2025 Adelaide Footy League - Division 3

[Littlelegs]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

[Lightning McQueen]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

Apparently a couple of broken ribs and unable to play finals was the result, there was no intention to tap the ball whatsoever.

[wenchbarwer]

Bloody hell, he's game taking that Kilburn ruck on...

[Littlelegs]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

Apparently a couple of broken ribs and unable to play finals was the result, there was no intention to tap the ball whatsoever.

Fair enough, he definitely intended to do it, had he of made contact with the ball would there still be an argument.
if he has been suspended that many times how is he still playing.

[Lightning McQueen]

Bloody hell, he's game taking that Kilburn ruck on...

Yeah, he's a fair unit.

[Lightning McQueen]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

Apparently a couple of broken ribs and unable to play finals was the result, there was no intention to tap the ball whatsoever.

Fair enough, he definitely intended to do it, had he of made contact with the ball would there still be an argument.
if he has been suspended that many times how is he still playing.

Probably a fair portion of them in juniors. He's a pretty athletic young lad.

[wenchbarwer]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

Apparently a couple of broken ribs and unable to play finals was the result, there was no intention to tap the ball whatsoever.

Fair enough, he definitely intended to do it, had he of made contact with the ball would there still be an argument.
if he has been suspended that many times how is he still playing.

Probably a fair portion of them in juniors. He's a pretty athletic young lad.

The name rings a bell, not sure if it's because of his reputation or not

[Hack]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

Apparently a couple of broken ribs and unable to play finals was the result, there was no intention to tap the ball whatsoever.

Fair enough, he definitely intended to do it, had he of made contact with the ball would there still be an argument.
if he has been suspended that many times how is he still playing.

I’m very torn on this one.

Regularly bigger body rucks ‘protect the space’ AKA block out other lighter rucks from running and jumping at the ball. This is what happens as a result, they jump into the ruck blocking.

I also see the argument that this was intentional and not really an attempt to tap the ball.

I’ve heard people say for years they need to change the rules so bigger rucks can’t just block out lighter rucks from getting to the ball but as far as I am aware that hasn’t happened.

[marbles]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

Apparently a couple of broken ribs and unable to play finals was the result, there was no intention to tap the ball whatsoever.

Fair enough, he definitely intended to do it, had he of made contact with the ball would there still be an argument.
if he has been suspended that many times how is he still playing.

I’m very torn on this one.

Regularly bigger body rucks ‘protect the space’ AKA block out other lighter rucks from running and jumping at the ball. This is what happens as a result, they jump into the ruck blocking.

I also see the argument that this was intentional and not really an attempt to tap the ball.

I’ve heard people say for years they need to change the rules so bigger rucks can’t just block out lighter rucks from getting to the ball but as far as I am aware that hasn’t happened.

probably can see them playing paper scissors rock soon instead of the rucking contest (safer, fairer)

[Bluedemon]

Payneham Oval
Grand Final
M3 - Westminster OS v Unley Mercedes Jets - 2:30pm
M3R - PHOS Camden v Pembroke OS - 12:15pm
C3 - PHOS Camden v Pembroke OS - 10:00am

[jo172]

Great GF to watch as a neutral.

Unley all guts but Westminster a bit too much class for when it mattered

[AdelaideSaint73]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

That's no suspension in any other league as far as I'm aware.

There were two free kicks not paid for impeding the ruck, one prior to the previous ball up, where the PHOS ruck jumps straight over the Kilburn ruck and wins it easily. He's then grabbed prior to the contest in question and another PHOS player has to throw the impeding Kilburn player out the way. Kilburn ruck steps way under the ball (it lands about 3 metres away on the opposite side of the contest). It should be a free to the PHOS ruck as the rule is you can cross the path of the contest as long as you get back to the ball.

To suspend a lad for 4 games for that is out of control. As was the suspension earlier in the year when he probably should have got 1-2 for stupidity, rather than 4 for kneeing (essentially rested his knee on a guy's helmet) harder contact happens 100 times a game.

[Old Red]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

That's no suspension in any other league as far as I'm aware.

There were two free kicks not paid for impeding the ruck, one prior to the previous ball up, where the PHOS ruck jumps straight over the Kilburn ruck and wins it easily. He's then grabbed prior to the contest in question and another PHOS player has to throw the impeding Kilburn player out the way. Kilburn ruck steps way under the ball (it lands about 3 metres away on the opposite side of the contest). It should be a free to the PHOS ruck as the rule is you can cross the path of the contest as long as you get back to the ball.

To suspend a lad for 4 games for that is out of control. As was the suspension earlier in the year when he probably should have got 1-2 for stupidity, rather than 4 for kneeing (essentially rested his knee on a guy's helmet) harder contact happens 100 times a game.

What match and time for 1st one ?

[AdelaideSaint73]

so i am pretty old and out of touch but is that now suspension? a ruckman jumping with knee into a bigger bodied ruckman protecting the space?

That's no suspension in any other league as far as I'm aware.

There were two free kicks not paid for impeding the ruck, one prior to the previous ball up, where the PHOS ruck jumps straight over the Kilburn ruck and wins it easily. He's then grabbed prior to the contest in question and another PHOS player has to throw the impeding Kilburn player out the way. Kilburn ruck steps way under the ball (it lands about 3 metres away on the opposite side of the contest). It should be a free to the PHOS ruck as the rule is you can cross the path of the contest as long as you get back to the ball.

To suspend a lad for 4 games for that is out of control. As was the suspension earlier in the year when he probably should have got 1-2 for stupidity, rather than 4 for kneeing (essentially rested his knee on a guy's helmet) harder contact happens 100 times a game.

What match and time for 1st one ?

Scotch Rd 13. 5.40 into the last. Took ages to find it.