Player discussion 2010

[Groover]

you make a good point REB. i was tossing up between him and Hille... i went with NicNat because i thought Jille would start pretty slowly considering his time off with injury...

other options worth considering? Renouf? McEvoy?

No and no.

The sensible option is to play two rucks that will guarantee you 190-200 points each week.

The more I think about it, the more I like Ryder as a 2nd ruck.

Hmac and Hille with warnock on the bench is a good option

[nuggety goodness]

you make a good point REB. i was tossing up between him and Hille... i went with NicNat because i thought Jille would start pretty slowly considering his time off with injury...

other options worth considering? Renouf? McEvoy?

No and no.

The sensible option is to play two rucks that will guarantee you 190-200 points each week.

The more I think about it, the more I like Ryder as a 2nd ruck.

Hmac and Hille with warnock on the bench is a good option

i'll stick with Tippett and might go with Hille over Natanui... warnock is already on the pine...

[Browny25]

Webberley or Nason from Richmond?

Cook or Sloane from Crows?

[Q.]

Hille is a risk too, for obvious reasons, but you may find he won't see much time in the middle.

@ Browny, IMO Nason and Cooke.

[Hondo]

you make a good point REB. i was tossing up between him and Hille... i went with NicNat because i thought Jille would start pretty slowly considering his time off with injury...

other options worth considering? Renouf? McEvoy?

No and no.

The sensible option is to play two rucks that will guarantee you 190-200 points each week.

The more I think about it, the more I like Ryder as a 2nd ruck.

I agree with you about the 2 rucks. I reckon one of them this year should be Sandilands. He's on an upward scoring path in recent seasons and could average 110+

[brod]

Have probably changed these four more than any other players

Tonight have
- M Clark
- K Tippett
- J Trengove
- S Grimley

[the wonder elephant]

heres mysuper coach team for round 1 pending team selections rip it apart at will look forward to any feedback as i havnt seen much nab cup cheers twe
backs: goddard,goodwin,bock,enright,kennely,hunt,schonemakers,waters,maguire
mids: ablett,okeeffe,boak,mckay,walker,jack trengrove,duncan,moles
ruck: sandilands,tippett,warnock,jackson trengrove
forwards:goodes,n reiwoldt,hall,dangerfield,westoff,j watts,tappscott,gumbleton,hitchcock
still haave a 100k so maybe a small fiddle with the forwards

[brod]

heres mysuper coach team for round 1 pending team selections rip it apart at will look forward to any feedback as i havnt seen much nab cup cheers twe
backs: goddard,goodwin,bock,enright,kennely,hunt,schonemakers,waters,maguire
mids: ablett,okeeffe,boak,mckay,walker,jack trengrove,duncan,moles
ruck: sandilands,tippett,warnock,jackson trengrove
forwards:goodes,n reiwoldt,hall,dangerfield,westoff,j watts,tappscott,gumbleton,hitchcock
still haave a 100k so maybe a small fiddle with the forwards

Tapscott listed as out indefinately (possible mid-season return) from hip surgery

[the wonder elephant]

heres mysuper coach team for round 1 pending team selections rip it apart at will look forward to any feedback as i havnt seen much nab cup cheers twe
backs: goddard,goodwin,bock,enright,kennely,hunt,schonemakers,waters,maguire
mids: ablett,okeeffe,boak,mckay,walker,jack trengrove,duncan,moles
ruck: sandilands,tippett,warnock,jackson trengrove
forwards:goodes,n reiwoldt,hall,dangerfield,westoff,j watts,tappscott,gumbleton,hitchcock
still haave a 100k so maybe a small fiddle with the forwards

Tapscott listed as out indefinately (possible mid-season return) from hip surgery

cheers brod

[Q.]

Watts also injured. Wouldn't have him in there anyway.

[the wonder elephant]

Watts also injured. Wouldn't have him in there anyway.

cheers m8

[the wonder elephant]

heres mysuper coach team for round 1 pending team selections rip it apart at will look forward to any feedback as i havnt seen much nab cup cheers twe
backs: goddard,goodwin,bock,enright,kennely,hunt,schonemakers,waters,maguire
mids: ablett,okeeffe,boak,mckay,walker,jack trengrove,duncan,moles
ruck: sandilands,tippett,warnock,jackson trengrove
forwards:goodes,n reiwoldt,hall,dangerfield,westoff,j watts,tappscott,gumbleton,hitchcock
still haave a 100k so maybe a small fiddle with the forwards

watts and tappscott out tex walker and possidilly in

[White Line Fever]

from the seasoned punters, this is only my second year, how much money should I have left in the kitty coming into Round 1??

[Rik E Boy]

from the seasoned punters, this is only my second year, how much money should I have left in the kitty coming into Round 1??

Personally, I like to spend as much of my cap as possible. However, with players such as Chris Judd missing the three rounds you might want some coin left over to secure his services in Round 6 when he is on 'the bubble' (i.e. his value is about to change). You could upgrade say a Trengove for Judd if you have the coin and save a trade.

regards,

REB

[Alaska]

ok, i'm not too fussed if people know my side, you can see it after rd1 anyways. my DT is as follows...

Goddard, Enright, Harbrow
Pearce, Malceski, Ladson, Hunt
Ablett (c) Montagna (vc) O'Keefe
Higgins, Robinson, Martin
Tippett, Natanui
Goodes, Giansiracusa, Waite
Hall, Ballantyne, Dangerfield, Campbell

EMER: Waters (def), Barlow (mid) Rockliff (fwd)

Bench:
def- Farmer
mid- Jetta
ruck- Vickery, Warnock
fwd- Taylor

my only questions are Robinson and Waite, not too sure on how they will go. also Troy Taylor and his possible charges... if he gets charged then he won't play for a while, if he plays he looks very exciting...

thoughts?

and my SC is similar, i changed my mind on Gold Coast GAJ...

Goddard, Enright, Pearce
Stewart, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson
Ablett (c) Montagna (vc) Swan
Higgins, Trengove, Martin
Tippett, Natanui
Goodes, Reiwoldt, Giansiracusa,
Hall, Dangerfield, Westoff, Ballantyne

EMER: Waters (def), Barlow (mid) Rockliff (fwd)

Bench:
def- Maguire
mid- Jetta
ruck- Warnock, Grimley
fwd- Peterson

questions only on Paul Stewart and Maguire... otherwise relatively happy.

now you can pick my sides to pieces, go for broke lads!!!

I stand to be corrected but I read Pearce is still on the Rookie list and is yet to be elevated for 2010.

[Alaska]

heres mysuper coach team for round 1 pending team selections rip it apart at will look forward to any feedback as i havnt seen much nab cup cheers twe
backs: goddard,goodwin,bock,enright,kennely,hunt,schonemakers,waters,maguire
mids: ablett,okeeffe,boak,mckay,walker,jack trengrove,duncan,moles
ruck: sandilands,tippett,warnock,jackson trengrove
forwards:goodes,n reiwoldt,hall,dangerfield,westoff,j watts,tappscott,gumbleton,hitchcock
still haave a 100k so maybe a small fiddle with the forwards

watts and tappscott out tex walker and possidilly in

I think Watts is on the way back and played in VFL last weeekend, could be only one or two weeks away.

[nuggety goodness]

ok, i'm not too fussed if people know my side, you can see it after rd1 anyways. my DT is as follows...

Goddard, Enright, Harbrow
Pearce, Malceski, Ladson, Hunt
Ablett (c) Montagna (vc) O'Keefe
Higgins, Robinson, Martin
Tippett, Natanui
Goodes, Giansiracusa, Waite
Hall, Ballantyne, Dangerfield, Campbell

EMER: Waters (def), Barlow (mid) Rockliff (fwd)

Bench:
def- Farmer
mid- Jetta
ruck- Vickery, Warnock
fwd- Taylor

my only questions are Robinson and Waite, not too sure on how they will go. also Troy Taylor and his possible charges... if he gets charged then he won't play for a while, if he plays he looks very exciting...

thoughts?

and my SC is similar, i changed my mind on Gold Coast GAJ...

Goddard, Enright, Pearce
Stewart, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson
Ablett (c) Montagna (vc) Swan
Higgins, Trengove, Martin
Tippett, Natanui
Goodes, Reiwoldt, Giansiracusa,
Hall, Dangerfield, Westoff, Ballantyne

EMER: Waters (def), Barlow (mid) Rockliff (fwd)

Bench:
def- Maguire
mid- Jetta
ruck- Warnock, Grimley
fwd- Peterson

questions only on Paul Stewart and Maguire... otherwise relatively happy.

now you can pick my sides to pieces, go for broke lads!!!

I stand to be corrected but I read Pearce is still on the Rookie list and is yet to be elevated for 2010.

Clancee Pearce from Freo? really?!?

[Sorry Dude]

ok, i'm not too fussed if people know my side, you can see it after rd1 anyways. my DT is as follows...

Goddard, Enright, Harbrow
Pearce, Malceski, Ladson, Hunt
Ablett (c) Montagna (vc) O'Keefe
Higgins, Robinson, Martin
Tippett, Natanui
Goodes, Giansiracusa, Waite
Hall, Ballantyne, Dangerfield, Campbell

EMER: Waters (def), Barlow (mid) Rockliff (fwd)

Bench:
def- Farmer
mid- Jetta
ruck- Vickery, Warnock
fwd- Taylor

my only questions are Robinson and Waite, not too sure on how they will go. also Troy Taylor and his possible charges... if he gets charged then he won't play for a while, if he plays he looks very exciting...

thoughts?

and my SC is similar, i changed my mind on Gold Coast GAJ...

Goddard, Enright, Pearce
Stewart, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson
Ablett (c) Montagna (vc) Swan
Higgins, Trengove, Martin
Tippett, Natanui
Goodes, Reiwoldt, Giansiracusa,
Hall, Dangerfield, Westoff, Ballantyne

EMER: Waters (def), Barlow (mid) Rockliff (fwd)

Bench:
def- Maguire
mid- Jetta
ruck- Warnock, Grimley
fwd- Peterson

questions only on Paul Stewart and Maguire... otherwise relatively happy.

now you can pick my sides to pieces, go for broke lads!!!

I stand to be corrected but I read Pearce is still on the Rookie list and is yet to be elevated for 2010.

Clancee Pearce from Freo? really?!?

Pearce is still on rookie list as IIRC Barlow was the one who got the nod to the main list.

[whufc]

Yeah im not fussed if people know my teams so here they are

AFL DREAMTEAM

DEF- Goodard, Enright, Gilbee, Mattner, Hurn, Hunt, Waters
MID- Swan, Ablett, Mitchell, Deledio, Kerr, Barlow
RUC- Naitanui, Seaby
FWD- Riewoldt, S.Johnson, Goodes, Franklin, J.Westoff, Hall, Stewart
EME- Nason (def), Banner (mid), Gumbleton (fwd)

BENCH- Trengove(def), M.Wright(mid), R.Stanley (ruck), D.Bass (ruck), J.Podsiadly(fwd)


SUPERCOACH TEAM

DEF- Goodard, Enright, H.Shaw, Hurn, Hunt, Waters, T.Slattery
MID- Ablett, Montagna, Swan, Boyd, Barlow, Jetta
RUC- McIntosh, Tippett
FWD- Goodes, Riewoldt, Lockyer, S.Johnson, Hall, Gumbleton, Stewart
EME- Trengove(def), Banner(mid), Dea(fwd)

BENCH- Nason(def), Trengove(mid), Stanley(ruck), Grimley(ruck), Davis(fwd)

[Alaska]

Yeah im not fussed if people know my teams so here they are

AFL DREAMTEAM

DEF- Goodard, Enright, Gilbee, Mattner, Hurn, Hunt, Waters
MID- Swan, Ablett, Mitchell, Deledio, Kerr, Barlow
RUC- Naitanui, Seaby
FWD- Riewoldt, S.Johnson, Goodes, Franklin, J.Westoff, Hall, Stewart
EME- Nason (def), Banner (mid), Gumbleton (fwd)

BENCH- Trengove(def), M.Wright(mid), R.Stanley (ruck), D.Bass (ruck), J.Podsiadly(fwd)


SUPERCOACH TEAM

DEF- Goodard, Enright, H.Shaw, Hurn, Hunt, Waters, T.Slattery
MID- Ablett, Montagna, Swan, Boyd, Barlow, Jetta
RUC- McIntosh, Tippett
FWD- Goodes, Riewoldt, Lockyer, S.Johnson, Hall, Gumbleton, Stewart
EME- Trengove(def), Banner(mid), Dea(fwd)

BENCH- Nason(def), Trengove(mid), Stanley(ruck), Grimley(ruck), Davis(fwd)

Remember Franklin is suspended for Round 1 and who is Bass? Has not played any trial games, must be a relative!