SAAFL division 6 2014

[Phantom Gossiper]

Phil Hall back to Central United.

[Footy Chick]

Congratulations to@Arch44 and @Scorpion on the birth of their bouncing baby boy early this morning

[zedman]

Congratulations to@Arch44 and @Scorpion on the birth of their bouncing baby boy early this morning

congrats arch44

[carey]

Congratulations to@Arch44 and @Scorpion on the birth of their bouncing baby boy early this morning

Congrats Arch well done.

[Footy Chick]

you're next! if Mel doesn't kill someone first...lol

[carey]

you're next! if Mel doesn't kill someone first...lol

Tell me about like chicks don't whinge enough she's been in hospital for 3 weeks now and don't I hear about it!

I started my holidays today so I want my Golf buggy delivered now!

[Mr Beefy]

Matt Lyons did a knee about 6 weeks ago and Ben copped a kick to his lower leg and broken in 2 spots on Sat.

Sorry to hear that.

AV bloke got 6 weeks for the reckless trip that broke his ankle

[Yank Man]

Matt Lyons did a knee about 6 weeks ago and Ben copped a kick to his lower leg and broken in 2 spots on Sat.

Sorry to hear that.

AV bloke got 6 weeks for the reckless trip that broke his ankle

Even more sadder to hear that. AV must be the bogey team of 2014, that's 3 players now with season ending injuries against them.

[Arch44]

Congratulations to@Arch44 and @Scorpion on the birth of their bouncing baby boy early this morning

Thanks guys both old girl and baby are doing well.

[Robb_Stark]

Jonathon Young Angle Vale D6 Tripping Reckless Body Guilty 6 weeks

whats going on down at head quarters we see people do far worse then this and get less

[Phantom Gossiper]

Jonathon Young Angle Vale D6 Tripping Reckless Body Guilty 6 weeks

whats going on down at head quarters we see people do far worse then this and get less

AV bloke got 6 weeks for the reckless trip that broke his ankle

I would say the punishment fits the stupidity.

[zedman]

Jonathon Young Angle Vale D6 Tripping Reckless Body Guilty 6 weeks

whats going on down at head quarters we see people do far worse then this and get less

AV bloke got 6 weeks for the reckless trip that broke his ankle

I would say the punishment fits the stupidity.

agreed..do some research for once robb instead of flying off with accusations..

[bickle]

whats going on down at head quarters we see people do far worse then this and get less[/quote]


yeah what i saw was the rosey player changed his line and the AV player tried to change with him but on the push off, his leg raised and collected ankles i think, pure accident.
ump gave him a yellow, as he should have, but then said to the AV player he has to give him another yellow when he found out he broke his leg.

on another note i see Phil Hall is coming back to the Units.
good lad Phil

[Phantom Gossiper]

yeah what i saw was the rosey player changed his line and the AV player tried to change with him but on the push off, his leg raised and collected ankles i think, pure accident.
ump gave him a yellow, as he should have, but then said to the AV player he has to give him another yellow when he found out he broke his leg.

Surely the umpire wouldn't give a yellow for an accident unless he genuinely believed the act to be either reckless or deliberate or with malice.

Sorry but changing direction and his leg came up and collected his ankle resulted in a broken ankle/leg in 2 spots to the player is difficult to believe.

Having said that I wasn't there, I didn't see the incident - i'm only commenting on how it sounds from an outsider point of view.

[Robb_Stark]

Jonathon Young Angle Vale D6 Tripping Reckless Body Guilty 6 weeks

whats going on down at head quarters we see people do far worse then this and get less

AV bloke got 6 weeks for the reckless trip that broke his ankle

I would say the punishment fits the stupidity.

agreed..do some research for once robb instead of flying off with accusations..

i did do my research and the way its graded is a load of rubbish Severe or high even for a broken ankle come on

kicking and headbutting get the same outcome yet have worse impact

[zedman]

Jonathon Young Angle Vale D6 Tripping Reckless Body Guilty 6 weeks

whats going on down at head quarters we see people do far worse then this and get less

AV bloke got 6 weeks for the reckless trip that broke his ankle

I would say the punishment fits the stupidity.

agreed..do some research for once robb instead of flying off with accusations..

i did do my research and the way its graded is a load of rubbish Severe or high even for a broken ankle come on

kicking and headbutting get the same outcome yet have worse impact

a trip is pretty much a kick..your saying a headbutt is worse than breaking someones leg in 2 places?? not even close..

[Robb_Stark]

i would of rated it at 3-4 games

[Phantom Gossiper]

i would of rated it at 3-4 games

Come on you've got to take into account the damage it did! The Rosewater lad may not play again this season because someones stupid act and you are staying he was harshly dealt with?

[Footy Chick]

i would of rated it at 3-4 games

I know people, I can ask if they'd have you on the tribunal panel as clearly you know everything

[Robb_Stark]

i would of rated it at 3-4 games

I know people, I can ask if they'd have you on the tribunal panel as clearly you know everything

lol its my opinion just like the tribunal has there opinion i would do a good job on the tribunal seen first hand how it operates maybe they need some young blood down at HQ