Round 16 Trades, Teams & Discussion

[Squids]

Finally some good news!

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/more-ne ... 6424394811

MELBOURNE rookie midfielder TOM COUCH is set to make his AFL debut on Saturday against Fremantle.

Thank Christ for that, finally dont have to hear Squids continually whinge

So what are the odds guys?
Green vest and under 10 points
Green vest 10-30 points
Green vest more than 30 points

That is an insult

will score 50+ and won't be submarine

[Lightning McQueen]

Finally some good news!

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/more-ne ... 6424394811

MELBOURNE rookie midfielder TOM COUCH is set to make his AFL debut on Saturday against Fremantle.

Thank Christ for that, finally dont have to hear Squids continually whinge

So what are the odds guys?
Green vest and under 10 points
Green vest 10-30 points
Green vest more than 30 points

46.

[Media Park]

No green vest and a soft tissue injury in the first five minutes.

[Alaska]

No green vest and a soft tissue injury in the first five minutes.

Yes looking at those soft tissues maybe in the warm up!

[Banker]

Patrick Ryder is OUT for a minimum of 4 weeks with a calf injury sustained at training yesterday.

[Banker]

My current list


Injured:

Pendlebury Test
Waters 5 weeks
Ryder 4 weeks
Franklin 3 weeks
Sexton season
Crozier season


Suspended:

Goddard 1 week
Martin 1 week


Dud:

Spurr

[Alaska]

My current list


Injured:

Pendlebury Test
Waters 5 weeks
Ryder 4 weeks
Franklin 3 weeks
Sexton season
Crozier season


Suspended:

Goddard 1 week
Martin 1 week


Dud:

Spurr

Ah but Lee Spurr had 21 disposals in the WAFL on the weekend

[CoverKing]

Bloody Ryder!!!! Had him for two weeks!

[cossi11]

Pendlebury and Murphy IN

[Squids]

What to do with Beau Waters.....

[Sorry Dude]

What to do with Beau Waters.....

4-5 weeks with his price and trades in hand i would be bringing in carrots or birchall if you don't already have them. even scotland or suckling? i was thinking yarran since he has lifted his game the last couple weeks.

[Johno6]

i dont think ill have any donuts this week barring any late withdrawals, but i will have another shit week.

[Coach Bombay]

Need advise. Scotland, birchall or Hanley? And chapman, beams, Johnson or okeefe?

[Lightning McQueen]

Need advise. Scotland, birchall or Hanley? And chapman, beams, Johnson or okeefe?

Can't go wrong with any of them, O'Keefe probably lacks consistency. My daughter brought in Hanley a few weeks back and he's been smashing it, Birchall is always good but misses a few games here and there and Scotland is a DPP. I put Chappy as captain last week with a good return.

[Sorry Dude]

Need advise. Scotland, birchall or Hanley? And chapman, beams, Johnson or okeefe?

I would go Scotland and Beams. Scotland is always going to find the ball, everyone knows that. Birchall and Hanley while putting up good scores their par scores are 80ish where Scotland is 90+ all the time.

Beams over the other 3 just because he has had 1 sub 100 game since coming back from injury and that was last week where Carrots towled him up. Johnson, Chapman and O'Keefe go a missing a bit to much for me.

[Lightning McQueen]

Need advise. Scotland, birchall or Hanley? And chapman, beams, Johnson or okeefe?

I would go Scotland and Beams. Scotland is always going to find the ball, everyone knows that. Birchall and Hanley while putting up good scores their par scores are 80ish where Scotland is 90+ all the time.

Beams over the other 3 just because he has had 1 sub 100 game since coming back from injury and that was last week where Carrots towled him up. Johnson, Chapman and O'Keefe go a missing a bit to much for me.

Fair analysis.

[Media Park]

No donuts at this stage, but some utter crap scores coming through both SC and DT with the likes of Patton, Geary, Saad, Hargrave, Walsh.

[Tiger83]

OUT - Waters
IN- Scotland

[cossi11]

choice between Scotland and Carrazzo hhhhmmmmmmm

[Sorry Dude]

choice between Scotland and Carrazzo hhhhmmmmmmm

Carrazzo. Plays a bit more up the ground, and with his "tagging" role finds a heap of the ball. North don't have a player you need to tag so he could be in for a big one tonight.