Round 5 Discussion

[LMA]

Do I give Shaw the flick today and go Birchall or do I stick with him as a permanent and hope he finds some form and save a trade ?

I've had Birchall since the outset, and thank christ I did.
I would take him over Shaw if it was me.

Yeah keen to get him as he looks to rise over 600k in the future but I have to use 2 trades and with the sides not being announced til tonight I don't want to trade someone in who might not be playing eg Terlich, Mayes, Kerridge, Docherty etc

[the wonder elephant]

Viney and Jenkins out cloke and papporone in ... colke very low breakeven and a must have atm

[Squids]

Gave Cloke the big VC

[the wonder elephant]

Gave Cloke the big VC

needs a big second half

[RustyCage]

Gave Cloke the big VC

needs a big second half

Cloke on 47 at 3/4 time

[Squids]

Gave Cloke the big VC

needs a big second half

Cloke on 47 at 3/4 time

Hopefully Gary Ablett can produce more than that then.

[Q.]

Will take Pendlebury's 135 as VC, just need someone to not get a gig this week.

[RustyCage]

Cloke ended up on 63

[RustyCage]

SC scores:

Essendon:
11 David Zaharakis 140
4 Jobe Watson 126
8 Jason Winderlich 123
5 Brent Stanton 119
1 Michael Hibberd 115
2 Tom Bellchambers 109
21 Dyson Heppell 103
9 Brendon Goddard 94
15 Courtenay Dempsey 93
20 Jackson Merrett 69
3 Scott Gumbleton 65
26 Cale Hooker 64
12 Stewart Crameri 61
29 Alwyn Davey 60
40 Ben Howlett 51
19 David Hille 51
22 Jake Carlisle 51
46 Mark Baguley 51
39 Heath Hocking 47
34 Kyle Hardingham 38
23 David Myers 36 (SUBBED ON)
32 Travis Colyer 33 (SUBBED OFF)

Collingwood:
10 Scott Pendlebury 136
22 Steele Sidebottom 136
39 Heath Shaw 130
36 Dane Swan 127
20 Ben Reid 125
21 Quinten Lynch 86
25 Ben Hudson 79
11 Jarryd Blair 77
2 Jordan Russell 64
32 Travis Cloke 63
19 Jamie Elliott 61
9 Martin Clarke 60
3 Brent Macaffer 59
13 Dale Thomas 58
16 Nathan Brown 58
40 Paul Seedsman 56
6 Tyson Goldsack 53 (SUBBED ON)
34 Alan Toovey 51
8 Harry O'Brien 41
41 Sam Dwyer 38
1 Alex Fasolo 28
28 Ben Sinclair 18 (SUBBED OFF)

[the wonder elephant]

the alpaca has 80 dream team points 9 mins in second quarter

[Jim05]

the alpaca has 80 dream team points 9 mins in second quarter

Very happy with that.
Swapped my skipper from Jobe to Stants and was shitting myself at halftime with Stants on 32, big 2nd half though.
All my Bomber boys got atleast 100.
Might get a decent score for once

[Johno6]

I will get a donut thanks to viney. Already made my 2 trades this round

Spewin.

[Moe]

My opponent in Hogg iv already using the captain loophole after 2 bloody games. Weak.
Hope Little Gaz goes beserk today.

[LMA]

Did I miss something during the week about Rockliff ? Is named last on an extended bench

[Q.]

Did I miss something during the week about Rockliff ? Is named last on an extended bench

Would be surprised if he got dropped.

[Alaska]

No Crouch, Viney, Stevenson and Suban and Neade looks to be the SUB maybe even Stevens, Lucas and O’Meara as well with MaCaffer and Dwyer locked in problems for some and Karnezis may be back to rip some $ out of you if you still have him.

[CoverKing]

Did I miss something during the week about Rockliff ? Is named last on an extended bench

No way in hell will he be dropped or the sub. will play 100%

[Trader]

Karnezis may be back to rip some $ out of you if you still have him.

Was going to dump him for Mayes. Hmmm what to do!

A) Mayes in for Karnezis
B) Mayes in for Viney
C) Let Mayes go??

[Q.]

Karnezis may be back to rip some $ out of you if you still have him.

Was going to dump him for Mayes. Hmmm what to do!

A) Mayes in for Karnezis
B) Mayes in for Viney
C) Let Mayes go??

Depends on how badly you need a F/M link

[Moe]

Did I miss something during the week about Rockliff ? Is named last on an extended bench

No way in hell will he be dropped or the sub. will play 100%

Especially with Rich & Hanley injured.