by Jim05 » Tue Dec 31, 2024 11:57 am
by am Bays » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:02 pm
by Jimmy_041 » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:04 pm
whufc wrote:We often criticise the selectors but in the aftermath of this test they got it pretty right.
Konstas- Everyone will remember his first innings forever; will he make it as a test cricketer....who knows but for one innings he was the only batsmen that was able to get on top of the possibly the worlds greatest ever bowler. His innings was the platform that set up the score of 450 plus.
Marsh- Primary role was as a batter and he failed that.... but a couple of extremely good and very important catches meant he had a minor impact. Bowled 10 overs for the test at 3 an over, probably is the limit of what would be expected with the ball from the batting allrounder Webster. Marsh needs to go undoubtedly but like Head whilst he failed in one role he was able to get involved in others.
by mal » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:13 pm
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:14 pm
am Bays wrote:Brendan Doggett was included in the Test Squad as cover Hazelwood for the Adelaide test (30 yo 41 FC games 140 odd wickets at 28) so he appears to be in the frame.
I think Starc and hazelwood will play in next years ASHES but not all the tests. Starc at 35 next provided he still has his pace will be looking at one last series.
I think Jim has a good team but we are looking potentially at 4 SA boys in the team can we afford that??
My team for the first test based on current form
- Konstas
- Hunt/Kellaway
- Labaschagne (3 x 50s in his last three tests means he's still getting picked)
- Smith
- Head
- Green
- Carey
- Cummins
- Starc
- 1 of Hazelwood, Richardson Doggett Boland
- Lyon
My only rider is that the likes of Labaschagne, Boland, Hazelwood, Lyon and to a lesser extent Starc dont have time on their side
Then the likes of Murphy, Rocachelli, McSweeny, Patterson, Richardson Doggett and O'Neil could easily be in too.
All will be revealed in Sri Lanka and the Caribbean.
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:15 pm
mal wrote:CC
The threats to OZ are obviously IN and EG
We gotta harness a team that can compete well in India
The type is a middle order batsman with flair
For that player to provide a finger spinning option
That player for me is Cooper Connolly
He is young, confident , and oozes natural ability
If he develops his finger spin , I think he is a real good long term player for OZ
Take him to SL should be a priority- to gain exposure on spinning decks
CC is a star
Remember this post
by The Dark Knight » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:21 pm
Lightning McQueen wrote:Konstas got found out, he has some great hand-eye co-ordination but he got lucky that hew was able to skip away to 30 odd without anyone realizing, you hit the nail on the head with one of your comments about how will he go in the 2nd dig, they clogged his hitting zones up and there wasn't a plan B.
by The Dark Knight » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:25 pm
https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/australia-to-play-three-tests-during-2025-tour-of-west-indies-1463882Lightning McQueen wrote:am Bays wrote:Brendan Doggett was included in the Test Squad as cover Hazelwood for the Adelaide test (30 yo 41 FC games 140 odd wickets at 28) so he appears to be in the frame.
I think Starc and hazelwood will play in next years ASHES but not all the tests. Starc at 35 next provided he still has his pace will be looking at one last series.
I think Jim has a good team but we are looking potentially at 4 SA boys in the team can we afford that??
My team for the first test based on current form
- Konstas
- Hunt/Kellaway
- Labaschagne (3 x 50s in his last three tests means he's still getting picked)
- Smith
- Head
- Green
- Carey
- Cummins
- Starc
- 1 of Hazelwood, Richardson Doggett Boland
- Lyon
My only rider is that the likes of Labaschagne, Boland, Hazelwood, Lyon and to a lesser extent Starc dont have time on their side
Then the likes of Murphy, Rocachelli, McSweeny, Patterson, Richardson Doggett and O'Neil could easily be in too.
All will be revealed in Sri Lanka and the Caribbean.
When was the Caribbean tour announced? Massive news for our development
by The Dark Knight » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:29 pm
am Bays wrote:Brendan Doggett was included in the Test Squad as cover Hazelwood for the Adelaide test (30 yo 41 FC games 140 odd wickets at 28) so he appears to be in the frame.
I think Starc and hazelwood will play in next years ASHES but not all the tests. Starc at 35 next provided he still has his pace will be looking at one last series.
I think Jim has a good team but we are looking potentially at 4 SA boys in the team can we afford that??
My team for the first test based on current form
- Konstas
- Hunt/Kellaway
- Labaschagne (3 x 50s in his last three tests means he's still getting picked)
- Smith
- Head
- Green
- Carey
- Cummins
- Starc
- 1 of Hazelwood, Richardson Doggett Boland
- Lyon
My only rider is that the likes of Labaschagne, Boland, Hazelwood, Lyon and to a lesser extent Starc dont have time on their side
Then the likes of Murphy, Rocachelli, McSweeny, Patterson, Richardson Doggett and O'Neil could easily be in too.
All will be revealed in Sri Lanka and the Caribbean.
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:42 pm
The Dark Knight wrote:Lightning McQueen wrote:Konstas got found out, he has some great hand-eye co-ordination but he got lucky that hew was able to skip away to 30 odd without anyone realizing, you hit the nail on the head with one of your comments about how will he go in the 2nd dig, they clogged his hitting zones up and there wasn't a plan B.
He got found out? Didn't he just get a very good delivery from a great bowler? There's no shame in that right? I think you're looking into his second innings dismissal a bit too much.
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:44 pm
The Dark Knight wrote:am Bays wrote:Brendan Doggett was included in the Test Squad as cover Hazelwood for the Adelaide test (30 yo 41 FC games 140 odd wickets at 28) so he appears to be in the frame.
I think Starc and hazelwood will play in next years ASHES but not all the tests. Starc at 35 next provided he still has his pace will be looking at one last series.
I think Jim has a good team but we are looking potentially at 4 SA boys in the team can we afford that??
My team for the first test based on current form
- Konstas
- Hunt/Kellaway
- Labaschagne (3 x 50s in his last three tests means he's still getting picked)
- Smith
- Head
- Green
- Carey
- Cummins
- Starc
- 1 of Hazelwood, Richardson Doggett Boland
- Lyon
My only rider is that the likes of Labaschagne, Boland, Hazelwood, Lyon and to a lesser extent Starc dont have time on their side
Then the likes of Murphy, Rocachelli, McSweeny, Patterson, Richardson Doggett and O'Neil could easily be in too.
All will be revealed in Sri Lanka and the Caribbean.
Labuschagne doesn't have time on his side? He's younger than Smith, Carey, Cummins and Starc.
by whufc » Tue Dec 31, 2024 12:55 pm
Lightning McQueen wrote:The Dark Knight wrote:Lightning McQueen wrote:Konstas got found out, he has some great hand-eye co-ordination but he got lucky that hew was able to skip away to 30 odd without anyone realizing, you hit the nail on the head with one of your comments about how will he go in the 2nd dig, they clogged his hitting zones up and there wasn't a plan B.
He got found out? Didn't he just get a very good delivery from a great bowler? There's no shame in that right? I think you're looking into his second innings dismissal a bit too much.
I quite possible am, time will tell. The lad likes to bat with flair and risk, he wasn't afforded that luxury in the 2nd dig as the fielders were in his zones.
Hopefully he has a patient side to him as I would love to see him be the next best thing.
I had my all my kids and their partners with me as we met at my house for brunch before going to a family function on Boxing Day, we weren't leaving while he was batting, I was in total awe of what he was producing, it was all everyone was talking about at the family show, even the ones that don't follow the cricket that much.
by am Bays » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:18 pm
Lightning McQueen wrote:The Dark Knight wrote:Labuschagne doesn't have time on his side? He's younger than Smith, Carey, Cummins and Starc.
People forget that he is only 30, I know I expected him to be older, he has definitely got a B for this series after a poor start, like him or not we need him moving forward for the next 3-4 years.
by Brodlach » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:19 pm
Brodlach wrote:Rory Laird might end up the best IMO, he is an absolute jet. He has been in great form at the Bloods
by am Bays » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:22 pm
Brodlach wrote:I’m doubting Starc plays Friday, who plays in his spot?
by Jim05 » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:23 pm
Abbott will probably get the gig.Brodlach wrote:I’m doubting Starc plays Friday, who plays in his spot?
by Jim05 » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:27 pm
Lightning McQueen wrote:
When was the Caribbean tour announced? Massive news for our development
by Armchair expert » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:29 pm
Jim05 wrote:Abbott will probably get the gig.Brodlach wrote:I’m doubting Starc plays Friday, who plays in his spot?
Maybe Richardson
Lightning McQueen wrote:You're a legend
by mal » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:29 pm
Lightning McQueen wrote:mal wrote:CC
The threats to OZ are obviously IN and EG
We gotta harness a team that can compete well in India
The type is a middle order batsman with flair
For that player to provide a finger spinning option
That player for me is Cooper Connolly
He is young, confident , and oozes natural ability
If he develops his finger spin , I think he is a real good long term player for OZ
Take him to SL should be a priority- to gain exposure on spinning decks
CC is a star
Remember this post
I thought you were referring to Colin Croft.
by whufc » Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:30 pm
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |