SA Footy

Seeing this crap makes me wonder Who is really the biggest dud to play cricket for Australia in any form of the game??
Give a reason and you CAN'T steal anyone elses answer.....

Ian Harvey, 17 with the bat, 30 with the pill (Economy of 4.7)

This guy was loved by the media,he was s**t!!

Hauritz...does absolutely nothing. For some reason they put him in when we need to contain the opposition and they spank 20 from the over. He was 12th man for NSW in Dec when he was called up for the Adelaide test. He was supposed to be mixing drinks for a state side and got called up for NATIONAL duty...how the hell does that work?

Mick Lewis 0/113 from 10 in his last ODI appearance (where SAf chased down 434)

Interceptor wrote:Mick Lewis 0/113 from 10 in his last ODI appearance (where SAf chased down 434)

Good call, also won us a 1 dayer in NZ.

LaughingKookaburra wrote:Ian Harvey, 17 with the bat, 30 with the pill (Economy of 4.7)

This guy was loved by the media,he was s**t!!

I quite liked Harvey. Good bowler from what i remember. Had a good slower ball. Alot of Variation

Brad Williams is a guy who comes to mind. Burst onto the international scene, then quickly disappeared. Not even playing State Cricket now due to numerous indescretions.

Pidge wrote:

LaughingKookaburra wrote:Ian Harvey, 17 with the bat, 30 with the pill (Economy of 4.7)

This guy was loved by the media,he was s**t!!

I quite liked Harvey. Good bowler from what i remember. Had a good slower ball. Alot of Variation

Good bowler with an average of 30 and an economy of 4.7 in an era where 250 was a good target to defend......Dud, very overated.

LaughingKookaburra wrote:

Pidge wrote:

LaughingKookaburra wrote:Ian Harvey, 17 with the bat, 30 with the pill (Economy of 4.7)

This guy was loved by the media,he was s**t!!

I quite liked Harvey. Good bowler from what i remember. Had a good slower ball. Alot of Variation

Good bowler with an average of 30 and an economy of 4.7 in an era where 250 was a good target to defend......Dud, very overated.

Going to have to agree to disagree on this one

Chris Matthews who couldn't hit the Gabba pitch on his lamentable test debut.

regards,

REB

Cameron White.

Serious Question.

Is this a biggest 'dud' thread? of which any person who has played for Australia is not. Or a thread to state the player you dislike the most or who has performed poorly at international level, which IMO doesn't make them a dud.

Well it's all relative bloods. It's the same for AFL dudness.

regards,

REB

Rik E Boy wrote:Well it's all relative bloods. It's the same for AFL dudness.

regards,

REB

I think it is easier to get a kick in the AFL than play a game of cricket for Australia, which is why so many kids choose this option. Good athletes get a game of footy, they don't get a game of cricket.

What are ya, a copper or something?? Lighten up mate,were not personally attacking them. I just sat back last night watched the 1 dayer and shook my head and this idea popped up.

Nah i just find it funny people sit behind a computer screen and call someone who has/is playing for their country a dud. I can understand people having an opinion that they are not good enough to be playing for Austalia but to call them a dud is poor form IMHO.

wycbloods wrote:

Rik E Boy wrote:Well it's all relative bloods. It's the same for AFL dudness.

regards,

REB

I think it is easier to get a kick in the AFL than play a game of cricket for Australia, which is why so many kids choose this option. Good athletes get a game of footy, they don't get a game of cricket.

Of course it's easier to get a game of AFL. Theres only 4-5 (maximum) states that AFL is a preference for and theres 16 (soon to be 17) teams with 40+ on each list. Seeing that is the highest standard in the country and seeing how many people play cricket for Australia each year thats a pointless argument.

I was just responding to REB's statement about the similarity to the AFL

Dan Cullen
Scott Muller

i can't split them.

I reckon a few of you Mexicans are starting to feel the heat.

regards,

REB