WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

[rodney fox]

You'll never get "The Shrive" back clopsy

i thought shrive went there coz of his mates not cash.

Were loaded at Dingy we pay over and above any offer made by Noarlunga........ Ha ha imagine how broke we would be

Gotta love the cheap shots

You are a bad man Rodney!
I am coming out to watch OUR lads tommorow?

Come on down Shoe Boy we will be happy to accommodate you at Christies...if that makes sense.

Your lads are going great guns, great spirit amongst them. Be sure to have a beer for me when were finished, just look for the lad with a big shark bite out of him

[the big bang]

For Each Team would be:

Aldinga - T.Harman then L.Shrive
Hackham - B.Mosar
OSB Lonsdale - G.Dean then R.Curyer
C/Beach - A.Bachmann then A.Love
Noarlunga - S.Thompson then S.Tasker
F/Hill - D.Kearsley then D.Butcher
Marion - T.Couch then B.Miegel
MV Park - S.Wiese then S.Guilhaus
H/Valley - D.Sugg then S.McKenzie
Porties - T.Tedmanson then M.Skrypek
Brighton - T.Johnstone then B.Brookman
Towns - M.Golding then M.Hiern
Cove - M.Reavill just over J.Vick
M/Vale - J.Sampson then S.Pollard
Reynella - Shane Bradshaw then B.McKeough

not sure how N & B Bayly could make it beyond selection. Not to mention JOSH and POLLY.

[Speccy02]

For Each Team would be:

Aldinga - T.Harman then L.Shrive
Hackham - B.Mosar
OSB Lonsdale - G.Dean then R.Curyer
C/Beach - A.Bachmann then A.Love
Noarlunga - S.Thompson then S.Tasker
F/Hill - D.Kearsley then D.Butcher
Marion - T.Couch then B.Miegel
MV Park - S.Wiese then S.Guilhaus
H/Valley - D.Sugg then S.McKenzie
Porties - T.Tedmanson then M.Skrypek
Brighton - T.Johnstone then B.Brookman
Towns - M.Golding then M.Hiern
Cove - M.Reavill just over J.Vick
M/Vale - J.Sampson then S.Pollard
Reynella - Shane Bradshaw then B.McKeough

not sure how N & B Bayly could make it beyond selection. Not to mention JOSH and POLLY.

Not sure what you mean there Big Bang, What selection are you talking about? Are you suggesting that the bayly boys, joshy or polly arent up too it. or are you just saying that youd have the Bayly boys in first.

[t express]

my opinion lads 1 josh vick
2 shane bradshaw
3 seb guilhas
4 b bayly
5 T johnstone

[cyclops]

1-beeching
2-t.bennets
3-b.bayley
4-n.bayley
5-j.sampson
6-j.farrier
7-j.vick
8-t.johnstone
9-s.bradshaw
10-s.mckenzie

[cyclops]

hopefully next year i will be able to put hodgey and zac ewer in that top 10.

[Kart Horse]

1-beeching
2-t.bennets
3-b.bayley
4-n.bayley
5-j.sampson
6-j.farrier
7-j.vick
8-t.johnstone
9-s.bradshaw
10-s.mckenzie

Which bayley is which? 13 and 3?

[cyclops]

1-beeching
2-t.bennets
3-b.bayley
4-n.bayley
5-j.sampson
6-j.farrier
7-j.vick
8-t.johnstone
9-s.bradshaw
10-s.mckenzie

Which bayley is which? 13 and 3?

braden-13,nathon-3

[Kart Horse]

1-beeching
2-t.bennets
3-b.bayley
4-n.bayley
5-j.sampson
6-j.farrier
7-j.vick
8-t.johnstone
9-s.bradshaw
10-s.mckenzie

Which bayley is which? 13 and 3?

braden-13,nathon-3

Cheers for that! Now knowing which is which

1- Bachmann
2- Beeching
3- M Reavill
4- B Bayley
5- toss up from a large number here on- eg Johnstone, Vick, Bradshaw and so on
Sorry to edwardstown but dont really know enough about u.

Would these little midfielders be as good in weaker sides? Or with weaker ruckmen?
Short, Brookman and beeching are sure to make u look even better.

[Junior]

1-beeching
2-t.bennets
3-b.bayley
4-n.bayley
5-j.sampson
6-j.farrier
7-j.vick
8-t.johnstone
9-s.bradshaw
10-s.mckenzie

Which bayley is which? 13 and 3?

braden-13,nathon-3

Cheers for that! Now knowing which is which

1- Bachmann
2- Beeching
3- M Reavill
4- B Bayley
5- toss up from a large number here on- eg Johnstone, Vick, Bradshaw and so on
Sorry to edwardstown but dont really know enough about u.

Would these little midfielders be as good in weaker sides? Or with weaker ruckmen?
Short, Brookman and beeching are sure to make u look even better.

Interesting point there Kart Horse!
Have to agree but in saying that you would have to also take into consideration the fact that these players play their part for their teams, if they all ran around doing there own thing then i wouldn't think they'd be quiet as successful... Ultimately that is the difference in the stronger and weaker clubs, the top players strive to be even better by training and working hard whereas the less successful clubs have a culture of 'i'm already at my best, why would i need to train' etc etc... Believe me, i see it first hand!

[Kart Horse]

Cheers for that! Now knowing which is which

1- Bachmann
2- Beeching
3- M Reavill
4- B Bayley
5- toss up from a large number here on- eg Johnstone, Vick, Bradshaw and so on
Sorry to edwardstown but dont really know enough about u.

Would these little midfielders be as good in weaker sides? Or with weaker ruckmen?
Short, Brookman and beeching are sure to make u look even better.[/quote]


Interesting point there Kart Horse!
Have to agree but in saying that you would have to also take into consideration the fact that these players play their part for their teams, if they all ran around doing there own thing then i wouldn't think they'd be quiet as successful... Ultimately that is the difference in the stronger and weaker clubs, the top players strive to be even better by training and working hard whereas the less successful clubs have a culture of 'i'm already at my best, why would i need to train' etc etc... Believe me, i see it first hand![/quote]

Yeah i know they would all still be good players but maybe brayden might only get 20 instead of 30 touches without Short or Reid feeding him. Same with johnstone and brookman. With gill out maybe Vick is prooving he is still that good as i dont know their other ruckmen

[cyclops]

Cheers for that! Now knowing which is which

1- Bachmann
2- Beeching
3- M Reavill
4- B Bayley
5- toss up from a large number here on- eg Johnstone, Vick, Bradshaw and so on
Sorry to edwardstown but dont really know enough about u.

Would these little midfielders be as good in weaker sides? Or with weaker ruckmen?
Short, Brookman and beeching are sure to make u look even better.

Interesting point there Kart Horse!
Have to agree but in saying that you would have to also take into consideration the fact that these players play their part for their teams, if they all ran around doing there own thing then i wouldn't think they'd be quiet as successful... Ultimately that is the difference in the stronger and weaker clubs, the top players strive to be even better by training and working hard whereas the less successful clubs have a culture of 'i'm already at my best, why would i need to train' etc etc... Believe me, i see it first hand![/quote]

Yeah i know they would all still be good players but maybe brayden might only get 20 instead of 30 touches without Short or Reid feeding him. Same with johnstone and brookman. With gill out maybe Vick is prooving he is still that good as i dont know their other ruckmen[/quote]
trust me mate u dont wona know there other ruckmen,the bloke is a struggler.

[Down the Hill]

Yes I'm bias but Toddy Johnstone is clearly No. 1 in my book and surely should be top 3 for anyone else on here. If I was a chick I'd have his child. Then again I'm not a chick so I'll settle for a reach around.

Cyclops, who are you kidding with Emu's occupying the top 5. Its a wonder they lose any game with those rankings. And Farrier and Sampson ahead of TJ and Vick. Give me a break. Beeching is no doubt a great player but I have never seen him have a really big one against Brighton so hard to judge him. Bennetts has to strut his stuff consistently for a bit longer before he can be compared with Toddy and Vick. Lets vote again after all the big guns play each other in the final rounds and finals. I think some judgements have been clouded during the mid-year slaughter period.

[Titanic]

Yes I'm bias but Toddy Johnstone is clearly No. 1 in my book and surely should be top 3 for anyone else on here. If I was a chick I'd have his child. Then again I'm not a chick so I'll settle for a reach around.

Cyclops, who are you kidding with Emu's occupying the top 5. Its a wonder they lose any game with those rankings. And Farrier and Sampson ahead of TJ and Vick. Give me a break. Beeching is no doubt a great player but I have never seen him have a really big one against Brighton so hard to judge him. Bennetts has to strut his stuff consistently for a bit longer before he can be compared with Toddy and Vick. Lets vote again after all the big guns play each other in the final rounds and finals. I think some judgements have been clouded during the mid-year slaughter period.

My top 5 are

1/ R.Beeching - Emus -
2/ T.Johnstone - Bombers
3/ S.Mckenzie - Vikings
4/ N.Bayly - Emus
5/ J.Vick - Cove
S.Pollard -Emus
B . Mckeough - wineys - these 2 very stiff - best full forward and half back going around in the comp

I have based this on form over a couple off seasons not just this season as think good players perform season in season out.Alot of good players i have not put in here - C.Smith - Emus N.Manhood - Porties J.Ramsay - CoveB.Brookman - Bombers the list could go on so it really comes down to personal opinion and lets face it we all see the players from our clubs the most.
Beeching as no1 for the reason of bring a genuine match winner
While not

[t express]

Yes I'm bias but Toddy Johnstone is clearly No. 1 in my book and surely should be top 3 for anyone else on here. If I was a chick I'd have his child. Then again I'm not a chick so I'll settle for a reach around.

Cyclops, who are you kidding with Emu's occupying the top 5. Its a wonder they lose any game with those rankings. And Farrier and Sampson ahead of TJ and Vick. Give me a break. Beeching is no doubt a great player but I have never seen him have a really big one against Brighton so hard to judge him. Bennetts has to strut his stuff consistently for a bit longer before he can be compared with Toddy and Vick. Lets vote again after all the big guns play each other in the final rounds and finals. I think some judgements have been clouded during the mid-year slaughter period.

the next 8 weeks will be the time too see these names up against each other,cant wait to watch

[KEYDEFENDER]

Number 1 for me is the new recruit for the Flies.....?.

Then Todd Johnstone (bias)
Vick, Milo, Gaskin (better than Beeching)
Polly is good but has had it good for so long.
Tedmanson probably best contested mark.

[cyclops]

Yes I'm bias but Toddy Johnstone is clearly No. 1 in my book and surely should be top 3 for anyone else on here. If I was a chick I'd have his child. Then again I'm not a chick so I'll settle for a reach around.

Cyclops, who are you kidding with Emu's occupying the top 5. Its a wonder they lose any game with those rankings. And Farrier and Sampson ahead of TJ and Vick. Give me a break. Beeching is no doubt a great player but I have never seen him have a really big one against Brighton so hard to judge him. Bennetts has to strut his stuff consistently for a bit longer before he can be compared with Toddy and Vick. Lets vote again after all the big guns play each other in the final rounds and finals. I think some judgements have been clouded during the mid-year slaughter period.

ok dth yor rite mate i was a tad biased,but not that far away.

[the big bang]

For Each Team would be:

Aldinga - T.Harman then L.Shrive
Hackham - B.Mosar
OSB Lonsdale - G.Dean then R.Curyer
C/Beach - A.Bachmann then A.Love
Noarlunga - S.Thompson then S.Tasker
F/Hill - D.Kearsley then D.Butcher
Marion - T.Couch then B.Miegel
MV Park - S.Wiese then S.Guilhaus
H/Valley - D.Sugg then S.McKenzie
Porties - T.Tedmanson then M.Skrypek
Brighton - T.Johnstone then B.Brookman
Towns - M.Golding then M.Hiern
Cove - M.Reavill just over J.Vick
M/Vale - J.Sampson then S.Pollard
Reynella - Shane Bradshaw then B.McKeough

not sure how N & B Bayly could make it beyond selection. Not to mention JOSH and POLLY.

Not sure what you mean there Big Bang, What selection are you talking about? Are you suggesting that the bayly boys, joshy or polly arent up too it. or are you just saying that youd have the Bayly boys in first.

not too sure what i meant by this post, as i cant remember making it! the 3:11am post time could explain a few things!

but yeh, i would have nath and brayden bayly as the two best emus. pretty tough task though, with beech, polly, sampson, massive......................the list goes on!!!

[Hawk#2]

I wouldn't say B.Mosar for the Hawks i was thinking along the lines of M.Paine

[DILLIGAF]

I wouldn't say B.Mosar for the Hawks i was thinking along the lines of M.Paine

he goes alright imoa was by far the best player against us