I'm all for this award its been around for years.
I would think the top finishers would get it nearly all the time but that doesn't seam to be the case. I get that maybe a club who had a lot of teams around the top but not go all the way could be consideration but I'm still a little confused.
Hay league guys! I don't want to spend all my posts bagging you but do you give this job to the umpires to pick as well?
Is this is worked out by personal opinions? If so I think you would have too much personal prejudice to be objective and fair.
How about you explain you formula for calculating this award so we all can understand it.
Then maybe you'll get rid of the controversy and anger and in the process start to regain some respect from all the clubs you represent.