Punk Rooster wrote:MagicKiwi wrote:Having lived in Adelaide for 34 years, can someone tell me when this sort of thing started? Was I asleep? Since when do Adelaide kids go out at night knocking on doors for some American celebrated thing?
probably no different to why millions of non-christians celebrate Christmas/Easter, non-horse lovers celebrate Melbourne Cup Day etc...
Mass cultural importation or repeated initial external exposure (in the case of "Trick or Treating", decades of American television, and now the internet), then a self perpetuating cycle of promotion, social acceptance (blind or otherwise), social expectation, profits and further exposure, not necessarily in that order.
Dressing up and going door to door didn't originate in North America, but seems to have resurfaced there several years after initial Celtic emigration to the region, as described in the Wikipedia
Trick Or Treating article. In part:-
"At the time of substantial Irish and Scottish immigration to North America in the late 19th century, Halloween had a strong tradition of "guising" - children in Ireland and Scotland disguised in costumes going from door to door requesting food or coins.
The earliest known reference to ritual begging on Halloween in English speaking North America occurs in 1911, when a newspaper in Kingston, Ontario reported that it was normal for the smaller children to go street "guising" on Halloween between 6 and 7 p.m., visiting shops and neighbors to be rewarded with nuts and candies for their rhymes and songs.. Another isolated reference to ritual begging on Halloween appears, place unknown, in 1915, with a third reference in Chicago in 1920.
The earliest known use in print of the term "trick or treat" appears in 1927, from Blackie, Alberta, Canada""Trick or Treat" is by no means encouraged in the StrayDog realm.
This year, a freshly printed and laminated sign fixed firmly to the front aluminium fly wire door, to the effect of:-
"Greetings All.
Sorry, we don't
believe in "Trick or Treating".
Please respect our wishes by
not knocking on our door.
Thankyou."I'd say we had five or six groups come by, most did so well after sunset. As our window is near the front door, we could hear that the young ones had no real problems understanding it (we made sure it was well illuminated), as well as a couple of groups being actively encouraged to do so by the accompanying adults before knocking, for which we were grateful. The majority of groups seemingly went about their activity with dignity.
There was, however, one raucous group. A few of their number came to our door and banged quite loudly, despite our wishes. As they didn't bolt off in a hurry I gave them the benefit of the (fleeting) doubt, assumed that they were just over zealous, and weren't simply being an obnoxious pain in the ar5e.
I came out only after they'd moved on, there were probably 15 of them ranging in ages of 10 to 15. Seemingly few of them had made any effort to dress up for the occasion. In hindsight, "mosquito" costumes for the lot of them would have been most appropriate.
Thankfully, (mildly pi55ed off as we were by this time) they didn't manage to wake up our little daughter or this group - in particular the adult with them - might have been rapidly visited by a couple an angry spirits that no amount of Hallowe'en dress-up will have appeased, and from which no amount of praying would have afforded salvation.
A couple of them seemed a bit disappointed that a nearby neighbour's letterbox didn't yield any lollies after they shook it a few times. The middle aged "responsible" male that looked on from the street looked as though he'd rather have been back at the pub.
If we were passively - in our own domain - not in favour of "Trick or Treat" before, this one group did little to change our minds, despite the efforts of the majority of smaller individual groups that came by.
A Mum wrote:
(I know it's an American tradition etc, etc - but
I do love seeing the little kids faces when you give them something)
Yeah, us too, but still plenty of Christmases and big childrens' parties to look forward to that will do our family nicely in our little patch of suburban heaven.
To each their own.
