by Head over it » Thu Apr 14, 2011 1:35 am
by lovetotalkfooty » Thu Apr 14, 2011 8:24 am
Head over it wrote:From the general discussion here is most of the names bandied around by the posters.
I could only have 20 options so have taken off the players from very early on
(Branson, Lovelock, Corbett, Croser) as not many posters would have seen them play and they are all VERY successful in their own right.
Posters can vote up to 15 times but dont have too use all 15 votes if they dont want too.
Just thought it mite be interesting to see if there are any bolters or any names mentioned that really dont deserve to be mentioned in such high regard.
Feel free to mention any other names that spring to mind also.
by pale ale » Sun Apr 17, 2011 1:09 pm
by Head over it » Sun Apr 17, 2011 3:06 pm
pale ale wrote:Interesting that not many people have voted for players like Staker and Hams who were both guns, very tough ask to pick a team from players of the past
by ol man emu » Sun Apr 17, 2011 7:45 pm
by Head over it » Mon Apr 18, 2011 12:30 am
ol man emu wrote:The team has to picked 100% on stats. couldn't do it any other way.
by Head over it » Tue May 17, 2011 3:16 pm
ol man emu wrote:The team has to picked 100% on stats. couldn't do it any other way.
by Look Good In Leather » Thu May 19, 2011 11:30 am
Head over it wrote:ol man emu wrote:The team has to picked 100% on stats. couldn't do it any other way.
I see what your saying ol man emu, and agree. Hears another question then. What stats are more important?
Mail medals aside as they would be the higher individual honour ( although predominantly a midfield medal)
Is it games played / b&f's / SFL representation / premierships / goals kicked for forwards.
Which of these is used and more important when comparing two players?
by a2m » Thu May 19, 2011 3:08 pm
by Head over it » Thu May 19, 2011 8:02 pm
Look Good In Leather wrote:Head over it wrote:ol man emu wrote:The team has to picked 100% on stats. couldn't do it any other way.
I see what your saying ol man emu, and agree. Hears another question then. What stats are more important?
Mail medals aside as they would be the higher individual honour ( although predominantly a midfield medal)
Is it games played / b&f's / SFL representation / premierships / goals kicked for forwards.
Which of these is used and more important when comparing two players?
All of these would be taken into consideration, the hard part is comparing players from different eras - particularly on things like representative football, first 50 years there are not a lot of records, in recent years it has not been as regular as the Lovelock Shield days. Unfortunately a lot of the goalkicking records were lost in 1994.
by Head over it » Sun Jun 19, 2011 9:56 pm
by Head over it » Wed Jun 22, 2011 2:58 pm
Head over it wrote:Well Looks like the voting has come to a stall on 195 votes.
Ive put the results in order below for easy perusal.
Not sure what they mean. Everyones got there opinions I guess, and they are pretty varied.
Only a couple of months until we can see how many on our list get the gig.
How many does everyone think??? I reckon around half (10).
B. Pilmore 11% [ 23 ]
S.Fishlock 9% [ 19 ]
A.Twigden 7% [ 15 ]
G.Gunn 7% [ 14 ]
P.Crate 7% [ 14 ]
M.Jolly 6% [ 13 ]
S.Pollard 6% [ 12 ]
B.Taylor 6% [ 12 ]
S.Talbot 5% [ 11 ]
W.Potter 5% [ 10 ]
J.Vick 5% [ 10 ]
M. Fitzgerald 4% [ 9 ]
J. Ash 4% [ 8 ]
C.Hams 4% [ 8 ]
J. Mott 3% [ 7 ]
K. Nadebaum 3% [ 6 ]
B.Veide 2% [ 5 ]
D.Modra 2% [ 4 ]
D Hibberd 2% [ 4 ]
J.Staker 1% [ 3 ]
by Pommy Git » Wed Jun 22, 2011 3:23 pm
Head over it wrote:Head over it wrote:Well Looks like the voting has come to a stall on 195 votes.
Ive put the results in order below for easy perusal.
Not sure what they mean. Everyones got there opinions I guess, and they are pretty varied.
Only a couple of months until we can see how many on our list get the gig.
How many does everyone think??? I reckon around half (10).
B. Pilmore 11% [ 23 ]
S.Fishlock 9% [ 19 ]
A.Twigden 7% [ 15 ]
G.Gunn 7% [ 14 ]
P.Crate 7% [ 14 ]
M.Jolly 6% [ 13 ]
S.Pollard 6% [ 12 ]
B.Taylor 6% [ 12 ]
S.Talbot 5% [ 11 ]
W.Potter 5% [ 10 ]
J.Vick 5% [ 10 ]
M. Fitzgerald 4% [ 9 ]
J. Ash 4% [ 8 ]
C.Hams 4% [ 8 ]
J. Mott 3% [ 7 ]
K. Nadebaum 3% [ 6 ]
B.Veide 2% [ 5 ]
D.Modra 2% [ 4 ]
D Hibberd 2% [ 4 ]
J.Staker 1% [ 3 ]
noticed that alot of the high vote getters on our list are from Morphies.
Not sure if it shows the quality of the players or the amount of MVFC posters on this site....![]()
.... As I voted for a few of them myself I will give them the benefit of the doubt.
by Head over it » Wed Jun 22, 2011 4:03 pm
Pommy Git wrote:Head over it wrote:Head over it wrote:Well Looks like the voting has come to a stall on 195 votes.
Ive put the results in order below for easy perusal.
Not sure what they mean. Everyones got there opinions I guess, and they are pretty varied.
Only a couple of months until we can see how many on our list get the gig.
How many does everyone think??? I reckon around half (10).
B. Pilmore 11% [ 23 ]
S.Fishlock 9% [ 19 ]
A.Twigden 7% [ 15 ]
G.Gunn 7% [ 14 ]
P.Crate 7% [ 14 ]
M.Jolly 6% [ 13 ]
S.Pollard 6% [ 12 ]
B.Taylor 6% [ 12 ]
S.Talbot 5% [ 11 ]
W.Potter 5% [ 10 ]
J.Vick 5% [ 10 ]
M. Fitzgerald 4% [ 9 ]
J. Ash 4% [ 8 ]
C.Hams 4% [ 8 ]
J. Mott 3% [ 7 ]
K. Nadebaum 3% [ 6 ]
B.Veide 2% [ 5 ]
D.Modra 2% [ 4 ]
D Hibberd 2% [ 4 ]
J.Staker 1% [ 3 ]
noticed that alot of the high vote getters on our list are from Morphies.
Not sure if it shows the quality of the players or the amount of MVFC posters on this site....![]()
.... As I voted for a few of them myself I will give them the benefit of the doubt.
Interesting to see Pollard and Taylor on the same number of votes. Any of you older blokes out there that saw Taylor play? How would you compare them?
by Leo » Thu Jun 23, 2011 11:58 am
Head over it wrote:Pommy Git wrote:Head over it wrote:Head over it wrote:Well Looks like the voting has come to a stall on 195 votes.
Ive put the results in order below for easy perusal.
Not sure what they mean. Everyones got there opinions I guess, and they are pretty varied.
Only a couple of months until we can see how many on our list get the gig.
How many does everyone think??? I reckon around half (10).
B. Pilmore 11% [ 23 ]
S.Fishlock 9% [ 19 ]
A.Twigden 7% [ 15 ]
G.Gunn 7% [ 14 ]
P.Crate 7% [ 14 ]
M.Jolly 6% [ 13 ]
S.Pollard 6% [ 12 ]
B.Taylor 6% [ 12 ]
S.Talbot 5% [ 11 ]
W.Potter 5% [ 10 ]
J.Vick 5% [ 10 ]
M. Fitzgerald 4% [ 9 ]
J. Ash 4% [ 8 ]
C.Hams 4% [ 8 ]
J. Mott 3% [ 7 ]
K. Nadebaum 3% [ 6 ]
B.Veide 2% [ 5 ]
D.Modra 2% [ 4 ]
D Hibberd 2% [ 4 ]
J.Staker 1% [ 3 ]
noticed that alot of the high vote getters on our list are from Morphies.
Not sure if it shows the quality of the players or the amount of MVFC posters on this site....![]()
.... As I voted for a few of them myself I will give them the benefit of the doubt.
Interesting to see Pollard and Taylor on the same number of votes. Any of you older blokes out there that saw Taylor play? How would you compare them?
Was talking to someone from Morphies about this the other day. Keeping opinions aside statistically they are almost identicle (its uncanny really)
Bayden Taylor
4 xPremierships
3 xLeading Goalkickers
3 x100 goal seasons
League record Most goals in a seaon - 156
3-4 time SFL rep
Scott Pollard
5 xPremierships (One as Captain)
3 xLeading Goalkickers
3 x100 goal seasons
League record Most goals in a Match - 27
3-4 time SFL rep
Virtually Impossible to seperate them on stats and obviously playing in different eras very difficult to seperate them on opinion as the game has changed so much in the last 30 years.
Maybe 1 at FF and 1 in FP is the only way to go.... not too many others that match it statistically with these 2.
by Head over it » Thu Jun 23, 2011 1:19 pm
Leo wrote:Head over it wrote:Pommy Git wrote:Head over it wrote:Well Looks like the noticed that alot of the high vote getters on our list are from Morphies.
Not sure if it shows the quality of the players or the amount of MVFC posters on this site....![]()
.... As I voted for a few of them myself I will give them the benefit of the doubt.
Interesting to see Pollard and Taylor on the same number of votes. Any of you older blokes out there that saw Taylor play? How would you compare them?
Was talking to someone from Morphies about this the other day. Keeping opinions aside statistically they are almost identicle (its uncanny really)
Bayden Taylor
4 xPremierships
3 xLeading Goalkickers
3 x100 goal seasons
League record Most goals in a seaon - 156
3-4 time SFL rep
Scott Pollard
5 xPremierships (One as Captain)
3 xLeading Goalkickers
3 x100 goal seasons
League record Most goals in a Match - 27
3-4 time SFL rep
Virtually Impossible to seperate them on stats and obviously playing in different eras very difficult to seperate them on opinion as the game has changed so much in the last 30 years.
Maybe 1 at FF and 1 in FP is the only way to go.... not too many others that match it statistically with these 2.
Certainly some unbelievable stats there from 2 great players. With Graham Gunn's name floating around, is it possible they both might find themselves in a forward pocket?? Wherever they finish, wouldnt you love to see a backline try and stop those three!!
by Leo » Thu Jun 23, 2011 1:38 pm
by Bag The Points » Thu Jun 23, 2011 1:43 pm
by Head over it » Thu Jun 23, 2011 2:09 pm
Bag The Points wrote:Didn't see Graham Gunn play but from what I hear he'd have been more like centre-half-forward. "Bang Bang" was awesome and you'd think he has to go in the side somewhere.
Another name will be right in the mix for the goalfront too ---- Chris Hams.
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |