by Booney » Mon Dec 08, 2025 3:00 pm
by wenchbarwer » Mon Dec 08, 2025 3:14 pm
by rd » Mon Dec 08, 2025 3:16 pm
by Lightning McQueen » Mon Dec 08, 2025 3:28 pm
mal wrote:whufc wrote:In the second innings England scored at 3.2 an over...........i'm not sure how people can say they haven't tried to adapt. That's as slow as they've gone in many years. That's almost as slow as test sides will go these days. Even taking out Stokes and Jacks partnership all the other players tempered back their natural aggression.
Yeah some players are struggling with the extra bounce and instinctively playing shots, we wouldn't play on our wickets but they're hardly the first lot of tourists to struggle with the extra bounce. Especially given first up they've been sent to Perth and Brisbane two of the bounciest wickets. But its not like their getting out charging down the wicket or trying reverse ramps.
The biggest criticism has to be on their preparation. Easy to mistake their tour as a working holiday with cricket on the side. Why some of the guys didnt play the lead up pink ball game ill never know.
Very good post
From what ive seen the Australian batters after the 1st dig in Perth have played as many iffy shots as the Poms
The Ozzies have done it better though
Steve Smith, for example , who entertained us all, played crazy shots, the type he really does not need to play v The Joff
The Green step back to the square leg fence and bowled was a shocker
BOOKMARK
The ball swings more in EG
We might be posting about the Australian batting techniques if they fail on the next tour of England
POMS rest of this tour
Batters who should or should not BAZBALL
CRAWLEY .................DEPENDS ON STATE OF GAME (next one is in SA)
DUCKETT ..................YES
POPE ........................DEPENDS
ROOT........................ NO
BROOKS.................. ABSOLUTELY MUST
STOKES................... DEPENDS
by dedja » Mon Dec 08, 2025 3:30 pm
by woodublieve12 » Mon Dec 08, 2025 3:34 pm

by Booney » Mon Dec 08, 2025 3:56 pm
by Armchair expert » Mon Dec 08, 2025 5:13 pm
by gadj1976 » Mon Dec 08, 2025 5:14 pm
whufc wrote:In the second innings England scored at 3.2 an over...........i'm not sure how people can say they haven't tried to adapt. That's as slow as they've gone in many years. That's almost as slow as test sides will go these days. Even taking out Stokes and Jacks partnership all the other players tempered back their natural aggression.
Yeah some players are struggling with the extra bounce and instinctively playing shots, we wouldn't play on our wickets but they're hardly the first lot of tourists to struggle with the extra bounce. Especially given first up they've been sent to Perth and Brisbane two of the bounciest wickets. But its not like their getting out charging down the wicket or trying reverse ramps.
The biggest criticism has to be on their preparation. Easy to mistake their tour as a working holiday with cricket on the side. Why some of the guys didnt play the lead up pink ball game ill never know.
by whufc » Tue Dec 09, 2025 6:08 am
Booney wrote:It our fault for believing the hype they built around themselves.
by am Bays » Tue Dec 09, 2025 8:13 am
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Dec 09, 2025 8:35 am
by wenchbarwer » Tue Dec 09, 2025 8:42 am
am Bays wrote:I'm still in awe of Carey's performance.
I'm sure there's several in here who've been in the nets and had the bowling machine cranked up to 80 MPH (~130 km/h) and even 90 MPH (~145 km/h).
60-70 I could sort of handle, but 80 and 90 MPH was getting out of my depth. Thank god I was wearing brown undies...
For Carey to be taking hoops at 135 km/h on a pitch with variable bounce consistently like shelling peas is beyond my comprehension.
Similarly, Ponting rocking on to back peg and pulling Shane Bond sending down wheels at 150 km/h at the WACA in 2001 at Akhter in 2000 is next level, too.
Elite sportspeople are wired differently or as NP Craig used to say, they're different species...
by Trader » Tue Dec 09, 2025 9:05 am
by woodublieve12 » Tue Dec 09, 2025 9:29 am
wenchbarwer wrote:am Bays wrote:I'm still in awe of Carey's performance.
I'm sure there's several in here who've been in the nets and had the bowling machine cranked up to 80 MPH (~130 km/h) and even 90 MPH (~145 km/h).
60-70 I could sort of handle, but 80 and 90 MPH was getting out of my depth. Thank god I was wearing brown undies...
For Carey to be taking hoops at 135 km/h on a pitch with variable bounce consistently like shelling peas is beyond my comprehension.
Similarly, Ponting rocking on to back peg and pulling Shane Bond sending down wheels at 150 km/h at the WACA in 2001 at Akhter in 2000 is next level, too.
Elite sportspeople are wired differently or as NP Craig used to say, they're different species...
Whilst I also appreciate his efforts, especially that diving catch with frigging Marnus in the way, this kind of stuff has been going on in baseball for years, at much higher speeds and distances!

by wenchbarwer » Tue Dec 09, 2025 9:36 am
woodublieve12 wrote:
Whilst I also appreciate his efforts, especially that diving catch with frigging Marnus in the way, this kind of stuff has been going on in baseball for years, at much higher speeds and distances!
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Dec 09, 2025 9:41 am

by wenchbarwer » Tue Dec 09, 2025 9:45 am
Lightning McQueen wrote:
by Aerie » Tue Dec 09, 2025 10:15 am
rd wrote:Whilst I am loving the current Ashes scoreline of Australia leading 2-0 after 2 Tests, I am missing the traditional fighting spirit of the English team.
I grew up in the 1970s – English batsmen were of the calibre of Boycott, Edrich, Cowdrey etc and our bowlers had to really earn those wickets and not get them handed to Australia by playing wild shots outside off stump after having batted for a dozen deliveries.
Similarly, our batsmen had to score runs of English bowlers like Snow, Willis, Underwood and it was hard enough to stay in let alone score freely. A bouncer from John Snow was designed to shake the Aussie batsmen up and not just being a hum drum method of not being scored off that ball.
The English preparation for the First Test was abysmal. A camp and a bit of a hit up against another group of English cricketers.
Bit like an AFL side preparing for the AFL season by playing trial matches against SANFL, VFL or WAFL teams only.
Like their ancestors, this English team should have arrived in Australia in late October and played South Australia, Victoria, NSW and WA prior to the First Test.
All their touring players would have played 2-3 matches each against strong opposition and be match hardened. Same goes for the Australian players who would have played a similar number of first class matches as well.
There would be no excuses for failure,
After that test, they would then play QLD prior to the Second Test.
They then play TAS prior to the Third Test and then play Boxing Day and New Year Tests as per normal scheduling.
Couple of obvious problems with this plan.
The State teams would like to rest their better players from these games – but wouldn’t do it if these games formed part of the Sheffield Shield season and so the State teams would earn points like any other Shield match.
After the SCG Test is completed, I would then have England play as the 9th team in the Big Bash throughout January – there’s 8 sold out English BBL games there in a heartbeat.
Cricket authorities love money and the Barmy Army would pack out the English Shield games and BBL games in addition to the Tests.
So, this plan requires the English and Australian players to be fully devoted to first class cricket and their country from late October to early February – surely extra financial inducement would be available to them by their respective boards.
by Jimmy_041 » Tue Dec 09, 2025 11:10 am
wenchbarwer wrote:woodublieve12 wrote:
Whilst I also appreciate his efforts, especially that diving catch with frigging Marnus in the way, this kind of stuff has been going on in baseball for years, at much higher speeds and distances!
Carey travelled much further than a catcher would. Alos outfielder and infielders don't start from a crouch position and start stationary.
Other Sports
Cricket
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |

