Are you serious? You cant be? I spoke to Matty Illman about this months ago and he said even how bad Westies were the last few years, there was no way their premiership side would get near West. He said 15 goals minimum. Remember all these blokes were fringe players/reserves players at LEAGUE CLUBS!!! There are some players that may not be up to it at westies but you have to remember 3/4 of the side would laugh at an amatuer side. Can you imagine one of the Amatuer hacks on CUPIDO one out in the goalsquare.... ?? Lenny Clarke rucking against Illman? You need to show more respect!
Post this thread in the SANFL thread and you people who think a SAAFL side could beat an SANFL side would shot down quick smart!
You dont see too many amatuer players come out and dominate SANFL, actually you usually see them play 3-4 reserves games and go back to where they come from cause they cant get a kick in the reserves!!!!! FFS.... what a joke....
Since when has Lenny Clark become a superstar - I haven't seen a double figure possesion count since his return from QLD?
Not sure Mark Demasi and Scott Webb would enjoy being referred to as former 'fringe' SANFL players, you mentioned respect R&B I didn't notice too much of it in your post...
by Wedgie » Sun Mar 23, 2008 3:13 am
Armchair expert wrote:Such a great club are Geelong
by bomber1976 » Sun Mar 23, 2008 10:53 am
brod wrote:Jayne wrote:Redandblack00 wrote:silent hour wrote:After watching the West v South trial game today I might have to change my mind about the top 4 div 1 teams not being able to beat an SANFL league team. Both West and South skill levels were atrocious and I know it was only a trial but on todays effort I would expect a top 4 div 1 side would not only be able to match either West or South but maybe even beat them.
My opinion only
HAHA... Are you serious? You cant be? I spoke to Matty Illman about this months ago and he said even how bad Westies were the last few years, there was no way their premiership side would get near West. He said 15 goals minimum. Remember all these blokes were fringe players/reserves players at LEAGUE CLUBS!!! There are some players that may not be up to it at westies but you have to remember 3/4 of the side would laugh at an amatuer side. Can you imagine one of the Amatuer hacks on CUPIDO one out in the goalsquare.... ?? Lenny Clarke rucking against Illman? You need to show more respect!
Post this thread in the SANFL thread and you people who think a SAAFL side could beat an SANFL side would shot down quick smart!
You dont see too many amatuer players come out and dominate SANFL, actually you usually see them play 3-4 reserves games and go back to where they come from cause they cant get a kick in the reserves!!!!! FFS.... what a joke....
Since when has Lenny Clark become a superstar - I haven't seen a double figure possesion count since his return from QLD?
Not sure Mark Demasi and Scott Webb would enjoy being referred to as former 'fringe' SANFL players, you mentioned respect R&B I didn't notice too much of it in your post...
Fringe? no way - REGULAR reserves player
by hawkseye » Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:31 pm
by gothebombers » Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:35 pm
hawkseye wrote:I think the only way to compare is the best v the best. So that means Centrals v Goodwood. Im thinking centrals by how much? Fitness is a big issue here. Previous posts have mentioned Demasi and Mills. Sure they would have footy knowledge and know where to go but is their engine the same as it was when they played league footy?
by GWW » Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:36 pm
gothebombers wrote:hawkseye wrote:I think the only way to compare is the best v the best. So that means Centrals v Goodwood. Im thinking centrals by how much? Fitness is a big issue here. Previous posts have mentioned Demasi and Mills. Sure they would have footy knowledge and know where to go but is their engine the same as it was when they played league footy?
well hawkeye , you played league (afl) 250 games for the hawks youd know better than most.
by the joker » Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:37 pm
by the joker » Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:38 pm
yeah who is hawkseyeGWW wrote:gothebombers wrote:hawkseye wrote:I think the only way to compare is the best v the best. So that means Centrals v Goodwood. Im thinking centrals by how much? Fitness is a big issue here. Previous posts have mentioned Demasi and Mills. Sure they would have footy knowledge and know where to go but is their engine the same as it was when they played league footy?
well hawkeye , you played league (afl) 250 games for the hawks youd know better than most.
Do we have a superstar on SA Footy.net
by hawkseye » Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:38 pm
by gothebombers » Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:39 pm
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |