SA Footy

Okay peoples i think it is fair to say we have lost the Ashes, Haddin and Hussey at the crease with 300 still to get.

What side would you pick for the first test on Aussie soil this summer

This is mine.

P Hughes
S Katich
R Ponting (c)
M Clarke
S Watson
M North
B Haddin
M Johnson
P Siddle
D Bollinger
B Hilfenhaus

Pick mine to pieces and show me your side Mr Selector .

Hughes
Katich
Ponting
North
Clarke (c)
Watson (would have hussey here if he gets us home in this test against the poms)
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

12th: Clark
13th: Ferguson

CoverKing wrote:Hughes
Katich
Ponting
North
Clarke (c)
Watson (would have hussey here if he gets us home in this test against the poms)
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

I agree aside from possibly including Hussey, unfortunate but we're playing the West Indies & Pakistan this summer so need to start moving on from the old blokes which should also mean this should be the end of Stuart Clark and Brett Lee's Test careers also and no way in the world is Michael Clarke ready for the captaincy.

Watson
Katich (vc)
Ponting
Clarke (c)
Hussey
North
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

Head Coach - T.Moody
Selectors - S.Waugh, J.Gillespie, M.Hayden, S.Warne, S.Young

The Cadet wrote:Watson
Katich (vc)
Ponting
Clarke (c)
Hussey
North
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

Head Coach - T.Moody
Selectors - S.Waugh, J.Gillespie, M.Hayden, S.Warne, S.Young

I would agree with your team there mate. You would have to say Watson has earnt that spot after the last 2 tests. He has batted well. Although he has not gone on to get that big score he has done well getting a few 50's.

Still I would like to add the option of have S.Clark playing instead of Hauritz. The off spinner would probably only be chosen to play say in Adelaide or Sydney.

The Cadet wrote:Watson
Katich (vc)
Ponting
Clarke (c)
Hussey
North
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

Head Coach - T.Moody
Selectors - S.Waugh, J.Gillespie, M.Hayden, S.Warne, S.Young

Why would you have Katich as vice captain, don't you think age is getting the better of him, he could still be called upon for guidance without the title, vice captains are usually captains in waiting.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

The Cadet wrote:Watson
Katich (vc)
Ponting
Clarke (c)
Hussey
North
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

Head Coach - T.Moody
Selectors - S.Waugh, J.Gillespie, M.Hayden, S.Warne, S.Young

Why would you have Katich as vice captain, don't you think age is getting the better of him, he could still be called upon for guidance without the title, vice captains are usually captains in waiting.

And a change of coach and every single selector? That's a massive change to a team structure, you would be dooming players to second guessing their spots and learning new processes instead of playing cricket. Great idea.

The Cadet wrote:Watson
Katich (vc)
Ponting
Clarke (c)
Hussey
North
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

Head Coach - T.Moody
Selectors - S.Waugh, J.Gillespie, M.Hayden, S.Warne, S.Young

S.Young?? Wow that's left field. What about we throw in Harry Frei too..

wycbloods wrote:Okay peoples i think it is fair to say we have lost the Ashes, Haddin and Hussey at the crease with 300 still to get.

What side would you pick for the first test on Aussie soil this summer

This is mine.

P Hughes
S Katich
R Ponting (c)
M Clarke
S Watson
M North
B Haddin
M Johnson
P Siddle
D Bollinger
B Hilfenhaus

Pick mine to pieces and show me your side Mr Selector .

i like this side,my only change would be krezja for one of the quicks.i really hope the selectors havnt forgotten this bloke.

smac wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

The Cadet wrote:Watson
Katich (vc)
Ponting
Clarke (c)
Hussey
North
Haddin
Johnson
Hauritz
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

Head Coach - T.Moody
Selectors - S.Waugh, J.Gillespie, M.Hayden, S.Warne, S.Young

Why would you have Katich as vice captain, don't you think age is getting the better of him, he could still be called upon for guidance without the title, vice captains are usually captains in waiting.

And a change of coach and every single selector? That's a massive change to a team structure, you would be dooming players to second guessing their spots and learning new processes instead of playing cricket. Great idea.

If New Zealand lose the next Test against Sri Lanka our test ranking will drop to 4, thats the worst it has been for 15 years. We have lost 3 of our last 5 Test series. The selectors have been a disgrace for along time now, Ponting as catain has been found out every time there is a bit of pressure on and has crumbeld as a captain. Englands team was one of there worst for some time, so how come they beat us.

If we change everything at once, we will never know.

cyclops wrote:

wycbloods wrote:Okay peoples i think it is fair to say we have lost the Ashes, Haddin and Hussey at the crease with 300 still to get.

What side would you pick for the first test on Aussie soil this summer

This is mine.

P Hughes
S Katich
R Ponting (c)
M Clarke
S Watson
M North
B Haddin
M Johnson
P Siddle
D Bollinger
B Hilfenhaus

Pick mine to pieces and show me your side Mr Selector .

i like this side,my only change would be krezja for one of the quicks.i really hope the selectors havnt forgotten this bloke.

Krejza and Hauritz would come into consideration for Adelaide and Sydney but i guess the first test would be at the Gabba so i wouldn't play a spinner.

Krejza and Hauritz would come into consideration for Adelaide and Sydney but i guess the first test would be at the Gabba so i wouldn't play a spinner.[/quote]

dis-agree,shane warne has taken wickets there,the only way a spinner is gona get better is if we play them.gotta blood more time into krejza,he showed us sumfn against the indians,we need to persist for a while,imo could be a match winner.

cyclops wrote:Krejza and Hauritz would come into consideration for Adelaide and Sydney but i guess the first test would be at the Gabba so i wouldn't play a spinner.

dis-agree,shane warne has taken wickets there,the only way a spinner is gona get better is if we play them.gotta blood more time into krejza,he showed us sumfn against the indians,we need to persist for a while,imo could be a match winner.[/quote]

Yep Shane Warne did but not many others. Neither Hauritz or Krejza are Shane Warne.

I think 4 quicks would be the best fit for the Gabba, we need to pick the four best bowlers for the conditions and if that means no spinner then so be it. North has showed he is handy enough to get some overs out of.

was shane warne that good after only a couple of mathes-no he wasnt,gee i new sum1 would say that.fact is we need a quality spinner and they need to adress this,hauritz is not the solution.

cyclops wrote:was shane warne that good after only a couple of mathes-no he wasnt,gee i new sum1 would say that.fact is we need a quality spinner and they need to adress this,hauritz is not the solution.

He may not have been but he was no where near as experienced at first class level as Hauritz and Krejza are.

We do need a quality spinner no doubt but there isn't one playing First Class cricket atm. Hopefully he comes along soon.

The spinning spot was always going to be a major issue once Warne gave it away. We can't expect to see another Warne IN OUR LIFETIME. But right now I reckon we aren't even getting a Dutchy Holland, Tim May or Ashley Mallett. We'd settle for a Greg Matthews or Ray Bright. The current crop are a disaster. I thought young kids were lining up in the nets at every club trying to bowl spin in the last ten years?

regards,

REB

Watson
Katich
Ponting C
Clarke
Hussey
North
Haddin
Johnson
Holland/ smith
Siddle
Hilfenhaus

12th: McKay
13th: Hughes

selectors cox, hildritch sacked boof and steve waugh in

sum1 tell me wot is the problem with krejza?

do not rate him not enough variation and it is the same as hauritz