SA Footy

WOW what a series this shapes up to be, the Aussies generally match up very well against the Saffers and with a new look Aussie side this is set to be a cracker.

Who will open the batting for Aus, personally i would like to see Warner and Hughes, i dont mind Cowan but find he gets bogged down far to often which puts added pressure on Warner, at least if Hughes bats time he generally scores quickly (even if it is from edges through the slips for four)

Will the Aussies go with the 4 paceman or include the spinner, is Lyon the automatic selection.

At this real early stage this is my 11

1. D.Warner
2. P.Hughes
3. S.Watson
4. R.Ponting
5. M.Clarke
6.?????????
7. M.Wade
8. J.Pattinson
9. P.Cummins
10. M.Starc
11. N.Lyon

whufc wrote:WOW what a series this shapes up to be, the Aussies generally match up very well against the Saffers and with a new look Aussie side this is set to be a cracker.

Who will open the batting for Aus, personally i would like to see Warner and Hughes, i dont mind Cowan but find he gets bogged down far to often which puts added pressure on Warner, at least if Hughes bats time he generally scores quickly (even if it is from edges through the slips for four)

Will the Aussies go with the 4 paceman or include the spinner, is Lyon the automatic selection.

At this real early stage this is my 11

1. D.Warner
2. P.Hughes
3. S.Watson
4. R.Ponting
5. M.Clarke
6.?????????
7. M.Wade
8. J.Pattinson
9. P.Cummins
10. M.Starc
11. N.Lyon

No Hilf or Siddle? just about our two best players last summer

Has our pace bowling depth ever been this good before? Hilf, Siddle, Cummins, Strac, Pattinson, Harris when fit & that other young kid from NSW

cowan should get first chance

1. warner
2. cowan
3. watson
4. ponting
5. clarke
6. m hussey
7. wade
8. siddle
9. pattinson
10. hilfy
11. starc

unlucky: cummins

David Brent wrote:

whufc wrote:WOW what a series this shapes up to be, the Aussies generally match up very well against the Saffers and with a new look Aussie side this is set to be a cracker.

Who will open the batting for Aus, personally i would like to see Warner and Hughes, i dont mind Cowan but find he gets bogged down far to often which puts added pressure on Warner, at least if Hughes bats time he generally scores quickly (even if it is from edges through the slips for four)

Will the Aussies go with the 4 paceman or include the spinner, is Lyon the automatic selection.

At this real early stage this is my 11

1. D.Warner
2. P.Hughes
3. S.Watson
4. R.Ponting
5. M.Clarke
6.?????????
7. M.Wade
8. J.Pattinson
9. P.Cummins
10. M.Starc
11. N.Lyon

No Hilf or Siddle? just about our two best players last summer

Has our pace bowling depth ever been this good before? Hilf, Siddle, Cummins, Strac, Pattinson, Harris when fit & that other young kid from NSW

1. Warner
2. Hughes
3. Watson
4. Clarke
5. Ponting
6. M. Hussey
7. Wade
8. Siddle
9. Cummins/Pattinson
10. Hilfenhaus
11. Lyon

That'd be my lineup at this stage. Pattinson or Cummins would be pretty unlucky to miss out IMO. Where are the young batsmen domestically, knocking down the door?

David Brent wrote:

whufc wrote:WOW what a series this shapes up to be, the Aussies generally match up very well against the Saffers and with a new look Aussie side this is set to be a cracker.

Who will open the batting for Aus, personally i would like to see Warner and Hughes, i dont mind Cowan but find he gets bogged down far to often which puts added pressure on Warner, at least if Hughes bats time he generally scores quickly (even if it is from edges through the slips for four)

Will the Aussies go with the 4 paceman or include the spinner, is Lyon the automatic selection.

At this real early stage this is my 11

1. D.Warner
2. P.Hughes
3. S.Watson
4. R.Ponting
5. M.Clarke
6.?????????
7. M.Wade
8. J.Pattinson
9. P.Cummins
10. M.Starc
11. N.Lyon

No Hilf or Siddle? just about our two best players last summer

Has our pace bowling depth ever been this good before? Hilf, Siddle, Cummins, Strac, Pattinson, Harris when fit & that other young kid from NSW

Oops I forgot about them defiantly have siddle in and more than likely hilf

David Brent wrote:Has our pace bowling depth ever been this good before? Hilf, Siddle, Cummins, Strac, Pattinson, Harris when fit & that other young kid from NSW

Potentially good - none of those have really had more than 1 good year at International level so far...

At this stage you would easily take McGrath, Gillespie, Lee, Fleming, Kasprowicz and Bichel circa 2000 ahead of them.

MAY-Z wrote:cowan should get first chance

1. warner
2. cowan
3. watson
4. ponting
5. clarke
6. m hussey
7. wade
8. siddle
9. pattinson
10. hilfy
11. starc

unlucky: cummins

7 tests for a return of 358 @ 29.83 with a HS of 74, no thanks.

Who cares they will bowl us out for 80.

Squids wrote:Who cares they will bowl us out for 80.

That's the spirit.

Why would no.6 be a ??????

westcoastpanther wrote:Why would no.6 be a ??????

He didn't now how to spell Smith

scoob wrote:

westcoastpanther wrote:Why would no.6 be a ??????

He didn't now how to spell Smith

Don't go there Scoob....

Warner
Cowan
Watson
Ponting
Clarke
Hussey
Siddle
Haddin (sigh)
Starc
Pattinson
Hilfenhaus

With Lyon likely to be dropped from the Redbacks side there is no way that he will be playing Australia. You don't even need a spinner anyway. Pace is our strength so why not utilise it. I can't remember seeing the West Indies employing a spinner very often.

Siddle to bat higher than Haddin is deadly serious. Siddle shows heart while Haddin is a chump. Selectors have made is clear they want him back. Clarkes bum buddy.

Siddle picked for consistency. Pattinson for agression. Hilfenhaus for swing. Starc for left arm swing.

Couldn't think of anyone to replace Cowan with. I would say Hughes but after seeing his SS dismisals I doubt the selectors would be taking the risk.

Having listened to the words from Clarke and Inverarity, Siddle and Hilf will play. With that being said:

1. David Warner (100%)
2. Shane Watson (100%)
3. Ricky Ponting (100%)
4. Michael Clarke (100%)
5. Michael Hussey (100%)
6. David Hussey (50%)
7. Matthew Wade (75%)
8. Peter Siddle (100%)
9. James Pattinson (75%)
10. Ben Hilfenhaus (100%)
11. Patrick Cummins (50%)

I think Starc will likely play over Cummins, although I am not a fan of it. If Watto does not open, then Cowan probably plays, and everyone shuffles down one, except that young debutant, who goes back to the Shield...

David Hussey

Ecky wrote:

David Brent wrote:Has our pace bowling depth ever been this good before? Hilf, Siddle, Cummins, Strac, Pattinson, Harris when fit & that other young kid from NSW

Potentially good - none of those have really had more than 1 good year at International level so far...

At this stage you would easily take McGrath, Gillespie, Lee, Fleming, Kasprowicz and Bichel circa 2000 ahead of them.

That's a good point, McGrath is twice as good as anyone we have now too but on potential this is a quality line up in the future. Could even throw M Johnson in the mix as well if we are getting desperate.

Media Park wrote:Having listened to the words from Clarke and Inverarity, Siddle and Hilf will play. With that being said:

1. David Warner (100%)
2. Shane Watson (100%)
3. Ricky Ponting (100%)
4. Michael Clarke (100%)
5. Michael Hussey (100%)
6. David Hussey (50%)
7. Matthew Wade (75%)
8. Peter Siddle (100%)
9. James Pattinson (75%)
10. Ben Hilfenhaus (100%)
11. Patrick Cummins (50%)

I think Starc will likely play over Cummins, although I am not a fan of it. If Watto does not open, then Cowan probably plays, and everyone shuffles down one, except that young debutant, who goes back to the Shield...

If they play 4 quicks Starc will play due to being a left hand bowler but do we need 4 quicks plus Watson in the team? I would play Lyon at the Gabba but 4 quicks maybe at the WACA.

Ponting will not go back to three

1. Warner
2. Cowan
3. Watson
4. Ponting
5. Clarke
6. M Hussey
7. Wade
8. Siddle
9. Pattinson
10.Hilfenhaus
11. Lyon
12th Starc

I reckon it's all over for Haddin and that the Cowan/Warner partnership will remain. Hughes feeds catches to the slips and the gully so won't play against the Saffers' pace attack on our bouncy decks. I think they'll pick Lyon for Brisbane for the variation and use Watson as the fourth seamer which means he will not open the batting. If Lyon does miss due to the conditions then I reckon Starc is the fourth seamer.

regards,

REB

whufc wrote:WOW what a series this shapes up to be, the Aussies generally match up very well against the Saffers and with a new look Aussie side this is set to be a cracker.

Who will open the batting for Aus, personally i would like to see Warner and Hughes, i dont mind Cowan but find he gets bogged down far to often which puts added pressure on Warner, at least if Hughes bats time he generally scores quickly (even if it is from edges through the slips for four)

Will the Aussies go with the 4 paceman or include the spinner, is Lyon the automatic selection.

At this real early stage this is my 11

1. D.Warner
2. P.Hughes
3. S.Watson
4. R.Ponting
5. M.Clarke
6.?????????
7. M.Wade
8. J.Pattinson
9. P.Cummins
10. M.Starc
11. N.Lyon

Why would you leave out Siddle who has a hat trick to his name at the Gabba and Hilf who hits the seam more than most? Add to that you've selected Hughes who is a walking wicket once the ball gets between his hips and his neck.

regards,

REB