Page 1 of 2
Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 8:38 amby Booney
With so much criticism of the current Australian squad I thought it was worth the punters in here picking our current second XI.
Now, we might not all agree with the first XI I have listed, but lets use it as a template.These guys in our best XI and our probable first Test line up.
Watson
Katich
Ponting
Clark
Hussey
North
Haddin
Hauritz
Johnson
Hilfenhaus
Siddle.
If we use that as our basis for the first XI - Now go and select your second XI, might not be a very strong side at the moment.
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:19 amby Booney
Nobody willing to pick a second XI?
Might be a reflection of how hard the current job the selectors have....
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:29 amby Hondo
I am not as expert on the state players as others on here but I'll have a go ...
Watson JACQUES
Katich HUGHES
Ponting KLINGER
Clark KHAWAJA
Hussey FERGUSON
North MACDONALD / SMITH / WHITE
Haddin PAINE
Hauritz DOHERTY
Johnson McKAY
Hilfenhaus BOLLINGER
Siddle. GEORGE
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:32 amby Lightning McQueen
Booney wrote:With so much criticism of the current Australian squad I thought it was worth the punters in here picking our current second XI.
Now, we might not all agree with the first XI I have listed, but lets use it as a template.These guys in our best XI and our probable first Test line up.
Watson Hughes
Katich S.Marsh
Ponting Khawaja
Clark Ferguson
Hussey White
North McDonald
Haddin Paine
Hauritz Smith/ Doherty
Johnson Harris
Hilfenhaus Bollinger
Siddle George
If we use that as our basis for the first XI - Now go and select your second XI, might not be a very strong side at the moment.
I'm only going on this season's form, although White can't come into consideration but I think he deserves a look at along with the injured test players like Harris and Bollinger.
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:33 amby Lightning McQueen
Hondo wrote:I am not as expert on the state players as others on here but I'll have a go ...
Watson JACQUES
Katich HUGHES
Ponting KLINGER
Clark KHAWAJA
Hussey FERGUSON
North MACDONALD / SMITH / WHITE
Haddin PAINE
Hauritz DOHERTY
Johnson McKAY
Hilfenhaus BOLLINGER
Siddle. GEORGE
Nearly snap.
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:55 amby CoverKing
Jacques
Hughes
Khawaja
Ferguson
White (c)
Smith
Paine
McDonald
Harris
George
Bollinger
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:20 amby Killa
Jacques
Hughes
Khawaja
Ferguson
White
Smith
Paine
Doherty
Starc
George
Bollinger
12 Man Bailey
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:24 amby Hondo
It's interesting that we aren't including Krejza. He's the popular name that comes up when Hauritz is getting bagged. But with Doherty now playing for Tasmania has Krejza fallen away or is he injured?
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:33 amby CoverKing
Krejza is just poo IMO.
And Starc in the second 11, I know it's your opinion but seriously
I would be pretty suprised if he even makes NSWs shield side on Wednesday!
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:51 amby Killa
CoverKing wrote:Krejza is just poo IMO.
And
Starc in the second 11, I know it's your opinion but seriously I would be pretty suprised if he even makes NSWs shield side on Wednesday!
Its about development. Australia A should go back when all players were under 25. In the game they had clarke, white, haddin, cleary, north, tait, cosgrove, doherty and etc. Australia had used these games as development team in tour games now these games can not be seen to lack of tour matches. I would look at starc for the first test of bollinger is strugling as his height and pace would be handy on a GABBA pitch.
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 12:35 pmby CoverKing
Killa wrote:CoverKing wrote:Krejza is just poo IMO.
And
Starc in the second 11, I know it's your opinion but seriously I would be pretty suprised if he even makes NSWs shield side on Wednesday!
Its about development. Australia A should go back when all players were under 25. In the game they had clarke, white, haddin, cleary, north, tait, cosgrove, doherty and etc. Australia had used these games as development team in tour games now these games can not be seen to lack of tour matches. I would look at starc for the first test of bollinger is strugling as his height and pace would be handy on a GABBA pitch.
I dont think Booney was talking about the side being a developing side. Its about the second best 11 in the country. Starc having played 10 games with only 25 wickets at 35 does not put him in a second best australian side. Mark Cameron would be ahead of him with 11 matches and 45 wickets at 27.
I understand he is promising and a future star, but to even consider him in your second best side in the 4 day game is outrageous
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 12:38 pmby Rik E Boy
Booney wrote:Nobody willing to pick a second XI?
Might be a reflection of how hard the current job the selectors have....
Hughes
Jaques
Kahawja
Ferg
Rohrer
White
Paine
Smith
Siddle
Harris
Cameron
12th - George
If Bollinger plays surely Siddle is Second XI. If Siddle 'goes up' then George. I'd have Cameron up (to Aussie A status) ASAP.
regards,
REB
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 12:39 pmby Rik E Boy
CoverKing wrote:Krejza is just poo IMO.
And Starc in the second 11, I know it's your opinion but seriously
I would be pretty suprised if he even makes NSWs shield side on Wednesday!
Surely he's a chance there. We are going OK if he can't. We've had Forrest bowling in recent matches although Gumpy would be a much better bat than Starc.
regards,
REB
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 1:21 pmby CoverKing
Starc does average 25 in his minimal games in FC cricket!
The shield game your mob would have Bollinger (is he fit), Clark, Cameron and Copeland all ahead of Starc IMO
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 1:25 pmby Killa
CoverKing wrote:Killa wrote:CoverKing wrote:Krejza is just poo IMO.
And
Starc in the second 11, I know it's your opinion but seriously I would be pretty suprised if he even makes NSWs shield side on Wednesday!
Its about development. Australia A should go back when all players were under 25. In the game they had clarke, white, haddin, cleary, north, tait, cosgrove, doherty and etc. Australia had used these games as development team in tour games now these games can not be seen to lack of tour matches. I would look at starc for the first test of bollinger is strugling as his height and pace would be handy on a GABBA pitch.
I dont think Booney was talking about the side being a developing side. Its about the second best 11 in the country. Starc having played 10 games with only 25 wickets at 35 does not put him in a second best australian side. Mark Cameron would be ahead of him with 11 matches and 45 wickets at 27.
I understand he is promising and a future star, but to even consider him in your second best side in the 4 day game is outrageous
I was talking about it shouldn't be the best second 11 but who is most likely to play test cricket within the next couple of years. Adding couple of players to look at and see where they are at like white, doherty and jacques
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 1:38 pmby Rik E Boy
CoverKing wrote:Starc does average 25 in his minimal games in FC cricket!
The shield game your mob would have Bollinger (is he fit), Clark, Cameron and Copeland all ahead of Starc IMO
Don't know much about Copeland. Hope Bollinger is OK because Siddle is Bichel lite.
regards,
REB
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 1:41 pmby CoverKing
Guess we will have to wait to Wednesday but Copeland ahead of Starc IMO!
Will NSW will play four quicks and Smith? Or 3 quicks and 2 of smith/hauritz/okeefe? Try picking their best side!
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 2:10 pmby smithy
CoverKing wrote:Guess we will have to wait to Wednesday but Copeland ahead of Starc IMO!
Will NSW will play four quicks and Smith? Or 3 quicks and 2 of smith/hauritz/okeefe? Try picking their best side!
Is Hauritz even in NSW best XI ?
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 2:20 pmby Rik E Boy
CoverKing wrote:Guess we will have to wait to Wednesday but Copeland ahead of Starc IMO!
Will NSW will play four quicks and Smith? Or 3 quicks and 2 of smith/hauritz/okeefe? Try picking their best side!
As long as it is available for when we play the Vics for a change.
regards,
REB
Re: Pick your second XI
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:11 pmby brod
Hughes
Jaques
Khawaja
Ferguson
White (C)
Smith
Paine
Cutting/Harris (if either can get fit)
Cameron
Bollinger
George
(Pretty long tail
)