SA Footy

Hindmarsh is to small for AU vs Victory games...

The Dark Knight wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:

Jim05 wrote:Further evidence of why games shouldnt be played at sub standard grounds. Would rather a decent game infront of 1000 people than see that crap dished up. Totally unsuitable for soccer, hopefully thats the last time they play there.
Result was fair in the end

Sub standard ground?!

For soccer yes.
One of the best surfaces in the world for cricket and probably the best in the country for AFL but it aint a soccer ground. Time to give up on the experiment. Next week at Etihad will see a similar scenerio for the Melbourne Derby, far better to play it at AAMI park. As a fan the experience isnt great either, crowd is far too far away from the pitch which negates the crowd factor.
Tonights game would of packed Hindmarsh and the atmosphere would of been electric and the standard of the game far better

Agree especially about the crowd, you're too far away when watching a game at Adelaide Oval that is why I much prefer Hindmash, atmosphere is definitely better there IMO because the crowd is closer to the action.

We sat in the mark rucciuto Stand second row from the front and the view was awesome. Looked over the entire game and had the best view for Cirios goal. Followed the ball straight in. def happy with the $40 i spent.

woodublieve12 wrote:Hindmarsh is to small for AU vs Victory games...

Agree but it is a fine balance because playing at AU is causing the product to be shit. Which can have a negative effect, it's also not a great viewing ground which causes alot of members to get pretty pissed because they have such quality seats at hindmarsh

There is also nothing wrong with a sellout at hindmarsh, it increases value to your product and gives people a call to action for further games.

Can't see an issue with them doing it once or twice a year, maybe for finals too. Soccer in Australia has struggled to make a buck for years, seems like they finally have it right with the introduction of the FFA cup and the two melb and Sydney teams etc, time to cash in while the have it right.

bennymacca wrote:Can't see an issue with them doing it once or twice a year, maybe for finals too. Soccer in Australia has struggled to make a buck for years, seems like they finally have it right with the introduction of the FFA cup and the two melb and Sydney teams etc, time to cash in while the have it right.

Cant be at the expense of the game though.
Its one thing to get a decent crowd but cant have the game compromised. Was a really poor advertisement for the game last night, take the last 10 minutes out of it and it was close to the worst game ive ever attended anywhere around the world
Wont happen but would love an extra 5-10,000 seats at Hindmarsh and it would be the perfect venue.

Similar situation to the AFL in Sydney, the SCG is too small yet far better than the bigger yet crappier Telstra Stadium

bennymacca wrote:Can't see an issue with them doing it once or twice a year, maybe for finals too. Soccer in Australia has struggled to make a buck for years, seems like they finally have it right with the introduction of the FFA cup and the two melb and Sydney teams etc, time to cash in while the have it right.

Agree the A-League are finally making big moves in this country!!!!

As a once off its fine but having what should have been the most entertaining game of the year turning into a bore fest because of the pitch is an issue!!

Jim05 wrote:

bennymacca wrote:Can't see an issue with them doing it once or twice a year, maybe for finals too. Soccer in Australia has struggled to make a buck for years, seems like they finally have it right with the introduction of the FFA cup and the two melb and Sydney teams etc, time to cash in while the have it right.

Cant be at the expense of the game though.
Its one thing to get a decent crowd but cant have the game compromised. Was a really poor advertisement for the game last night, take the last 10 minutes out of it and it was close to the worst game ive ever attended anywhere around the world
Wont happen but would love an extra 5-10,000 seats at Hindmarsh and it would be the perfect venue.

Similar situation to the AFL in Sydney, the SCG is too small yet far better than the bigger yet crappier Telstra Stadium

There was talk about expanding Hindmarsh and putting a roof on it made of the same fabric as the Cube in Beijing that they used for the swimming.

If you google Coopers Stadium and look at the Adelaidenow article from Feb it explains it.

whufc wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Hindmarsh is to small for AU vs Victory games...

Agree but it is a fine balance because playing at AU is causing the product to be shit. Which can have a negative effect, it's also not a great viewing ground which causes alot of members to get pretty pissed because they have such quality seats at hindmarsh

There is also nothing wrong with a sellout at hindmarsh, it increases value to your product and gives people a call to action for further games.

I'm not missing a half of the game waiting for a beer... Players are professionals they should adapt

its like that everywhere thou having to wait for food or drinks

woodublieve12 wrote:

whufc wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Hindmarsh is to small for AU vs Victory games...

Agree but it is a fine balance because playing at AU is causing the product to be shit. Which can have a negative effect, it's also not a great viewing ground which causes alot of members to get pretty pissed because they have such quality seats at hindmarsh

There is also nothing wrong with a sellout at hindmarsh, it increases value to your product and gives people a call to action for further games.

I'm not missing a half of the game waiting for a beer... Players are professionals they should adapt

Players can adapt if they play and train there every week. Victory didnt even get a training run there.
Why havnt the Swans adapted to Telstra stadium? Every AFL game played there is a disgraceful spectacle
Soccer should be played on soccer grounds only

Swans have lost 1 game there in the past 2 seasons...

Well Hindmarsh should have better facilities to accomodate those big crowds then.
32 thousand come see a game at a world class venue and people still complain...

woodublieve12 wrote:Swans have lost 1 game there in the past 2 seasons...

Well Hindmarsh should have better facilities to accomodate those big crowds then.
32 thousand come see a game at a world class venue and people still complain...

Complaining because the standard was terrible and that was attributed to the conditions. The casual followers of the game of course are going to prefer games played at AO but for soccer people such as myself and many others who attend every game we much prefer Hindmarsh. The players absolutely hate it and they are the ones who matter most. The same debate is going on over the border with the Melbourne derby being played on an inferior surface at Etihad instead of a world class purpose built soccer stadium

Jim05 wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Swans have lost 1 game there in the past 2 seasons...

Well Hindmarsh should have better facilities to accomodate those big crowds then.
32 thousand come see a game at a world class venue and people still complain...

Complaining because the standard was terrible and that was attributed to the conditions. The casual followers of the game of course are going to prefer games played at AO but for soccer people such as myself and many others who attend every game we much prefer Hindmarsh. The players absolutely hate it and they are the ones who matter most. The same debate is going on over the border with the Melbourne derby being played on an inferior surface at Etihad instead of a world class purpose built soccer stadium

Trust Wub to turn a soccer thread into a Swans thread.

**** you Brisbane you bunch of ******* ****! [GRINNING FACE WITH SMILING EYES][SMILING FACE WITH OPEN MOUTH]

I went to my first A league game ever. Seats were pretty good (I was in the Eastern stand), whilst it didn't have the same close up feel I hear Hindmarsh has, I couldn't complain.

I'm with WUB, surely if you're a professional, having a half hour warm up, you should just adjust to the conditions. It was equal for both teams, but both teams looked very timid to even try & score. Which resulted in some pretty substandard viewing for the casual observer & the usual fan.
The last ten minutes when both teams played with intent the conditions seemed irrelevant for both teams.

Good work by the Victory crowd, they certainly had the United contingent covered & were better to watch then the game for the first 84 minutes!

Also went on friday night.

Agree regarding comments made about the surface. Turned the game into a very dour spectacle, with players obviously unable to judge to movements of the ball.

If Hindmarsh were to be increased to 25k, surely that would suffice for the blockbuster matches? Build on the Eastern side of the ground and you have a great stadium. As the popularity of Australian football, and the A-League as a competition grows, surely there wont be any issues with crowd sizes.

valleys07 wrote:Also went on friday night.

Agree regarding comments made about the surface. Turned the game into a very dour spectacle, with players obviously unable to judge to movements of the ball.

If Hindmarsh were to be increased to 25k, surely that would suffice for the blockbuster matches? Build on the Eastern side of the ground and you have a great stadium. As the popularity of Australian football, and the A-League as a competition grows, surely there wont be any issues with crowd sizes.

Agree, would love to see in the next 5 years plans to extend hindmarsh to 25k

Soccer have hit alot of winners recently with free to air tv coverage, all games live on foxtel plus foxtel now showing a ridiculous amount of soccer.

They have also found the perfect timing for seasons imho

whufc wrote:

valleys07 wrote:Also went on friday night.

Agree regarding comments made about the surface. Turned the game into a very dour spectacle, with players obviously unable to judge to movements of the ball.

If Hindmarsh were to be increased to 25k, surely that would suffice for the blockbuster matches? Build on the Eastern side of the ground and you have a great stadium. As the popularity of Australian football, and the A-League as a competition grows, surely there wont be any issues with crowd sizes.

Agree, would love to see in the next 5 years plans to extend hindmarsh to 25k

Soccer have hit alot of winners recently with free to air tv coverage, all games live on foxtel plus foxtel now showing a ridiculous amount of soccer.

They have also found the perfect timing for seasons imho

Agree whufc. Football deserves a bit of publicity in this country on the back of another world cup campaign. It needs to grow if we are to qualify and compete in 2018.

Spot on about timing of seasons. I am an avid fan of Aussie Rules, but quite like watching United during the A-League season. They deserve to get the opportunity to have the states support along with the 36ers over summer.

valleys07 wrote:

whufc wrote:

valleys07 wrote:Also went on friday night.

Agree regarding comments made about the surface. Turned the game into a very dour spectacle, with players obviously unable to judge to movements of the ball.

If Hindmarsh were to be increased to 25k, surely that would suffice for the blockbuster matches? Build on the Eastern side of the ground and you have a great stadium. As the popularity of Australian football, and the A-League as a competition grows, surely there wont be any issues with crowd sizes.

Agree, would love to see in the next 5 years plans to extend hindmarsh to 25k

Soccer have hit alot of winners recently with free to air tv coverage, all games live on foxtel plus foxtel now showing a ridiculous amount of soccer.

They have also found the perfect timing for seasons imho

Agree whufc. Football deserves a bit of publicity in this country on the back of another world cup campaign. It needs to grow if we are to qualify and compete in 2018.

Spot on about timing of seasons. I am an avid fan of Aussie Rules, but quite like watching United during the A-League season. They deserve to get the opportunity to have the states support along with the 36ers over summer.

yep agree with this. still only a casual fan but much more likely to show an interest when im not following the afl

Not sure this deserves it's own thread so I'm putting it here....

Adelaide Now reporting that Adelaide United v Liverpool is almost a done deal for July next year at Adelaide Oval.